Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

I'll be brave and ask for a critique...

Posts

I'll be brave and ask for a critique...

#1

JL

I'll be brave and ask for a critique...

JL

>Okay, as I said, I'll be brave.

Details first. Butternut seat. White oak spindles, arm rest, back hoop and crest. Maple legs, stretchers and arm posts. Oak rockers. No finish yet. There is a lot more work to do on this one what with sanding and all.

Is it too busy?

Did I go over the top putting a crest on it?

Should I deepen the seat more?


img

Re: I'll be brave and ask for a critique...

#2

Re: I'll be brave and ask for a critique...

john lucas

>Most interesting. As someone who has studied windsor style chairs I'm not sure what to think. Part of me likes it and part of me sees it as a combination of two styles of chairs. I think the crest rail and curved top compete with each other. I'm not sure exactly why I feel that way. Most of the top windsor chairs have lines that flow from one to another and I think maybe that might be what bothers me.

Over all it's very well done with clean turnings. You are to be congratulated. It will be interesting to see what others think.

Re: I'll be brave and ask for a critique...

#3

Re: I'll be brave and ask for a critique...

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi JL,

I love Windsor chairs and I know how much work this was, incvredible to see. This is not the classic comb back that I have seen before, it looks like you are combining designs here...they compete and I think I like the classic comb back better, none the less you have made a wonderful chair.

take care,

Jim


img

Re: I'll be brave and ask for a critique...

#4

Re: I'll be brave and ask for a critique...

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>I agree with the others. It looks like two style and I think they do compete. Also I agree the seat needs to be a lot deeper. It will fit better as well as look better.

Re: I'll be brave and ask for a critique...

#5

JL

Re: I'll be brave and ask for a critique...

JL

>Thanks for the kind words.

A crest does not a comb back make though. Crests or "head rests" were used in several styles including continuous arm chairs as well as sackbacks.

Re: I'll be brave and ask for a critique...

#6

Re: I'll be brave and ask for a critique...

john lucas

>There are actually a lot of inovative designs in windsor chairs. They were adapted to the needs of the craftsman making them. Yours is simply another inovation that fits your needs. The book Windsor Style in America has hundreds of photos and drawings and it's really surprising some of the takeoffs and modifications to the original windsor styles.

I'm really delighted to see someone doing other styles of turning. I like bowls and vessels but I've seen so many it's refreshing to see something else.

Re: I'll be brave and ask for a critique...

#7

Re: I'll be brave and ask for a critique...

Philip Duffy

>My 2 cents; The driving axiom here is simply;"is it comfortable"? All else is secondary in my view as there are classic forms of Windsors and hundreds of variations. I like my comb-backs but the idea of having a rocker with some nice features is attractive. I wonder if the crest were a bit shorter would it look more classic? Phil

Re: I'll be brave and ask for a critique...

#8

JL

Re: I'll be brave and ask for a critique...

JL

>Is it more comfortable? Well, the LOML took it for a "test sit". She liked it. I went for a large crest because that way I could get more spindles for support. I didn't feel comfortable with only three spindles into the bottom of the crest. Five spindles seems to offer reasonable support, the spindle diameter is only 3/8" above the hoop.