Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

But what would you use it for?

Posts

But what would you use it for?

#1

But what would you use it for?

Terry Fox

>I'm sure you've had the same experiance I have - a potential buyer admires that beautiful six inch dia. thin wall hollow form, only to have a companion say "but what would you use it for?". Many people seem to need to justify the purchase of a small object by more than just "it's good to look at". Most objects have relatively obvious uses, bowls, boxes, etc., but not HFs.

When asked the question, how do you respond?

Terry

(the occasional post keeps me out of 'lurkerdom'.)

Re: But what would you use it for?

#2

Andy DiPietro

Re: But what would you use it for?

Andy DiPietro

>You can put dried or artificial flowers in the HF's.

Re: But what would you use it for?

#3

Well... You could say

Raymond Overman in SC

>"Sir, you could give it to your mother-in-law for Christmas and satisfy your need to aggravate her by giving her something that just further clutters her house and has no discernible purpose."

"Ma'am, It would make a great conversation piece at dinner parties. Especially if you painted it blue. I can do that for you at an extra cost."

"What do you do with that art you bought last Summer, Ma'am? Why you hang it on a wall and let it collect dust of course... while occasionally admiring it as an overpriced purchase you made while vacationing."

"It's a spittoon Sir. You spit in it." (especially effective when talking to someone who dips)

"It's a chamber pot ma'am, for people with very small backsides."

"It's a bong." (Especially effective for shows on the west coast or near colleges)

"It's art Ma'am. Oops, I missed a zero on that price tag. Let me fix that."

"Now that you mention it Sir, it is cr@p. However, your wife likes it so it's probably going home with you anyway."

"It is what it is." (Especially gratifying when you wander off after saying it)

Re: But what would you use it for?

#4

Re: Well... You could say

Lee Buck

>Not relevant to HFs but Dave Hardy, the old master in our region, tells about a lady who kept coming back to admire a bowl at his table. Finally she said it was lovely but she just couldn't spend $300.00 for a bowl. His reply..."Lady, I certainly wouldn't."

Re: But what would you use it for?

#5

Re: Well... You could say

John Lucas

>Raymond You missed your calling as a comedian. Those are hillarious.

Re: But what would you use it for?

#6

Re: But what would you use it for?

Bill Youngblood

>One of the big name box turners, and I don't remember who, said that when asked that question, he reponds with, "My wife has a lot of these and she uses them for ... stuff."

Re: But what would you use it for?

#7

Re: Well... You could say

Raymond Overman in SC

>John,

Sarcasm just comes naturally after years of being a systems admin. The problem really starts when apathy sets in.

Re: But what would you use it for?

#8

Brad Vietje

Re: Well... You could say

Brad Vietje

>I make a lot of hollow forms, so I've heard all this...

If you give a hollow form a job, like holding dried flowers, it becomes a vase. If you can charge more than 500 bucks for it, you can call it a vaaase.

When asked "But what does it DO ?" I usually reply "It's doin' it. It was made to sit there and look pretty, and it doesn't have to do anything to do that." If I'm feeling a little more abrasive, I'll add something like "...well, what do you do with a Picasso ? You certainly don't eat salad off it". Usualy I take the polite route and say that hollow forms are like sculpture or a painting -- just made to look pretty.

I like to joke (mostly to other turners) that I don't like to worry about function, but prefer to make expensive, useless things with no function at all. Of course, I also make perfectly useful bowls and boxes and such, but there's something pretty liberating about making something just to look as pretty as you can make it, and for no other reason.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: But what would you use it for?

#9

Re: Well... You could say

Jim Swank

>Draw youself up to full height, look down your nose in a disapproving fashion like a French maitre d', and say "Sir, if you have to ask, I'm afraid you wouldn't understand."

Re: But what would you use it for?

#10

Re: Well... You could say

Raymond Overman in SC

>I think the corrollary to that statement is, "Ma'am, if you must ask, you can't afford it."

Of course, you can never really read people by their appearance nor their taste. Those that look like they can't afford something will surprise you and those that look like they can, can't.

Re: But what would you use it for?

#11

More often than not...

Peter Teubel

>When they ask "What do you do with it?", I usually respond with "You dust it."

Re: But what would you use it for?

#12

My older sister did that to me

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>Last year i gave my sister two turned pieces i had done. One was a shallow HF of redwood burl and the other was a small walnut bowl. My wife and I thought they were nice and I had redone the bottoms after I read here that no tooling marks is mo' better. When I handed them to her she asked what are they for and what do I do with them. My wife caught the look on my face and quickly offered up a few suggestions. I was bummed because my sister didn't realize the work involved and the sentimental value. To her credit she does have them on a shelf in the living room of her house.

