Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Segmented construction question

Posts

Segmented construction question

#1

Segmented construction question

JohnDillbeck

>I guess I would be called a lurker. Have been around since BP days.I have been doing segmented work for five years and have always been concerned about crossgrain glue joints. I try to minimize or prevent having them.I notice on alot of segmented pieces the bottom is a single piece. I started using four pieces for the bottom a couple of years ago.Anyway I recently made a bowl out of Bocote. I did not measure moisture content. First mistake. Made the bottom a solid piece Three inches dia. Second mistake. Put it in a gallery that is extremely dry, in the midwest with no humidifier. The bowl tore itself apart at the bottom. I suspect the moisture content of the wood is primary. What do you guys think?

Re: Segmented construction question

#2

Re: Segmented construction question

Bill Youngblood

>If you segment the bottom, 99 times out of a hundred, or more, the bottom will split. I learned the hard way also to ALWAYS use a solid piece for the bottom.

Bill

Re: Segmented construction question

#3

Re: Segmented construction question

John Lucas

>John I had the same problem. A piece blew up when it went to an exhibition. It was extemely dry there. There are a lot of potential problems with bottoms on segmented work and I'm not the best one to tell you what to do but I'll throw in my 2 cents worth.

A lot depends on the size of the bottom. You will get wood movement no matter what but a large bottom moves more than a small one. With a solid piece you get a fair amount of movement in one direction(across the grain) and almost none in the other(with the grain). If you make the bottom out of 4 pieces mitered together you change how they move but they still move so either you have to make the bottom float (like in a cabinet door) or you have to make the bottom small enought that what little movement you get doesn't matter.

I started making the bottoms out of what I'll call plywood. I resaw the wood so each piece is about 1/8" or less(depending on the bottom thickness) and then laminate them together so the grain runs crossways like plywood is assembled. This way the bottom doesn't move but of course you have cover the edges or it looks like plywood.

I will be interested in others approach.

Re: Segmented construction question

#4

Re: Segmented construction question

Bill Stehman

>Hi John,

Sounds like you have a good understanding of moisture, wood movement and grain alignment.

Several thoughts to consider. Less wood less movement, meaning even on the foot turn as thin as possible even if you have to hollow it up from the bottom. A tenon will also provide the best insurance allowing movement without coming apart. The biggest cause of failure for the foot is probably using solid veneers to separate the foot. These too should be segmented to achieve grain alignment. Wall thickness of 1/8 or less (including the foot) will give the best success.

Curt Theobald has some excellent videos that covers grain alignment even with within design rings.

Good luck

Bill

Re: Segmented construction question

#5

Re: Segmented construction question

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>John,

I remember you from the BP days.

If this was a larger Segmented Turning forum, you would have really opened a real can of worms with the bottom - seg vs solid - question.

I think the Malcolm Tibbetts is still doing a segmented bottom with a floating center.

Last I talked to Curt Theobald and Bud Latvin, they are solid bottom people, as am I.

On about 90% of my pieces, I end up with a lamination on the bottom - bottom piece, followed by a couple layers of veneer that I add for looks, but I believe that it has the added advantage of creating a 3 veneer plywood layer (I cross laminate the veneers). This may be why I have built my pieces here in the humid deep south for years and have never had one come apart (that I know of), including pieces that I sent to family in Phoenix, Arizona.

The bottoms on mine are seldom what most woodturners consider thin. 1/2" - 3/8" thick (or more on big pieces). I don't want the bottom broken by someone's heavy handedness, or by stresses from the other layers. The upper layers are never thinner than 1/4". I want a decent glue contact surface, but that is thin enough for the wood and glue to move w/o cracking - I think.

Just my way of doing it, and my opinions.

Mark

You have gotten some

Re: Segmented construction question

#6

Re: Segmented construction question

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>I have no idea where the "You have gotten some" line on the bottom came from.

Also another couple of thoughts.

1) When I said that the upper layers are no thinner that 1/4", I was talking wall thickness.

2) As most of you have seen, I do not build bowls with high/tall segment rings, or few segments per ring. Having said that, as always there are exceptions, that being tinted bowls. 12 Segment rings 3/4" tall, are for faster production. These are low profit bowls.

I began to think about #2 above, and I wonder if that is not a contributor to the longevity of my bowls. I wonder if the small size of the segments relative to the glue surface, reduces the destructive force that they can impart on the joint. Just a thought.

Mark

Re: Segmented construction question

#7

Re: Segmented construction question

Fog Tanner

>Thanks for clearing that up Mark. I was beginning to wonder what it was I had gotten, since I had gotten where was it, along with how did you know that I had gotten it in the first place. But, now I am bummed out because I didn't get it in the first place. Not sure which is worse, not having gotten it or having gotten it and not knowing.

Re: Segmented construction question

#8

Ray Allen techniques

Bill Stehman

>I was lucky to spend many hours in his shop one winter and he developed many techniques over the years to prevent segmented failures for ever changing climates.

Align grain, sand all joints, turn your bowls thin and plan a for movement including veneer layers.

Between winter dryness and summer humidity I can feel the veneer lines in one of his bowls but it always returns to normal. Just thoughts.

Re: Segmented construction question

#9

Re: Ray Allen techniques

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Yeah, Bill, it is a long learning process for all of us. Thankfully, with forums like this, we can share that process and speed us all along. Everytime I talk to Curt Theobald, I end up modifying something I do in segmenting.

Unfortunately, some of Ray Allen's bowls are coming apart because of grain alignment, even he was not perfect.

Mark