Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Failed and Typical Base

Posts

Failed and Typical Base

#1

Failed and Typical Base

JohnDillbeck

>This is a pic of the failed joint. The more I look at it the more I think it was wet wood and not a single piece. The second pic is a typicalwhich I use 4 pieces. My opinion is that a single piece is worst case and the stresses diminish as the number of pieces increase,i.e. best case being the number of pieces in the ring. Can't get the second pic in the message.


img

Re: Failed and Typical Base

#2

Re: Failed and Typical Base

Bill Youngblood

>Hi John,

Glad to see a segmenter for a change. Not that there is anything wrong with other types of work.

My best guess is also wet wood. What is the diameter of the base piece? I rarely go more than 3". Usually 2 to 2 1/2" and haven't had one come apart yet. Of course now they probably will. This looks like Black Cherry which is notorious for schrinking if it is the least bit wet. Hope this helps.

Bill

Re: Failed and Typical Base

#3

ebd

Re: Failed and Typical Base

ebd

>From your picture it looks like you are using a solid piece to "plug a hole" in the segments (for want of a better way to describe what I think I'm seeing). If not, please disregard what follows.

IMO this is never a good idea. It's much too hard to get a perfect fit and any change in humidity will affect the joint. Also, end grain to end grain joints are the weakest providing a failure prone point somewhere along the circumference of the solid piece.

A much better way is to make the bottom as wide as or only slightly narrower than the 1st course of segments (which becomes the 2nd course of the piece). This gives a good face grain to face grain glue joint that will not pull apart. I also prefer to use a solid final course when possible to anchor the last course of segments.

A simplified example of what I'm talking about is below. It only has a single segmented ring with a solid top and bottom (2 solid pieces above and below). I've kept pieces glued up this way in my unheated shop for 10 years without failure of any joints. Winter temperatures get below zero and in the matter of a few hours will come up to 70 (extremely dry) when I fire up the woodstove. In summer it can get close to 100 with very high humidity. Pretty harsh conditions but no failures or "glue creep".


img