On the other hand, I'm one of those people that when I go to a crafts show I admire a piece and then think to myself why do I need this and put it back. This "shaker", frugal, borderline cheapskate, techinacl trait is why I often don't make something, flat or round, myself as I ponder why will someone need or want to buy this. Most of the time I need to hear "I need this, or will you make that" to get me to plunge head first, non stop into a project.

I admire how you folks apply your artistic talents and have the confidence that "Yeah, someone's gonna want this" to your creations.

Re: But what would you use it for?

#13

Re: But what would you use it for?

Bruce Forrest

>Here in Canada, I'd tell them that at the end of the day, they should put all of their heavy 1 and 2 dollar coins (loonies and twoonies) in it. Then when it's full, they might have enough money to buy another one to add to their collection.

Re: But what would you use it for?

#14

Try education

Terence Rice

>I try to educate them if I can and have the time. I explain that like a painting it is primarily for looking at but that wood is a very tactile medium. It is also for holding and carressing. "Here, (handing it to them)Feel the texture. Notice how light it is. Turn it and look at the way the light plays off the grain. Smell it, every wood has it's own distinctive odor. It began as a piece of wood that nature made and out of that piece I have released a form that I found there. It takes both of us, the wood and the artist to make what you have there. It doesn't need any other purpose."

Many people go away with a new appreciation for woodturning and I have had several come back and show friends what they have learned. And some have even bought the piece.

Re: But what would you use it for?

#15

Re: But what would you use it for?

eliot d

>I just go right ahead and say something insulting to them and then try to avoid their company in the future.

Re: But what would you use it for?

#16

Re: But what would you use it for?

Raymond Overman in SC

>Really? How's that working out for you there? Sunshine and roses I would assume.

Re: But what would you use it for?

#17

Why let it bother you? (long--hey, it's Dinyar!)

Dinyar Chavda

>I used to get annoyed at this question, but not any more.

Most of us are selling items to people who have not benefitted from the tax law changes over the last six years. In fact, many of our customers are worse off today financially than they were a decade ago, and they have less discretionary income. This is not a political statement, just a description of the reality facing people.

So, what's wrong with their asking that question? In a sense, it may indicate that they are interested in the item, but they lack a justification for buying it, and, if you provide it, they may buy it. I try to remember that I am competing with other non-essential items like wearable art/craft in the form of jewelry and clothing, pottery dishes---things that are pretty, and whose function is obvious. Whether they are aware of it or not, customers make these trade-offs in their minds. I've had cases where helping the person rationalize their decision led to a purchase. And in another cases, it was just an enjoyable conversation. Frankly, I ask the same question about buying DVDs---what do you do with a movie after you've seen it a couple of times (if that!)?

It's interesting that people don't tend to ask that question about salad bowls, and yet I wonder how many $300 bowls are actually being used as salad bowls. It would not surprise me if many of them are sitting in the center of a coffee table in the living room---but, whether or not the bowl is actually used, , customers have justified their purchase with a rational reason.

Hey, I ask similar trade-off question all the time, myself, when it comes to my purchases. Do I spend $35 to join the AAW, or do I use it to buy the 3D Design Software? (No offence, Jamie)

I find that I enjoy my shows more, and, surprisingly, also sell more stuff since I changed my attitude to this question. Selling turned items is tough---why make it more difficult? In a way, I am reminded of Jimmy Connors. When he started, he would snarl at the crowd, and get into verbal fights with them and with linesmen--was even booed at Wimbledon. Then, as he put it, he realized "It's tough enough fighting the guy across the net. Why fight the crowd also?" Just that one question led to his become one of the most crowd-pleasing and adored players on the circuit, a reputation that was cemented in his incredible run in the 1991 US Open.

So, my attitude is: "Answer the question. It's a reasonable one".

Re: But what would you use it for?

#18

Re: But what would you use it for?

eliot d

>I was actually thinking about a dinner with four couples at a restaurant a few weeks ago, where one of the women is an artist from whom I've bought paintings -- although I never actually met her in person. She shows her work in numerous places and charges a fair amount. SHE's the one , who, when someone else said to her, "Well you know Eliot has some nice turned hollow vessels at such and such gallery; their selling for $800", who said, "Oh, what do you do with them, put in dried flowers?"

Re: But what would you use it for?

#19

Re: But what would you use it for?

eliot d

>(Should have previewed the post. "They're selling .. ". Not "their" ... .)