Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

I got a little carried away.

Posts

I got a little carried away.

#1

I got a little carried away.

Bob Way, Canton, MI

>It really was just going to be a day of some playing around and experimenting. Actually, it�s Carole Valentine�s fault. Before the first of the year she posted about mastering the use of a ring tool. Some of her determination rubbed off on me to do the same with a Termite tool I had, but never tried. A free Saturday and a piece of left over walnut seemed to be the perfect opportunity.

It went far better than I expected. Then one thing led to another, and what I ended up with were a bunch of �firsts� for me. I dragged out a drawing of an idea I had done with other materials and a different scale in mind. My lid turning needed a little tweaking. It�s not a suction pop, turner�s lid, but it fits just about dead on without any sliding around in the opening. First lid I�ve done that I really like the fit. Next, something to lift it with seemed fitting. So, first finial I�ve ever turned. Well, second one. I did the first to shape, then thought I�d try another with a little embellishment. The rest was done to finish prototyping the drawing for evaluation purposes.

Anyhow, my little trial and error efforts ended up with this piece. It is walnut and hard maple, 3� wide by 6 �� high overall. Finish is one coat too many lacquer.

I am a new product development guy by day. For every successful idea I�ve ever aired there are far, far more unsuccessful ones. So, I would appreciate your thoughts and comments, and I hope you will appreciate that I will not be offended, nor put on the defensive, by them. It�s a continuous improvement thing I�m working on.

I do enjoy this forum.

Bob Way


img

Re: I got a little carried away.

#2

Re: I got a little carried away.

David Walser

>I really like it! I think the finial ties nicely to your two piece foot. Can you post a picture with the lid off? Also, spill the beans on how you liked using your termite tool (please)!

Re: I got a little carried away.

#3

Great Combination

Ron McKinley

>of woods and nicely executed.......Ron

Re: I got a little carried away.

#4

Re: I got a little carried away.

dtewell

>Whenever I get 'carried away' I usually just have more wood for the burn pile. I love the finial, I always have trouble with them.

Re: I got a little carried away.

#5

Re: I got a little carried away.

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Bob, this is a great looking little box. I love the finial accent too. Very nice job!

Jen

Re: I got a little carried away.

#6

Re:Good effort, but there are ....

Jamie Donaldson

>.. practical reasons for hiding a box joint in a recess or bead joint.It is very easy to nick or chip a sharp joint edge such as you have used here, and the rounded shape also feels kinder to the hand. I like Ray Key's philosophy about objects like boxes that are handled should feel friendly to the hand. Everything else looks great-good job.

Re: I got a little carried away.

#7

Brad Vietje

Nice job, Bob...

Brad Vietje

>Very pretty result, so its a good thing for us who get to see this that you pushed yourself to try your hand at a few new things ! Its a very nice, fairly formal shape, and the contrasting woods really look great.

If you make a few more similar pieces, and create a series of sorts, you can experiment with different lid/body configurations and try your hand at an inset lid, or even a suction fit "turner's" lid, and address some of Jamie's concerns about possible chips to the hard edge of the lid. Boxes are fun because there are so many slight variations to try.

For now, I'd just set it on the mantle, and take great pleasure in admiring your excellent work -- its a thing of beauty.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: I got a little carried away.

#8

Re: I got a little carried away.

Bob Way, Canton, MI

>Thanks, David. You know, I had heard of so many different experiences from those who had used the tool. All warned about horrendous catches and such. I had none of those at all. I read the instructions that came with the tool, did a dry run with it in position, then turned on the lathe and gave it a go. Maybe it was just one of those days everything falls into place, but I enjoyed using it, and was really pleased with the results. It was easy to use, and offered a nice cut. I don't think it will replace my gouge or scraper entirely, but it won't just sit in the drawer any longer.

My daughter in law borrowed the camera this afternoon to photograph the projects the 3rd graders she teaches have done. I'll take one with the lid off for you when she returns it.

Bob Way

Re: I got a little carried away.

#9

Re:Good effort, but there are ....

Bob Way, Canton, MI

>Point well taken, Jamie. Thanks. I hadn't thought of that in terms of the lid, but now that you mention it, I think that "feeling friendly to the hand" was the problem I had with the base and little pedestal. Both of those have some sharp edges. Those I'll have to work out something, but your suggestion has given me some ideas for the top. Thanks again.

Bob Way

Re: I got a little carried away.

#10

Re: Nice job, Bob...

Bob Way, Canton, MI

>Thanks, Brad. I always appreciate the encouragement you and so many others give to the postings.

It is a rather formal shape, moreso than I think I want for the original idea. So, back to the drawing board and on to stage 2. There are some things I really like about it, and I'll keep those. The others I'll work on and it'll be nice to have something to roll around in my hands for reference.

I am afraid it won't end up on the mantle, however...my wife gave the finial verbal affirmation, the rest got a smile, a nod, and that cute little thing she does before handing it back to me.

Thanks, Brad.

Bob Way

Canton, MI.

Re: I got a little carried away.

#11

Re: I got a little carried away.

Bob Way, Canton, MI

>I've got a fair amount of that too. Funny how even though some of them are just incredibly embarrassing, I still think of them as time well spent in the shop.

Bob Way

Canton, MI.

Re: I got a little carried away.

#12

Re: Great Combination

Bob Way, Canton, MI

>Thanks, Ron. For a guy who has failed every time his wife sent him off to the paint store alone to match a paint color for the trim with a background color of the wall paper, I appreciate Mother Nature saving me from that dilemma with a maple and walnut combination.

Bob Way

Re: I got a little carried away.

#13

Re: I got a little carried away.

Bob Way, Canton, MI

>Jen, thank you. I have watched your pieces evolve, and they just keep getting better and better. That's a morale booster on it's own, but your kind words are as well.

Bob Way

Canton, MI.