Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Warping on purpose

Posts

Warping on purpose

#1

Warping on purpose

David Breth

>I like the way a warped bowl or form looks when it is pretty severely warped, and have experimented off and on to try to get some interesting shapes. I'm wondering if I can get some hints on the influence of a few of the items below:

1) Wood characteristics particularly susceptible to warping (open vs. tight grain, end vs. side grain, super- vs moderately-green, etc.)

2) Thickness walls/bottom? How about if you had a bowl wall that varied in thickness multiple times down its' length?

3) Forms that are more/less susceptible to warping?

4) Storage to maximize warp - brown bag, brown bag with shavings, totally exposed to air, doesn't matter?

5) Sanding. Any hints or comments? After it warps there isn't going to be any "Put it on the lathe and sand it". I've sanded several green pieces on the lathe to finish, as I would a dry bowl. When I pick it up to finish it off x months later, there's some fuzz typically, the result of the drying process, but not too terrible to sand off. No doubt I'm heating the wood when I do that, and possibly I'm slowing the drying process if I burnish the wood. Am I inhibiting/promoting warpage?

6) I've heard of people wraping stuff around the wood to encourage warping - what is typically used? How is it applied?

This post is a lot more involved than I meant for it to be. I've done some experimentation, but my results have been pretty ho hum (nothing looks worse than a slightly warped bowl. You either need incredible warp or none for a winner). I haven't found much on line except for turners' webpages where they say on their home site that sometimes they think warping looks nice so they do it sometimes. Hmmmm. Not the instruction I was seeking.

Thanks for any assistance !

David Breth

Re: Warping on purpose

#2

Re: Warping on purpose

John Lucas

>I only have a couple of minutes before my next assignment but I'll try to answer a few question. First of all read up on wood movement. Wood moves differently in 3 different planes. You would want to accentuate this effect.

Thin warps more than thick and you can accentuate that by putting pressure on the sides. Johannes Michelson warps his hats with rubber bands and clamps.

Cone shaped pieces warp less than flat pieces. Cone shaped pieces tend to get taller and don't show the warp. Flat pieces will usually warp a lot but may also crack.

Wet wood, and especially wet and hot wood can be bent easier than cold and dry.

That's just a few things off the top of my head.

years ago there was a show at our gallery and they guy called the potato chip bowls. The were large flat platters turned extremely thin and then allowed to warp. they really moved.

As far as species, I'm not as sharp on that. I've steam bent species like maple, oak, ash, cherry, and walnut but don't know much about the others.

Re: Warping on purpose

#3

Re: Warping on purpose

Michael Sinclair in Orkney

>Hi David

I have just been playing with this a couple of months ago using green burl oak.

Most of my turning is to finish in one go and I have found I can leave the thickness about 1/4" or maybe a bit more.I wet sand with water and leave it on a shelf low down in the workshop which is heated and sits about 12 - 18 degrees centigrade.I keep an eye on things to watch out for mould and the like.After about 8-12 weeks if it seems OK I sand dry as best I can on the burls with 320 up to 400 but not much more .The problem I have is trying to true up the bottoms when they are so warped.I do mark the centre initially but I just play with it untill it looks OK.I then coat with Danish oil as Russ does in his DVD but I do not oil sand on the burls.I will post some pics of a few pieces once I have them.Most of my pieces made from sycamore,ash and elm just go oval however the burls were the real winners and moved a lot.I have seen oak turned wet and thin move a lot too but I have never tried it.

Cheers

Michael

Re: Warping on purpose

#4

Re: Warping on purpose

Michael Sinclair in Orkney

>Some quick photos we took to let you see the general idea.


img

Re: Warping on purpose

#5

Re: Warping on purpose

Michael Sinclair in Orkney

>A second pic side view. Approx 6" x 6".


img

Re: Warping on purpose

#6

Re: Warping on purpose

Jeff from MA

>It might be interesting to pick pieces of wood from certain parts of a tree. The crotches and where large branches meet trunks should have a lot of stress built into the wood. I suspect that the bigger the branch, and the more severe the angle would indicate more stress built into the wood. As the piece dries, and as you remove more fibers, the stress relief could cause interesting warps. It definitely can cause interesting cracks and splits.

