Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Digital photo woes...

Posts

Digital photo woes...

#1

Digital photo woes...

Steve Russell

>Hello to the group,

I'm curious what anyone with a website is doing to setup for digital photos that they post on the web? Are you shooting at a low resolution like 1 MP and then optimizing for the web at 72-dpi, or are you shooting at a high resolution like 8 MP and then optimizing for the web?

I have four digital cameras, a 1MP unit, a 7 MP unit and an 8.3 MP unit, plus the still images from the video camera. When I shoot at 8.3 MP and convert it to a .jpg and then optimize it for the web, there are too many artifacts, especially on photos that have text.

Is it better to shoot at the lowest resolution you can, or the highest before you convert to .jpg and then run it through a web optimizer? I'm using Photoshop and I also have Photoshop elements. It seems like every photo is different and needs lots of tweaking with the quality to get it down low enough for a web page.

I'm trying to keep my photos around 10K or less if possible (for the web pages and my blog pages), but that won't work with text in the photo sometimes, like the label on a can of finish for example. So, what is anyone else doing? What is your specific shooting and optimizing protocol? Thanks for any assistance and best wishes to you and yours!

P.S. I sure wish John Lucas lived next door... :-) Hehehehe!

Steve Russell

Eurowood Werks Woodturning Studio

The Woodlands, Texas

Machinery, Tool and Product Testing for the Woodworking and Woodturning Industries

Re: Digital photo woes...

#2

Re: Digital photo woes...

Bob Fawcett

>Steve,

I am no expert, see the thread below, but I did a lot of experimenting yesterday. I shoot with a 4MP camera. I usually crop the photo first, then resize it to fit a computer screen. WC advises no more than 500 pixels in the longest direction. Last I "save as" and set the jpeg compression. This is were the compression comes in. WC limits is 40K. When I saved to a file size of 11-15k I got lots of artifacts. If I saved to around 30k I got a nice picture. Best to experiment. I would save after the crop and resize, then experiment with saves to get the size and resolution you want.

Re: Digital photo woes...

#3

Re: Digital photo woes...

john lucas

>Steve the computer end is where I know almost nothing. My specialty is lighting and camera's. I can barely turn on that strange beast called a computer. I shoot a 6 meg camera and they come from the camera as JPG's. Unless I need to modify them a lot I leave them as jpg's. If I have to do very much I convert them to TIFF's and do all my work in that mode. My boss says it doesn't do any compression when working on TIFFs. Everytime you do anyting to a JPG in compresses the file. After you've changed the contrast, played with levels, tweaked the color, cropped, retouched some dust, etc you've compressed the heck out of the file and it will do all sorts of things to the image.

When I'm done playing I size them to 600 Pixels in the long dimension and 300 dpi. Then I do a Save for Web which converts it to 72 DPI. I don't know why they look better when I do this instead of just converting them to 72 when I'm sizing it but they do.

I don't have a website and no absolutely nothing about sizing for that purpose so I can't help you there.

Re: Digital photo woes...

#4

Re: Digital photo woes...

Carole Valentine

>Steve, in Photoshop (I use version 8) do you use the "Save for web" option? I generally shoot at high res, crop, do whatever tweaking I need to for levels, color balance, etc. I then save a copy in .psd or .tif format (less lossy than jpg) for future use. Then under the save for web, dialog, I set the image size to whatever I want, then hit the little drop down arrow up next to "presets" and click "optimize to file size." Enter your desired file size and hit OK. Under the tabs for viewing choose "2 Up" and you can see the original alongside the optimized one. Save it as a jpg and you are good to go.

Re: Digital photo woes...

#5

Re: Digital photo woes...

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Steve, I try to keep the process simple, with as few steps as possible.

To begin with, I go for the highest quality image possible from the camera, in case I want to print it. I tuck the original image file in a safe place, and always edit a copy using the Gimp which is very similar to Photoshop.

First, I crop if needed, then scale the image down to final size and on the first Save, I can adjust the compression quality. If I need to do that again to reduce the file size, I'll do a "Save As" with that file, and overwrite (replace) it, or start over with a new copy and choose a lower quality value (higher compression). It is better to do all editing in one session if possible, see further below.

10 kb file size may be about right for a small jpg of probably 300 pixels in the largest dimension with fairly good quality. It's not too difficult to get an 800 x 600 jpg down to 40-50 kb with decent quality but it's important to do it in as few steps as possible as the jpg format is "lossy" meaning the quality is degraded a bit at each edit.

Because of that, I do try to get a nice image from the camera and avoid as much editing as possible, such as contrast/brightness adjustments.

Re: Digital photo woes...

#6

Re:Carole has the right stuff! Shoot at ...

Jamie Donaldson

>.. a large JPG and download to the computer. When you want to manipulate an image,make a copy and never work on the original. Make the changes you want as a PSD format in Photoshop, and save the size changes for last.

Re: Digital photo woes...

#7

Re: Digital photo woes...

