Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

American Elm Vase

Posts

American Elm Vase

#1

American Elm Vase

Allen Neighbors

>This is from a limb crotch above a 38" dia American Elm tree that was felled by a tornado in May last year. It's 11.5" tall X 8.25" dia at the top. The rim is 1/4" thick, tapering down to sidewalls of 1/8" (Had a catch inside that I had to cut away). Bottom is about 3/8" at the thickest part. I think the foot is too wide, but I was afraid it would tip over too easily.

Critiques necessary... photographically, too. :o)


img

Re: American Elm Vase

#2

Re: American Elm Vase Bottom shot 

Allen Neighbors

>


img

Re: American Elm Vase

#3

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: American Elm Vase

Leo Van Der Loo

>Hi Allan, that's a very nice vase from a beautiful piece of wood, looking good.

If I would have been so lucky to have that Oneway lathe and that wood, and your skill, (wow that's a lot) I would have made the vase narrower at the bottom, using that flowing line you used, still I think it is a beaut, thanks for showing.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: American Elm Vase

#4

Steven Antonucci

I think I agree with you...

Steve Antonucci

>with respect to the foot being too big. I suspect that I would have probably worked the foot down to "tippy".

Not meaning to hijack your vessel thread, but I saw an absolutely brilliant solution to this riddle at the Woodturning Center in Philadelphia last week. I forget wwhat the artists name was,but they had turned a tall thin-walled vessel like yours with a disproportionately thick bottom (>1" thick). The vessel sat up perfectly on a rounded bottom, and when touched would gently spin and rock while always uprighting itself. If you know what a Weeble is, that's the dynamics of it.

With such strong grain, are you concerned that this will contort beyond it's current form?

Steve

Re: American Elm Vase

#5

Re: American Elm Vase

Bob Fawcett

>Very nice Allen.

For me, that wonderful grain makes the foot work just as it is.

Re: American Elm Vase

#6

Re: American Elm Vase

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks, Leo, you silver-tongued outfit, I appreciate your kindness. :o) I've seen your work; If you had my talent, you'd be stepping backwards. :o)

Thanks again.

Re: American Elm Vase

#7

Re: I think I agree with you...

Allen Neighbors

>Steve, I've got a weeble bottle. I know exactly what you mean. Wonder if I could jam this back on the jam chuck and give it a try...

I love for things to distort, so it won't bother me if it does..

Thanks for posting. :o)

Re: American Elm Vase

#8

Re: American Elm Vase

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks, Bob. Thinking about turning some more off the foot...

I hollowed this with a Munro-type tool that a friend from Australia made. It worked like a charm. Works better on end grain than anything I've ever used.

I appreciate the comments.

Re: American Elm Vase

#9

Re: American Elm Vase

RevDoug

>Allen, just continue the line you have. It doesn't have to go to a round bottom, but a flat, or "no foot" bottom would do the trick.

You've turned a beautiful piece here. The wood is a definite jewel of a find. Good going my friend.

Turn 'em round,

Re: American Elm Vase

#10

Re: American Elm Vase

Rick Bane

>Allen,

I like the bottom as it is. That's kinda' the way I like to do my vases. I would have made it samller in thickness though. Very nice piece of wood and a nice job of bringing it out!

Rick Bane

Re: American Elm Vase

#11

Re: American Elm Vase

C.W.Stivison

>Very nice piece Allen. I kind of like the foot and my wife(WHO WAS STANDING BEHIND ME WHEN I WAS LOOKING AT IT)liked it alot and I can't remember her ever being wrong. But remmeber I'm a rookie.

Re: American Elm Vase

#12

Re: American Elm Vase

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks, Doug (I may do that.) and Rick, I appreciate the comments.

Re: American Elm Vase

#13

Re: American Elm Vase

Allen Neighbors

>Let�s hear it for the wife!! :o) LOL.

I�m a rookie, too. Soon be three years� my, how time flies� especially when I�m having so much fun. Thanks for the kudos. :o)

Re: American Elm Vase

#14

Re: American Elm Vase

Ron McKinley

>Beautiful wood and great shape. I like my bowls, vases and women to have a good foundation! .......Ron

Re: American Elm Vase

#15

Re: American Elm Vase

RevDoug

>No arguement from me on that. 8)

Turn 'em round,

Re: American Elm Vase

#16

Mike Stafford

Re: American Elm Vase

Mike Stafford

>Very nice, Allen. I love the overall shape but the base seems to be a little large. However I still like the form and finish.

Re: American Elm Vase

#17

Re: American Elm Vase

Fred Bearman

>The shape really works to display that fantastic piece of wood! And for me the foot is just right, leaves a solid feel. Great piece to display this beautiful wood. Thanks.

Fred Bearman

Port Huron, Michigan