Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Difficult question

Posts

Difficult question

#1

Difficult question

eliot d

>Let's say you wanted to go back and forth between using the Tormek with its gouge sharpening jig and the Wolverine, with its Vari - Grind jig, which are similar but not the same. And the idea is to get the exact same grind. How would you proceed? Is it enough to duplicate the angles, distances , etc. One would think so; but , for example, how do the angle settings of each jig compare? I've looked at the sharpening article in American Woodturner(Vol.21,N0.4) and even tried their gouge setup jig, which works fine. The problem comes up if I choose to refine the edge on the Tormek without changing the shape. And why do you think the author chose 23 degrees for the control leg angle on the Vari-Grind jig? He just says he "believes" it should be set that way. (I suppose I could ask him.) Maybe Kirk DeHeer will see this post.

Re: Difficult question

#2

good question!

phil in NJ

>If using a grinder and a tormek as well, I'm not sure the hollow grind would be the same based on wheel diameter either.

How do people who do this work it? Or is it just rough shaping on the grinder, then forever use the tormek until a major regrind is necessary?

Thanks!

Phil

Re: Difficult question

#3

Re: good question!

John Lucas

>Eliot that was my thought also is the diameter of the wheels would be different so even if you got the grind correct between the two. As the wheels wear it would change. Possibly if you got something like the Geiger jig that lets you set the jig up the same no matter what the size of the wheel it would help but that would only work for the Wolverine type system and not the Tormek.

Re: Difficult question

#4

Re: good question!

Terence Rice

>I rough shape on the grinder and then use the Tormek from then on unless I need to make a major modification

Re: Difficult question

#5

Re: Difficult question

Russ Fairfield

>You will never get an exact match because of the difference in wheel diameters, and whatever differences there might be in the geometry of the 2 jigs. but you can get close. I have heard folks claim that they can get an exact match (other than wheel diameters) with the Sorby grinding jig. I would suspect this is true because they are exactly the same jig as the Tormek. The geometry of the Wolverine is different, and you cannot get an exact match; but you can get close.

There are 2 things to remember. The bevel at the tip is matched to the wheel with movement of the sliding support arm. And, the bevel along the sides of the tool are matched by moving the pivot arm on the jig.

Starting with the tool that has been ground on the Tormek, put the tool in the Wolverine jig, and use a fixed protrusion if the tool beyond the clamp that can be duplicated with either a gage-block or by measureing. Start at 2"

Start with the pivot arm on the jig in the "full down" position.

Put the jig in the notch of the sliding bar and slide until you have the bevel at the nose touching the bevel at and just below the tip. Use a black laundry marker on the tool bevel and rotate the wheel by hand.

Then rotate the jig to the side of the profile, and adjust the arm on the jig to where the wheel just touches the cutting edge and the bevel below it again. If you can't get there, get as close as you can.

Go back to the tip and move the sliding support bar again to match the tip bevel as before. It will have moved.

Then go back to the side gring and adjust the pivot arm on the jig until it rubs the bevel at the cutting edge. Again, if you can't get there, get as close as you can.

Repeat as necessary until you can get the side of the tool to rub with as little movement as possible of the pivot arm.

If you want to get closer, try a 2-1/4" and a 1-3/4" protrusion bekond the clamp of the Wolverine jig and see if that will get you closer.

In the end you will want the edge along the side grind to be the controlling dulication, and let the tip bevel angle take care of any difference. This is because the tip bevel is the easiest to grind away because there is less steel in contact with the wheels, and you will be less likely to notice a difference of a couple degrees of angle at the tip than you would along the sides of the profile.

Fix the position of the arm on the Wolverine jig. The next time you use it, set the protrusion of the tool beyond the clamp, and adjust the sliding support arm to pick up the bevel on the side of the profile.

And, that will be as close as you can get.

Re: Difficult question

#6

Re: good question!

