Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Another View

Posts

Another View

#1

Another View

James Fox

>Here is another view of my "mystery wood" bowl. Not sure this adds anything to solve the question of what type wood it is or just confuses the issue more.

Any thoughts on solving the type of wood puzzel are welcome.

Also thanks to all on your comments on the initial posting.

James


img

Re: Another View

#2

JL

Re: Doesn't have the ash grain..

JL

>but it is pretty. I like the color a lot.

Re: Another View

#3

Re: Doesn't have the ash grain..

bowlman

>Well, I don't know what wood it is either, but that sure looks like a graft line ... happens when a plant (tree), is grafted to a root stock.

Re: Another View

#4

Re: Another View

David Walser

>James,

I'm not sure what kind of wood your bowl is made of, but I'd bet a lot of money on it not being ash. It's the wrong color for ash. It doesn't have ash's open grain, and, unless it's a burl, the grain pattern is not similar to any ash I've ever seen. It looks more like some kid of fruit wood to me.

Whatever the wood is, the bowl is very nice.

Re: Another View

#5

Re: Another View

Karen Freitas

>Hi Guys,

This is my first time ever posting on any messageboard. I have been a lurker but enjoy Wood Central more every time I read it. I may have to post more often when I can.

I think this wood looks just like the Carob we turn out here in Calif. Carob has a tight grain pattern with colors ranging from orange to pink with brown streaks. It's a dream to turn and sands easily.

That is my best guess.

Karen

Re: Another View

#6

Brad Vietje

Maybe Mountain Ash ?

Brad Vietje

>I think we're all agreed -- that's a very pretty little bowl with a lovely shape (nice job !), and it ain't one of the common species of Ash.

I'd suggest this piece of wood was laying on the ground, or partly under ground, or otherwise in a moist place, and has begun to spalt or degrade somewhat, since the discoloration runs pretty cleanly through the growth rings and the live tree didn't respond by putting on curly wood or growing around a physical "thing" like a graft interface.

I also think color is only a hint, as there can be some pretty wide color variations in many woods. It does have little zig-zag lines and a diffuse pore structure, but the zigs and zags aren't so pronounced as the American Elm I'm familiar with, and a little more like Black Cherry. Anybody think Mountain Ash is a possibility ? That would give it a Cherry look, and the fellow who said it was Ash would be sorta correct in a general way...

Sure is a nice little bowl, though...

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Another View

#7

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Maybe Mountain Ash ?

Leo Van Der Loo

>Brad, I certainly agree with You on the partial submersion or burial, which could be one reason for the red color also, I do not believe it's Mountain Ash, I have turned Mountain Ash aka Rowan Tree, but that wood is lighter, and does not have that grain as I recall, it's more a light brown, also I 'm quite sure it does not grow in a hot climate.

To bad this new picture does not give us a better look at the wood grain, the sound wood might give us a better look than the partially spalted side.

There are so many different trees out there it's nearly impossible to tell what it is for certain, but we can eliminate some, still leaving us a large number though.

So much to learn and so little time.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Another View

#8

Re: Another View

WHH

>Looks like spalted cherry to me

Re: Another View

#9

Thanks to all...

James Fox

>I�m always amazed at the help that everyone on this site is so willing to give. Leo, Brad and all the others who have taken the time made such an effort just to try to identify the wood in my little bowl�thank you so much.

James

Re: Another View

#10

Re: Another View

Thad Parker

>James,

it seems the consesus would be that it is not ash. It looks nearly identical in color and grain to a few pecan pieces I've done this year. I am by no means any form of authority on wood ID, so others more qualified may over rule me...your bowl looks like pecan to me though. I'll try to post a pic.

~ Thad

Re: Another View

#11

Re: Another View

Carole Valentine

>Hi Karen! Just wanted to say "Welcome to WC." Keep posting! Have never seen Carob, but I hear it is pretty and nice to work with. Maybe you could post a pic of a finished piece made from it?

I have no clue what this wood is. Almost looks like a graft to me. The right side looks like cherry.

Re: Another View

#12

Re: Another View

Allen Neighbors

>What Carole said. :o) We're all glad you came onboard with a post.

Would like to see a finished carob piece, too. :o)

Re: Another View

#13

Re: Another View

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi James,

You have a particularly curious hunk of wood there. I agree with everyone else that it's not ash. The first pic looks a lot like elm, but the second does look something like cherry. I'm including a couple of pics of an elm bowl that has sort of similar grain and spalting.

If you have a small piece of the unspalted wood that you want to send, I'll see if it matches any of the micrographs that I have. E-mail me and we'll set something up. No guarantees, but if we do figure it out, you'll have to make another post, so everyone else who is trying to noodle this out will have some closure.

Gary

Re: Another View

#14

Probably be helpful to include the pics.

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Here's the first pic of the elm bowl which shows some grain similar to the grain on the right half of the second pic of the mystery wood.

Gary


img

Re: Another View

#15

Second Pic

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Here is a pic of another side of the same elm bowl with some similar spalting to what is shown on the left side of the second picture of the mystery wood.

Gary


img

Re: Another View

#16

ebd

Re: Doesn't have the ash grain..

ebd

>The grain is running the wrong way for this to be a graft.