Re: Warping on purpose

#7

Re: Warping on purpose

Michael Sinclair in Orkney

>Group shot. Small one is the thinest and moved the most. It's about 3/16 thick.

In reality they cant to one side most visable perhaps on the piece on the left.

Not the best pics but I hope it gives you some ideas.

Cheers

Michael.


img

Re: Warping on purpose

#8

Re: Warping on purpose *LINK*

Raymond Overman in SC

>Christian Buchard has a very successful series he calls baskets and gourds that are thin turned madrone. It's one of my favorite series of work. You can see it at the link below.


http://www.burchardstudio.com/baskets.html

Re: Warping on purpose

#9

Re: Warping on purpose

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>The shapes of these warped pieces is reminiscent of hand built ceramic pieces.

Impressive.

keith

Re: Warping on purpose

#10

Brad Vietje

Re: Warping on purpose

Brad Vietje

>Jeff brings up some good points to consider. Crotch wood, compression curl (below heavy branches), buttress wood (near base of fluted tree bole), reaction wood, flatsawn, endgrain, sidegrain -- all will affect the movement. Burls and curly figure will tend to wrinkle as well as warp.

I have turned the potato chip bowls John mentioned, and I often wet sand curly figured wood with warm water up to about 320 to reduce the amount of texture I'll lose later when I smooth the dry wood and remove raised grain from the drying process (see Michael's posts and photos). I usually use Scotch Bright pads and careful hand sanding with 400 after the wood dries to keep the wrinkly texture. I hope the not-so-good photo of a Curly Eucalyptus hollow form shows intentional wrinkle, though hollow forms like this usually don't warp very dramaticlally.

I'd recommend Turning Green Wood by Michael O'Donnell to help you plan your experiments -- sounds like fun !

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT


img

Re: Warping on purpose

#11

Steven Antonucci

Some things you might consider useful

Steve Antonucci

>1.) Of all of the wood species I've ever turned, madrone moved the most. In fact, it moved so much it wants to jump off of the lathe and run acros the shop. Raymond Overman alluded to Christian Burchard's baskets, and I'm pretty sure they're all madrone. There is nothing you can do to stop Madrone burl from moving and it is probably the most unstable substance on the planet.

2.) Any figured woods will move more than straight grain. I have some white oak crotch platters that are so wavy that they have never been finished (they're art pieces...) Crotch figure is under compression on one side, and tension on the other. As you cut the wood, it relieves the tension and the wood moves to a new point of equilibrium. The bigger the limb, the more tension.

3.) Thin turnings move, thicker ones crack (generally). Uniformity is the key and thinner is better.

4.) I try to sand the piece on the lathe while it's still wet. Once it dries, the surface gets a cool undulating texture that sanding messes up, so I "finish" the turning and just wait it out. I'd bag the wood to control drying, lest you increase the risk of the thing you turned tearing itself apart.

Steve

Re: Warping on purpose

#12

Re: Some things you might consider useful

John Lucas

>Madrone is what Christian Burchard uses. He demonstrated for our symposium last year and showed how much the move.

Re: Warping on purpose

#13

Thanks to all!

David Breth

>Very much! I appreciate the responses, photos, links, the works. I've always admired the effect of letting the wood be wood.

As I think of Madrone, I can't help but think what a nice gift that would be for my wife to provide on my birthday this June.....

David B.

Re: Warping on purpose

#14

Re: Warping on purpose *LINK*

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Warping wood is fun, check out what Christian Buchard does with Madrone Burls and warping


http://www.burchardstudio.com/baskets.html

Re: Warping on purpose

#15

Re: Warping on purpose

Lan Brady

>Michael,

I agree with Keith, these are great!

Lan

Re: Warping on purpose

#16

Re: Warping on purpose

David Breth

>I wonder if he bleaches them to eliminate mold issues....

David B.

Re: Warping on purpose

#17

Re: Warping on purpose

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>He turns them so thin, that they are dry in a few days. Cycling it though the microwave, you can do it in a couple of hours.

Mark