John Kyler

>I don't have the Tormek, but the Sorby jig uses the Tormek jig in their base. I would think you could likely set up the Sorby base on the grinder of similar size wheel as the Tormek and it could be very close, and likely work well. I ended up with 2 of the Sorby bases and one of the jigs and have never had the time to set them up. I was going to make a clamping base so the Sorby could be removed and not interfere with the Wolverine. But time is on backorder on my schedule. I need 48 hours in a day.

John

Re: Difficult question

#7

Re: My work on the 23-degree angle.

Russ Fairfield

>The 23-degrees is nothing more than a personal preference that works for the author. If you want to duplicate what they are doing, then use that angle and those instructions. If you want to use what works best for you, then experiment with other angles.

I don't use the 23-degrees, and I don't know of anyone else who does either. Some of them use a little more, some little less, and some a lot more or less; but we get our tools ground with some degree of repeatability, we all get the job done, and the wood will never know the difference.

Personally, I use different angles for different tools because what works for me on a 5/8" tool will turn a 1/4" or 3/8" tool into an unuseable stick. Different angles also work better for different tip and side angles. That is why the pivot arm is adjustable.

At $50 apice for the jigs, it is not all that expensive to have 2 or 3 of them that are fixed at the different angles that work the best for the different tools and profiles. You will save the time and wasted tool steel from having to adjust the jig every time you use a different tool.

Re: Difficult question

#8

Why not...

Peter Teubel

>...just buy another Wolverine base (available seperatly from Oneway) and mount it under the Tormek? Then you can use the Vari-grind with the same settings. The difference in wheel diameter will affect the bevel, but a secondary (i.e. very small) bevel produced on the Tormek shouldn't affect the cutting action of the tool.

Re: Difficult question

#9

Re: Difficult question

Pat Taylor

>I just use the Tormek for everything. Sure it's slower, but it works fine. Why the need for another grinder? Is it just for speed?

Re: Difficult question

#10

Re: Why not...

eliot d

>Peter. Can't do that because there's all kinds of stuff on the Tormek ( e.g. the watere tray) where the Wolverine would have to go. I suppose one could get around that somehow, but it would be a big deal.

Re: Difficult question

#11

Re: Difficult question

eliot d

>Well, if you ever try re-shaping the grind of a tool on the Tormek, it takes FOREVER. The idea would be to shape on the Wolverine and get a super sharp edge on the Tormek using cool, water bath grinding that removes very little steel.

Re: Difficult question

#12

Re: Difficult question

eliot d

>Thanks Russ. Why am I not surprised that you actually supplied an algorithm to do the job! I will try it soon.

As I was thinking about the problem, I did come up with another method -- but it will work only for the 45 degree grind that is described in the DeHeer American Woodturner article and the Tormek setup for the 45 degree bevel on their TTS-100 Turning Tool Setter.

This would mean JS=2 ,P=65, and use the first hole on the Setter for the Tormek settings. And for the DeHeer article, 5 7/8 inches on the Goluge Setup Jig (using DeHeer's 23 degree angle and his 2 inch extension). If DeHeer would calculate the Gouge Setup Jig dimensions for 55 degrees ( instead of 50 degrees) then one could match the Tormek settings on the Turning Tool Setter for 55 degrees. also. This is the one I'm most interested in.

Re: Difficult question

#13

Re: Difficult question

eliot d

>On second thought, this 45 degree method may not work, either. It would certainly get the 45 degree bevel angle to match at the nose, but I'm not at all sure about what would happen on the sides. Back to The Russ Fairfield way!

Re: Difficult question

#14

Here's how Steve Worcester did it. *LINK*

Clem Wixted, Jonesboro, AR

>Seems like Steve Worcester has come up with a way to replicate the Ellsworth grind using the Vari Grind jig on the Tormek. He has designed a platform to fit under the Tormek so you can use the Vari Grind jig to sharpen your gouge. He also provides an adjustment for wheel wear.