Steve Russell

>Hello Bob,

Thanks for your help on this... I guess I need to do more editing in a non-lossy format first and then switch to .jpg. Geez, I thought learning HTML, Flash and Dreamweaver was tough... :-o Thanks again and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

Eurowood Werks Woodturning Studio

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: Digital photo woes...

#8

Re: Digital photo woes...

Steve Russell

>John,

Thanks for your help anyway. You have helped me quite a lot over the years and I appreciate your kindness. Don't worry, I knew nothing about a website until a few months ago and I'm learning something new everyday. Take care and best wishes to you and yours!

Steve Russell

Eurowood Werks Woodturning Studio

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: Digital photo woes...

#9

Re: Digital photo woes...

Steve Russell

>Hello Carole,

Thanks for the Photoshop specific info. I have used PS Elements a little bit and just recently got the full blown version. Whilst trying to learn Photoshop, I've been learning all about HTML, Flash, Dreamweaver and RSS... Whew! My head is spinning. :-o

I will give your protocol a go tonight and let you know. I've just learned about layers in PS, that was way cool!!! Lots more fun than chainsawing... :-) Take care and best wishes to you in all of your woodturning endeavors!

Steve Russell

Eurowood Werks Woodturning Studio

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: Digital photo woes...

#10

Re: Digital photo woes...

Steve Russell

>Hello Ken,

Thanks for your assistance! I think I have been saving too often with my .jpg's, so I will monitor that better in the future. I love the flexibility of digital, but it requires a entirely new set of skills to get optimum results. It's a good thing I don't sleep much... Thanks again and good luck to you!

Steve Russell

Eurowood Werks Woodturning Studio

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: Digital photo woes...

#11

Re: Digital photo woes... *LINK*

nailshooter

>Hello Steve. I posted a more detailed response, but it got lost in cyberspace. I do a lot of consulting reports and inspections, and to keep the .pdf sizes of my reports manageable I have to keep the pics smaller. And for my inspections, nothing is more annoying than to look at a picture that shows the front of a house, and due to its size (affecting the viewing aspect) you only see the door knob.

So, over the years I have developed this technique, not based in science, but experience. I take a full sized pic for archives and details. These are usually burned onto a CD and used as needed later as they are in the 2mb - 4mb. For reports, emails, etc., if my target size is about 60kb or so, I take a picture that is roughly 5 or 6 times the size I need, or about 300kb to 360kb. I find that I have plenty of room fully edit the picure and retain enough of it to suit my purpose.

The larger pictures work better for hard printing, should that need arise. But the smaller pictures work better when it is time to "compress" the image. Photo compression is nothing more than losing some of non-critical data in a picture. So when you compress, proportionally, it makes a better picture to compress 350kb to 60kb as opposed to 3mb to 60kb. You compress large pictures so much that they will go out of focus, lose details, change colors (hues) and start generating artifacts when you compress too much.

I use Elements when I have to repair a picture, but for a quick, full featured editor for 95% of what I do I use Xnview. The depth of his program is amazing, and it gives you a wide array of formats, compression protocols, sizing and dimension methods, etc. It also allows for a wide array of plug ins, of which there are some really handy ones. For me it is much faster than Elements, and more full-featured than Irfanview which is a favorite around here. Like Irfanview, it is freeware.

I provided a link below. Hope this helps.

Robert


http://tinyurl.com/rm9yw

Re: Digital photo woes...

#12

Re: Digital photo woes...

Steve Russell

>Hello Robert,

Thanks for the info... I sorta thought that taking a smaller photo and compressing that would be better than taking a large photo and trying to get it down far enough to fit your needs. Like you said, it starts getting fuzzy and those nasty artifacts start showing up. I'm going to take a few test shots at various resolutions and see which looks better when compressed. Unfortunately, the lowest I can shoot on my digital cameras is 1 MB, but that's a lot smaller than 8.3 MB. Thanks again and best wishes to you and yours!

Steve Russell

Eurowood Werks Woodturning Studio

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: Digital photo woes...

#13

Re: Digital photo woes...

Ed in Leaside (Toronto, Ontario)

>Hi Steve,

You mentioned in the Aftermath thread that "... I had some trouble with the Prince William Sound photo getting it less than 80K for WC's upload. It did not come out too clear, sorta fuzzy in the edge detail. Still trying to master Photoshop!!! :-o"

Did you run the image through Filter>Sharpen>Unsharp Mask? This will usually resolve most fuzzy edge problems. But don't over do it.

Ed, using Photoshop since Version 3 IIRC. ;-)

Re: Digital photo woes...

#14

Re: Digital photo woes...

Steve Russell

>Hello Ed,

Thanks for the tip. I did not use the unsharp mask on the photo... Most of the fiddling was done with .jpg compression settings. I have tried to use the sharpen feature before on some other photos, but did not find it useful. I will try unsharp this time and see if that helps. I need to get a tutorial on Photoshop that walks you through all of the features. There is one on DVD that has gotten high marks that I'm going to try. Thanks again and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

Eurowood Werks Woodturning Studio

The Woodlands, Texas