Re: Chuck or Face Plate -- kinda long
Brodie Brickey
>From Oneway's website "If your lathe is more than a 16" swing, we recommend our Stronghold Chuck" URL: http://www.oneway.ca/chucks/talon.htm
The Stronghold is intended for blocks larger than 16". If you are going to be doing a lot of turning in that upper range, I'd recommend getting the larger chuck and specifying at time of purchase either the #3 or #4 jaws (since it normally comes with #2 which you already have). I thought the jaws were interchangeable between chucks but it doesn't look like they are going by part numbers on Oneway's site, which is unfortunate.
Yes, you can turn between centers and if you use a forstner bit to "deep seat" the spur drive you can probably turn just fine.
The problem, I believe, comes into play once you've turned your tenon. Once mounted on the chuck, you're now asking the #2 jaws to trust to hold a very big block of wood. Moving up to #3 would help a lot, but would it be enough if you tried to core out a half dried maple bowl blank? It wasn't for me and I have a stronghold, the blank was only 13" in diameter, I sheared the foot off twice with #2 jaws. I went out and bought a #4 jaw set and have been very happy since. I will purchase the #3 set in the near future for other stuff in the middle range, but for now moving up to a very large foot gives me greater options.
If a stronghold isn't in your price range now, faceplate and bring up the tailstock as much as possible until you're down to thinner walls. The faceplate is kinda old school since chucks are so much faster, but they are generally very safe with the right screws. It may take a little more time with a faceplate, but reconstructive surgery takes a lot longer, just ask your Dentist.
May all your turnings be smooth,
Brodie
http://www.SmoothTurning.com