We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I'm new, and I'm wondering if I'm doing something wrong. I was rough-turning a 9" diam. x 10" tall beech bowl blank, with some bark inclusions on my Jet mini with a 3/8" bowl gouge (freshly sharpened) and I was getting this low frequency chatter/vibration, no matter what speed I used. The outside rough-turning was fine, and this problem only occurred with the hollowing. I was using the stock 4-screw faceplate with 1.25" screws (0.75" penetration) and no tailstock at the time.
I notice that the beech is very hard, compared to the maple, cedar, pine, & cherry that I've used before, despite the beech being very wet.
Am I pushing the limits of the motor on the Jet mini? Is the cutting location just cantilevered too far from the faceplate, so as to induce more vibration? Other ideas? Thanks in advance.
>Pat, first of all, welcome to WC! One of the first things I would check is be sure the screws have not loosened in the wet wood. That is probably a pretty heavy blank for a mini and I would not be comfortable with only 4 screws holding it, but then I am basically a chicken.
>First, how is the blank oriented? If you are turning end-grain (grain of the tree running parallel to the bed of the lathe), it will be more difficult. From reading your post it sounds as though this started immediately when you started the inside.
However, if not then, how deep have you got inside the bowl? How thin are the walls? How are you making your cut?
The bowl being 10 inches deep has added a lot of pressure on everything, particularily the mounting screws as Carole mentioned. The only suggestion I have is to keep the tool rest as close as possible and stay out of the line of fire.
Maybe some others will comment if you can answer some of these questions?
Help us better understand your question. Is the "chatter" you are experiancing ONLY something associated with your cutting, or is it present when the lathe is turning and you are NOT cutting, too? "Chatter" is the rapid skipping of tool's cutting edge against the wood and may be caused by many things. Vibration, which may exist without cutting, also may be caused by many things. The solution to your problem may depend on whether you have chatter or vibration.
Having said all of that, with a blank extending 10" away from the headstock -- unsuported by the tailstock, I suspect you need a steady rest. A steady rest will help support the weight of the blank and will counteract the side pressure you put on the blank when cutting, greatly reducing chatter (and for that matter, vibration).
>The orientation is end-grain. I essentially trued the outside, and I turned away about 2 inches of depth on the inside, with the wall ~1 inch thick.
The chatter started immediately with hollowing the inside. I'm starting the cut on the wall, riding the bevel toward the inside with the tool rotated about 30 degrees or so. (I think this is the right way, otherwise please correct me!)
I finally decided it was just too deep for a wood so hard on a small lathe, so I parted the blank in half to make 2 bowls instead. I turned the bottom half into a smaller bowl without the chatter, so I think the screws may have had trouble with the exceptionally wet wood and such a heavy blank.
I'd like to turn deeper pieces in the future, so if you have tips for avoiding this problem I'm all-ears. Perhaps orienting the grain parallel to the lathe would help for a piece this deep? Thanks!
>No vibration when not cutting, only when the tool makes contact. Therefore chatter, not vibration. I guess I'll have to check out the "Shop made Bowl Steady for Jet mini lathe" thread, huh.
>I think that I read that you are hollowing into endgrain with the bowl mounted to a faceplate via screws. I'd guess that screws into endgrain is causing your issue, and that the work piece is actually not as securely mounted as you'd believe.
>I'm sorry, I think I misstated the orientation. The grain is perpendicular to the axis of rotation, as with typical faceplate/bowl turning. So, the screws are no into endgrain, but I still think that the screws were not tight enough, due to the wetness of the wood.
Any tips for securely screwing into really wet wood?
>and my opinion is that this is a build in problem with the small mini lathes, and this was/is a bigger problem even with the General International and similar lathes.
The distance between the bearings in the headstock is closer in those than in the Jet, Delta and similar ones that have the pulleys between rather than behind the headstock casting walls.
By using ball bearings and having them so close together, the clearance in the bearings will give the work piece room to start chattering, the longer the wood to be turned the worse it gets, using a steady rest is about the best way to get around this.
Installing the best precision bearings you can get will help some, but they are moving parts and therefore need some clearance to be able to move.
Turning between centers is not a problem or short pieces close by the headstock, but hollowing longer vases and goblets will bring this out in my experience with those mini lathes.
>While I cut from rim to center riding the bevel on cross grain wood, I usually cut from center to wall when I'm deep hollowing an end grain piece. The only way I know to cut this path while riding the bevel is to use a hook or ring tool. Most of the time I just use a round nose scraper tool and forget the bevel. Since I'm the originator of the "steady rest for Jet mini" thread, I naturally think revisiting that thread will solve all your problems and bring peace and happiness to the entire known world. While at the wood show this past weekend, I hollowed 9" into a vase which had a diameter near the base of 2". The steady allowed me to cut that 2" dimension before I started any hollowing.
>wet wood... Sweet Gum... and it slings water out while spinning. I put the 4" faceplate on with 8 screws... #12X 1.24" w/large threads. I shape the outside, and turn a tenon for my chuck. Then I reverse the piece, and core it with the Kel-McNaughton Coring System. I've never had one come loose.
>It has been said that the rule of thumb is to hollow from rim to center with cross grain wood and center to rim with end grain wood. There are pieces of wood that are anti the rule of thumb though. You may have one of those. Make a pass or two in the opposite direction and see what happens. You may very well be surprised. Of course it goes without saying even though it should be, a sharp tool will make a difference. The steady is a great idea. If your screws are the problem, one help is to back all the screws out after marking the face plate and the wood for re-alignment. force a drop of Gorilla glue into each screw hole. Re-install the face plate. Allow the glue to set up over night and then go to it. The moisture in the wood will cause the glue to set up and fill any and all gaps. They will not come out easily. Then again, you don't want them to come out easily, do you?
This has been an interesting discussion to read. You've collected some great tips about cutting with the grain, steady rests, sharp tools, etc... One other posibility is that the base of the surface that contacts the faceplate could be a problem. It actually doesn't want to be flat, but almost flat -- very slightly concave -- so the faceplate contacts securely around the edges to give you the best mechanical advantage.
Whenever using fresh, green wood, re-tightening after a while is a good idea, with both faceplates and chucks.
Cutting technique and precise bevel & edge "attack" angles all improve with time. Sometimes in an effort to ride the bevel, one can RIDE the bevel, and pushing too hard into the wood with the bevel will just perpetuate chatter, and each rotation will produce more chatter. With time and experience, a really sharp tool and a very slight change in tool edge angle can get rid of this. An easier way is to use a scraper, VERY lightly, with the tool tipped down slightly, but cutting a little above center -- just skim off the tops of the chatter marks if you can. Each of these ideas takes practice, but it will all seem second nature soon enough. As any green bowl gets a little thin, it will have a tendency to flex, so you may have to consider that steady, or look into steadying it just a bit with your hand.
Hope you show us what you create -- looks like you have learned a lot on this one (oops -- now two) soon-to-be-beautiful bowl(s).
>... correctly, you are way off the tool rest with a rather small tool. An unsupported cut would cause the vibration/chatter you encountered, and regardless of lathe size and other elements mentioned.
>Thanks for all the tips and suggestions everyone! Man, this group is fantastic.
Brad, Not sure if I mentioned, but I broke the first one with a bad catch after I got the wall too thin cleaning up another catch. :( The second one just came out of the DNA, so I'll let you know in a week or two!
>Pat, I am turning a deep (14") vase on my Powermatic. It would be impossible to do this without my homemade steady, and even with it I'm sure the 12mm Munro hollower has caused some very nice chatter embellishments inside the base..to bad it wont be seen. ;)