Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Hollow Form Question

Posts

Hollow Form Question

#1

Bob Moffett

Hollow Form Question

Bob Moffett

>I have another question. I am trying to learn how to do hollow forms. With bowls, I have put them in brown paper bags stuffed with shavings and let them dry for 6 months or so or until I got around to finishing them. My shop is in my basement and I store them there. With hollow forms being turned with the grain running leagthwise rather than crosswise as in a bowl, should I use the same time frame to dry them. Someone told me that since they were long grain the wood would not move as much and they didn't have to dry as long. I understand why the wood wouldn't move as much but, it seems to me like the wood would take longer to dry. I tried finishing a small one with Waterlox while it was still pretty wet and was not pleased with the finish. I use Waterlox on a lot of my bowls and have gotten very good results with it. Should I let them dry longer than a comperable size bowl or not?

Re: Hollow Form Question

#2

Re: Hollow Form Question *LINK*

Darrell Feltmate

>Bob

You will likely get varied responses for this question. Everyone who turns hollow forms has a different set of rules, all of which are correct. Personally I like to turn them green to finish, regardless of the grain direction. Long grain tends to dry uniformly while side grain will distort in the direction of the grain. Plan for this and turn accordingly. I find that drying the wood with a heat gun prior to finishing is a big help. You may want to check out my web site under Hollowing How To" for other hints.


Around the Woods

Re: Hollow Form Question

#3

I agree

Reality Check

>First, the good thing about long grain turning is that, distortion and cracking is less compared to side grain, and the structure of a more closed hollow form as opposed to an open bowl actually contributes to the physical structure of the piece.

What I do, and this works for me! You may find something different that works for you.

In many cases, and depending on the species, if you turn a piece thin enough, you can green turn a piece from start to finish without any extra drying involved. Will you get some distortion?. Yes, is that bad? Depending on the piece it may even add interest to it. Ellsworth turns many pieces like this he just lets the wood �do it�s thing� and his pieces are great. It you are achieving a more of a �perfect symmetrical form� you may need to twice turn it. You will find because of the grain orientation and support characteristics of a somewhat closed form you may only have to Paper bag it dry for 2-3 weeks(paper bags are great by the way, I don�t even need to use shavings in my climate ) , then you open air dry (hanging upside down-do NOT cover opening) for another 3-4 weeks. Most wood are pretty stable at that point unless your blank was too thick. Keep in mind in some species, sapwoods and heart woods dry and or move at surprising different rates which the sapwood is sometimes prone to cracking (Locust for example is bad, heartwood very stable, sap very unstable) in this case I will throw some Anchorseal on the sapwood and bag dry it longer.

All this of course depends on your climate, the wood species and experience with the species at hand . Also, with special pieces or special woods I do dry them longer just as a safety measure.

Good Luck

Reality Check

PS, Lawn paper bags work very well, they are heavier and keeps the moisture in a bit more than thinner bags, but still allows fairly fast initial drying.

Re: Hollow Form Question

#4

Re: Hollow Form Question

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Bob, in my experience a hollow form can have a shorter drying time than a side-grain turning such as a bowl. If a form is turned with the pith right on center, or is from a large enough chunk of wood that is far away from the pith, I wouldn't worry about warpage so the form in this case can be turned to finished size.

If I am concerned about warpage for some reason, I'd wrap only the outside with paper and let moisture escape from the inside before allowing the exterior to start drying. Otherwise the exterior drys faster, increasing the chance of wierd things happening such as cracking.

Re: Hollow Form Question

#5

Re: Hollow Form Question

Molly Winton

>Bob, you've gotten some very good advice already, but I'll add my 2 cents in also. I live in the Northwest, where there's a lot of moisture in the air, as opposed to Arizona or Utah for example where it is extremely dry. I turn all of my hollow forms to their finished form and thickness and then let them dry on their own prior to finishing. I usually bring them in the house (68-72 degrees) and they're dry in about a week. My final thickness ranges anywhere from 1/8" to 1/4" depending upon the hollow style. Usually I have no problems with cracking, but I can get some distortion on occasion. I've only had one cracking problem recently and that was with sycamore. It cracked so badly I thought it was ruined, but I left it alone, and let it finish drying. Now that it is done, the cracks are almost invisible. They closed right up. Like anything else, so much depends upon the wood species, wall thickness, wall uniformity, and blind luck. I hope this helps.