Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT

Posts

Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT

#1

Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT

Bob Way, Canton, MI

>I'm hoping some of you who are really good at this tool making thing might be able to help me out. As an offshoot of my woodturning, I also do some stone turning. I've come to the point where my interest and modest skill level have graduated from "giving it a go" by using high speed steel tools to "I think I'd like to do more of this" using carbide tipped tools. Thing is I haven't found much available tool wise or information wise along the lines of making a few carbide tipped tools.

I've been doing some research and it seems I can either use indexable carbide inserts, or braze carbide tips to steel to make the tools. Beyond that, I've kind of hit a dead end as to what would be involved doing either one. Can any of you suggest a forum, some reading material, other sources you might know of, etc, that might help guide me in taking the next step? I would certainly appreciate it.

Bob Way

Re: Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT

#2

Re: Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Bob, they do sell lathe tools with a carbide insert. I don't know anything about stone turning but a strong shank with a well surported insert would be my first guess. Ebay has inserts at good prices.

Re: Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT

#3

Re: Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT

John Lucas

>The indexable inserts would be very easy to install on a piece of cold roll steel to make your own tools. All you will need is some way to drill and tap threads so you can install the insert. You may have to buy a special screw to fit in the insert without checking I don't know if a standard countersunk screw would fit but I can check.

Re: Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT

#4

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT *LINK*

Leo Van Der Loo

>Hi Bob, I think this stone turning is a very limited specialty thing, and I always have had a desire to do some alabaster turning , didn't get to it, but looked into what was needed, and what I found, just like you, there's just not much out there and one has to build their own tools, depending what type of rock you are going to tackle, picking up old router bids and de-soldering the carbide tips or getting carbide milling inserts, come without holes, and then braze them on steel stock, I think the indexable turning tips are not as suited for stone, as they have scalloped edges good for turning metal, but not shaped for stone IMO.

Max Crimmel did give workshops at one time, you might be able to get in touch with him.

I do have a link to a "stone shop" there might be something of interest there for you, good luck, and if you ever feel like showing your work, I'm all eye's

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


http://www.stonemandist.homestead.com/Index.html

Re: Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT

#5

Re: I would think the worst part....

Jamie Donaldson

>...of turning/cutting stone is not the tool holder, but holding the stone on a lathe? How would one go about mounting it?

Re: Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT

#6

Re: I would think the worst part....

John Lucas

>I asked Rude Osolnik what lathe you should use to turn alabaster and he said "someone elses". Apparently it's corrosive.

Re: Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT

#7

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: I would think the worst part....

Leo Van Der Loo

>Depending the type of stone, the usual way is a lot like wood, drill a hole and grab with pin chuck, turn/scrape/sand the bottom side, glue on a wood waste disk and screw that to a face plate, CA is the glue used with alabaster, then hollow out etc.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT

#8

Leo Van Der Loo

Abrasive for sure

Leo Van Der Loo

>

Re: Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT

#9

Re: I would think the worst part....

Bob Way, Canton, MI

>Leo pretty much covered it. Pin chucks, pin jaws in a chuck, and attaching a mounting block with epoxy or weldbond all work. I am doing a piece at the moment using pin jaws with my chuck, and the jury is still out on that process, at least for me. Up until now, I've always attached a mounting block and kind of like that. Must have something to do with resisting change, or having trouble moving out of my comfort zone.

It's a very fine dust, but heavy. So while a lot falls right down there's a fair amount that will get into every nook and cranny found on a lathe. If there is quartz in the alabaster, and chances are there is at least some, that's the real abrasive part.

It's all scraper work, but the nice part is there are no catches. Didn't mean to get sidetracked, but thought I'd share a little in case someone was curious.

Enjoy your turning.

Bob Way

Re: Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT

#10

Re: Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT

Bob Way, Canton, MI

>Thanks for suggestions. Gee, I always forget about eBay. I'll swing by that way to see what I might find. Thanks for the encouragement, John. I'm no tool maker by any means, but I can do a little grinding, drilling and tapping. And, Leo, the link was real treat. I wasn't familiar with Stoneman, and didn't have a lot of time to look over their site, but it looks like they've got some nice inventory of stone and items. And I'll scrounge you up a photo.

I appreciate you all (or is it "y'all"?) taking the time to help me out with this.

Bob Way

Re: Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT

#11

Re: Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT

Rick in Colgate, Wi

>Most any carbide tipped tool, whether brazed on or with an insert will work well for turning stone. The insert tool holders come in a wide variety of styles including square and rectangular shanks to round bars that would be easy to add a long wooden handle to. If you go the insert route you would also have access to titanium coated inserts which are much more durable than uncoated carbide.

Grizzly industrial has a good supply of these tools and inserts and you should be able to get a good idea of what might work for your purposes. Remember that some insert holders are designed for turning outside diameters and others for inside diameters.

Turning stone sounds like it would be fun to try and I have yard full of gypsum that I could practice on!

Rick

Re: Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT

#12

Re: Tool Making -- kinda, sorta OT

Bob Way, Canton, MI

>Thanks for the suggestion Rick. I've been doing some research on inserts, and I have to admit it has my head spinning a bit what with all the codes and grades associated with them. I'll check out your suggestions. I appreciate you helping me out with this.

Bob Way