Clem


How to use the Vari Grind jig on the Tormek

Re: Difficult question

#15

Richard Allen

Re: Difficult question

Richard Allen

>Hi Eliot

I did this about a year ago. I have always used the Sorby jig on the dry grinder.

Once the bowl gouge was set in the sorby jig I could transfer between the Tormek and the dry grinder.

BTW Don Riggs had a sorby jig welded to a short "V" arm replacement for use in the Oneway base.

I tried the Tormek for all my turning tool sharpening for 2 months. I then switched back to the dry grinder for a month. Followed by use of the Tormek for a month.

I was unable to detect a difference in the woodturning experience beyond the additional maintenance of the Tormek. Finding the Tormek to increase my effort with no improvement in my turning experience I retired the Tormek. I "plan" to use the Tormek for sharpening kitchen knives but I won't waste my time sharpening turning tools using the Tormek.

Re: Difficult question

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Difficult question

keith tompkins

>Eliot, by pivoting the arm on the wolverine jig, you are changing the SIDE angle. At 23 degrees, as in the article, you will get the grind Kirk uses. By moving the arm near the center, you will begin to develop a long side grind. The nose angle not only sets the bevel, it also sets the bevel on the side grind as well.....For example, if you have a side grind with perpendicular wings, increase the nose angle, NOT the arm angle. Btw, My wolverine jig is just about dead center for the adjustment.

Re: Difficult question

#17

Re: Difficult question

Fog Tanner

>I use an Ellsworth jig for my Ellsworth gouge on my dry grinder. After trying to use the Tormek jig to duplicate the grind I decided to use the Ellsworth jig on the Tormek. I made a base that the Tormek sits on, it has two rails to lock its position. I made a sliding arm similar to the one on my dry grinder using the same relative numbers. The arm is actually locked onto the part of the rails of the Tormek and has a locking screw, so it always goes back to the same location.

So now if I am doing a lot of bowls I set this up and use it inplace of the dry grinder. The same thing would work for the Vari-grind as well. For all my other gouges I just use the Tormek, as the Ellsworth is the only jig I have for my dry grinder.

Re: Difficult question

#18

Re: Difficult question - Simple solution

RK in Milwaukee

>This setup allows you to use your Tormek jigs on your dry grinder. The pedestal is 7 3/8" tall.


img

Re: Difficult question

#19

Re: Why not...

eliot d

>Well, now that I've read some of the other posts, apparently, big deal or not, some turners have figured a way to mount a Wolverine under a Tormek wheel. So you had the right idea, all right. I have to hand it to you, because , if you really look at a

Tormek, there just seems to be no way. There's a boat- load of stuff in the way!

Re: Difficult question

#20

Re: Difficult question - Simple solution

eliot d

>RK in Milwaulkee, You are definitely a genius! What an elegant solution! This is the one I'll try first. Why didn't I think of it? Just dumb as a bag of hammers , I guess. Thanks!

Re: Difficult question

#21

Quite simple, really...

Peter Teubel

>Put the Tormek on a raised platform and mount the Wolverine base under it. You might have to add a riser block to the pocket of the V-arm, but that's it. With the base under it, you should be able to use the V-arm from either side, depending on how you like to sharpen (grinding into or away from the edge).

Re: Difficult question

#22

Re: Difficult question

Bob Fawcett

>"There are 2 things to remember. The bevel at the tip is matched to the wheel with movement of the sliding support arm. And, the bevel along the sides of the tool are matched by moving the pivot arm on the jig."

Russ,

This is the opposite of what Oneway shows in the video on their website. Can you it either way?

Re: Difficult question

#23

Re: Could be. Try it and see

Russ Fairfield

>

Re: Difficult question

#24

Re: Difficult question - Simple solution

eliot d

>RK, Just so you know your message and picture had an effect , I spent all day today redesigning my Wolverine work station and making something that looks just like the picture you provided. Tomorrow I'll set up the Tormek sliding angle fixture and try it out. Thanks again.

Re: Difficult question

#25

FANTASTIC solution

Clem Wixted, Jonesboro, AR

>