Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ???

Posts

Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ???

#1

Brad Vietje

Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ???

Brad Vietje

>While I'm very glad to have missed out on all the posts about quality, lurkers, and all that, I'm a little concerned because a number of people are posting photos of turning exchange pieces either sent or received...

Aren't we a bit early here ? My note says I ought to send something to arrive the week of Feb 13 - 17. I suppose I thought the week would be one of excitement and anticipation as we all opened up our gifts during the same week ..? Anyhow, if its time to send, I'll send away, but are we diluting the whole thing by spreading out the fun over nearly a month ?

BTW: a very sincere THANK YOU to Ron, Collin & Dennis for all their efforts !

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ???

#2

I Don't Think So

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Brad, according to my instructions, we are supposed to have the exchange item to the recipient during the week of Feb. 13-17. We are supposed to take a digital picture and send it to the organizers using the provided e-mail address. I plan on following the instructions as requested.

Re: Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ???

#3

Re: Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ?

Bill Stehman

>Brad,

The original rules said,

"Turnings should be received by the week of February 13-17, 2007. Plan your mailing accordingly! "

Regardless, I had to mail mine now as I plan to be out of town for awhile, if it ever stops snowing in AZ.

Re: Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ???

#4

Re: Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ?

Kurt Rosenzweig

>I'm sorry if I posted to soon Brad! Just following suit. Plus My piece has already been received. Dammed if I do and dammed if I don't I guess. This whole thing is just getting out of hand. Last time for me thats for sure.

Re: Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ???

#5

Brad Vietje

Snowing in AZ ? Cool ! Or maybe COLD !?!

Brad Vietje

>My plan is to send my piece to arrive at its new home (out near the Rockies...) the week of 2/13 - 2/17, and if something arrives here before then, I'll just have to drool over it, and not open it until 2/13 (I sure hope its got a drool-proof finish!).

Now, let's see if I'm as disciplined as I say I am...

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ???

#6

Re: Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ?

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Brad, I posted this question on the google group site, and it doesn't seem to matter according to Colin. I'd rather not wait that another month, so will be shipping this week sometime.

Re: Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ???

#8

Brad Vietje

OH, Gosh, I don't mean to chastize anybody

Brad Vietje

>I truly was wondering if I wasn't paying attention to a new change or if the plan was to send things any time up till 2/17. Looks to me like up until the date of 2/17 has been the plan all along, and I just fixated on a more restricted arrival date.

I do hope everyone stays in the pool -- this was a lot of fun last year, and no one should feel like they have to create a museum-quality piece to participate. I read only a few of the comments from this past weekend, and I really hope we can all look past the strong opinions, and just have some fun.

Please don't give up, Kurt. Still feels like fun to me!

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ???

#9

Re: Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ?

Ron in Drums PA

>Don't worry about it Brad, it's fine

Re: Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ???

#10

Re: Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ?

Ron in Drums PA

>Please don't feel that way Kurt, Better Early than Never! :)

Re: Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ???

#11

Both!

Bill Stehman

>15 degrees this morning so I will probably loose some palm trees. Palm wood bowls anyone??

Love to go south but I'm on the Mexican border now... oh well.

Re: Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ???

#12

Hang in there Kurt, -long, but a few deserve it.

Greg Haugen

>Kurt, you're response is a sad response. I'm sorry you feel that way. Hang in there. This isn't directed at you.

I'm someone who has planned exchanges for the last two years for my club. Our club has 60 members, we usually have 12-15 people participate in the exchange. This year a few people "played along" and have been turning for less than a year. By the way, our club also has Pam Reilly and Ken Grunke in it and they participated. Two very well known and gifted turners. Not one person complained about a new person that may not "talk" too much at meetings. Not one person fought over who has Ken or Pam, I hope I don't get "_____". It was FUN. The only thing that is good about this exchange is its not titled a "Christmas" exchange. The true meaning of Christmas and "giving" would have been lost a long time ago. If it was I hope someone grabs you by the ear and yanks you around like your mother should have done when you acted like a child. The point is giving and sharing while having FUN. It is a shame that these guys that put this together spent their time and effort and a few of you have turned it into this. If you pulled your name because of a lurker or whatever you want to call people, shame on you. It's an exchange, not a "gallery item for signing up" promotion. News flash-you were a lurker at one time too. You were new to turning or a forum at one time too.

I will be in the exchange next year. I'm excited about it this year. I may send my gift this week because I have two big jobs coming in that will take up space and two demos to plan and prep for Feb. On top of that I'm a full time at home dad and nothing in my shop or house is safe for too long with three daughters, 7 mon, 3, and 5. I'm sorry that may take away from the "shot gun" effect on the Feb. week but its the best for me and someone's piece.

To the guys that planned this. Well Done. Thank you so much.

Anyone who doesn't like my posting, my email is listed. I usually don't for spam. Don't like my posting I have thick skin, bring it.

Lets have some fun while we expand our craft. Come on people!~

Greg

Re: Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ???

#13

Steven Antonucci

Good thing it wasn't a Christmas Exchange...

Steve Antonucci

>because you know someone would have taken it as anti-Hanukah, anti-Diwali, or some other group!

We should make the rules as simple as possible:

If you want to participate, then participate.

If you don't want to participate, then don't participate.

If you want to make the rules, then run the damn thing, but don't complain about how other folks run it.

Sometimes I think people just have too much time on their hands and have to invent a problem so they can invent a solution...

Steve

Re: Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ???

#14

Amen Steve!

Greg Haugen

>

Re: Turning Exchange -- Did I do something wrong ???

#15

Re: Hang in there Kurt, -long, but a few deserve i

Rick Bane

>Greg,

Thanks for saying what I think alot of people have tried to say but ended up going the wrong way. I'm with you!!

Rick Bane

Heath, Ohio