Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Lathe Duplicators

Posts

Lathe Duplicators

#1

Lathe Duplicators

Don Emmerling

>I am interested in buying a lathe duplicator. I have located one at Rockler for $199. I would like to know if anyone here has any experience with duplicators in general and more specifically the one I noted. Since I have never used one I need to know if this one is technically good and the price reasonable, or alternatively if there is a better one out there for similar or less money.

Thanks in advance for your thoughts.

Don in Johnstown

Re: Lathe Duplicators

#2

Re: Lathe Duplicators

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>This is only my opinion, take it for it's 2 cents worth, but in general, I think duplicators are a waste of time and money. Setup is rather painstaking and time-consuming, and the single-point tool used in this type of rig does not leave a very good tool finish unless you move the carriage at a snail's pace on the final cut and still, you may have to go over the work with a hand held tool, to clean it up and sharpen the detail a bit.

Recently however, I was in a situation where a duplicator proved to be of help when a fellow club member asked me to help turn almost 200 railing spindles for a job he was contracting. He had the use of a Delta duplicator shown at http://woodworker.com/cgi-bin/fullpres.exe?partnum=46-408

to rough the spindles out, then passed them on to me to finish off with hand tools. It worked pretty slick, and made the job easier for both of us.

One big problem with the less expensive units is the lack of rigidity. If you stop in midcut, the tool will dig in because it deflects as you make the cut. The work itself will deflect on a narrow spindle. This was a problem if my friend had the duplicator set too close to finished size. So if you are relying on a rig to give a finished surface, the final cut needs to be very slow, shallow and even. A high RPM helps a lot here.

Vega has a unit similar in design to the Delta but heavier duty, and also a midi-duplicator for benchtop lathes:

http://www.vegawoodworking.com/

I don't see prices on the site, you may have to inquire.

Spindle turning by hand can be fun, and can also be very frustrating if you're trying to teach yourself. A day with a pro might be worth it and very likely be cheaper than any duplicator.

Re: Lathe Duplicators

#3

Re: Lathe Duplicators

Russ Babbitt

>I have the Vega on my 20" longbed Woodfast. I bought it used and at a good price. Setup does take time because I do not use it that often. The cut it makes is a bit rough. That also depends on the speed you turn and the material you are turning. Sharp details are hard to duplicate. Finish turning by hand and/or sanding is required for a good finish. It is up to you to decide if it is worth it or not. What are you turning for? How good can you duplicate, and how many pieces are you duplicating. Some duplicators like the Vega can also do ornamental turning to a certain degree. The Vega is rock solid once mounted. If you do a lot of duplicating and regular turning the Vega can be mounted on the back side of the lathe, you remove the duplicator bed and you can leave the brackets in place.

Re: Lathe Duplicators

#4

Vega *LINK*

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>No affiliation whatsoever, and have not even seen this unit but a Vega duplicator for benchtop lathes is going for $219, see link below. Given Vega's fairly good reputation, and seeing the enlarged pic of the unit, it should be a good buy if you don't need over 10" length capacity. It has a chain drive like it's bigger brother.


VEGA MIDI LATHE DUPLICATOR

Re: Lathe Duplicators

#5

Re: Lathe Duplicators

Ed

>I have a vega duplicator.

I downloaded and quickly read the instructions for the Rockler duplicator that you are looking at.

The vega is significantly more expensive than the Rockler, but it is also much easier to operate and much more capable. If you are only turning out a couple copies of simple work, you woud probably be satisfied with the Rockler. But do you really need a duplictor for a couple copies of something simple?

One problem with all duplictors is that they don't do well on duplicating details at 90 degrees to the work. Like the cheek on a tenon or flats on the top and bottom of a bead. Without going into too much detail, suffice it to say that there are lots of other detail features that are problematic to reproduce.

Unless te work was specifically designed with the duplicator in mind it will need hand turning after duplication. I find the finish suitable for painting right off the duplicator. More traditional wood finishes will benefit from sanding first.

One advantage of the vega is that it can be mounted on the back side of the lathe (with the cutter turned upside down). This leaves the front of the lathe free for hand turning so that you can take care of anything the duplicator couldn't handle before removing the piece from the lathe. This saves a lot of time unmounting and remounting work. It also allows for delivery of completed partial quantities without breaking setup. It did not appear that the Rockler was really suited for that type of use.

There is enough set up time involved in using the duplicator that I only use it if exact replication is absolutely critical or if I'm looking at a LOT of copies.

Ed

Re: Lathe Duplicators

#6

Re: Lathe Duplicators

OB OBrien

>Don. I have the Vega 36 inch pro model and have done quite a few spindles. There is a learning curve which is helped by videos showing you basically how to use the machine. There are several attachments that allow you to do some incredible work. One is a traveling steady rest that holds the spindle while your cutting on it and stops the wood from flexing. Another is an attachment that holds a router instead of an HSS cutter. A spiral attachment for doing spirals and straight fluting or reeding. There are carbide cutters for doing fine detail work and three different stylus to obtain finish work. All this information is not readily known, you have to learn it from someone who has one and knows how to use it. I'm not affiliated with Vega but have enjoyed their willing help and customer service. The one I have is for sale because I am cutting back on my work in order to go fulltiming in an RV. If your interested please contact me privately. If you get one somewhere else I'll still be glad to help you in any way I can. Good luck.

Re: Lathe Duplicators

#7

Re: Lathe Duplicators

John Lucas

>Don You didn't say what you would use it for. You could use a router and an table with a guide to produce some shapes. it cuts cleaner than a duplicator but it won't do fine details very well. If you want'ed to make rolling pins or lamps with long curves and no fine beads it would be great and really fast.

Re: Lathe Duplicators

#8

Re: Lathe Duplicators

John Kyler

>Don,

I have seen both the Vega and the Rockler.

I was going to buy from Mr. Obrien, but my wife had already bought a Vega Pro 36 on the net(found out as I was working out the deal). Although I have not used the Rockler, and I don't know of anyone that has one, if you have to have/or just want a duplicator, I would recommend the Vega. The comments above are valid with it's limitations on square cuts etc.

And I hope to get my Vega on the lathe in the next week or so. Been shoveling too much snow and have not had the time to play YET!