Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

Posts

Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

#1

Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Hi,

Is there such a thing as a good general purpose bowl gouge for use with a Jet Mini? For a beginner?

Or, worded another way, with your turning knowledge, what first bowl gouge would you suggest for a newbie wanting to just play around/test/learn on his Jet Mini & Nova G3 chuck.

Thanks,

Joe

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

#2

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

Jeff from MA

>Many folks seem to like to start with the Harbor Freight set, I picked up an inexpensive carbon steel gouge at Sears. IMHO The best gouge will be one that you don't mind watching disappear as you first learn to sharpen and then experiment with the grind variations.

I would guess that more steel left my first bowl gouge in my first three months of turning as left all of my tools in the past 4 years.

Jeff

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

#3

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

Lan Brady

>Joe,

One option, Sears.com has 3/8" bowl gouge for 20 dollars. They are HSS. Learn your sharpening skills on this and then buy the nicer $60+ gouges.

Actually, I have 3 of the Sears gouges and they work great.

One of them has been sharpened really short trying to figure out the grint that works for me.

Good Luck, Lan

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

#4

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Thanks. Never thought of Sears for a cheapo gouge. I hate going in there...

Thanks,

Joe

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

#5

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

eric_s

>FWIW, as a self taught inexperienced truner, I was in the same position a few months ago and went with 1/2" P&N, mostly because of price. I have been very happy with it, it is a big improvement over the HD scraper I was using. I made the handle from an old softball bat. I sometimes wish it was larger.

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

#6

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

John Lucas

>Joe I recommend the Packard brand tools from Packard.I looked at all the bowl gouges at the AAW symposium and decided that this was the best deal. It holds up well and costs less than most. I've been using thier tools for a while.

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

#7

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Is there a particular size you would suggest?

Thanks.

Joe

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

#8

Brad Vietje

John may differ with me but i'd say...

Brad Vietje

>For a mini lathe with a 10" capacity, I'd go for a 3/8" bowl gouge. For a larger lathe, I'd shoot for a 1/2" as my first bowl gouge.

There are differences in flute shapes and all that, but those preferences will develop over time. My first 3/8" bowl gouge is still my favorite, but I now have different size and shaped bowl gouges for different tasks. A good-quality, general purpose gouge with good quality HSS will be useful for a lot of projects. For general use, I like those with a round, "U"-shaped flute. Just be sure to learn how to sharpen it without grinding it all away -- I recommend attending a few club meetings and asking for some assistance if you're not sure how to do that.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

#9

Leo Van Der Loo

Not answering your question directly, but...

Leo Van Der Loo

>have you gone to a turners club and looked and asked how and what, it would be very beneficial to you to do that, look what those turners use and how, OK know how to sharpen is very important, than a good tool is better than a cheap tool.

For a mini lathe a 1/4 or 3/8" bowl gouge is large enough, and you don't need a "long and strong" If you buy a un-handled tool you get more tool for your money, and then you also get some spindle turning practice.

The P&N small gouges run at $25.- to $30.- a piece and are good tools, but there are other choices, just my 2 cents Canadian

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

#10

To add to the confusion

Gordon Seto

>A �" P&N is a 3/8" by English standard.

American manufacturers measure their bowl gouges by the diameter of the round stock. The English measure the width of the flute.

So a 3/8" P&N would be a �" bowl gouge from Sheffield.

Gordon

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

#11

Leo Van Der Loo

and to add, P&N uses 10 mm instead of 3/8"

Leo Van Der Loo

>

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

#12

Brad Vietje

Yup -- forgot about that

Brad Vietje

>So, by recommending a 3/8" bowl gouge, I mean a gouge made from 1/2" stock, but the flute is 3/8" wide, using the English measuring system.

BV

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

#13

Thanks for the info.

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

#14

Re: Yes, there is.

Russ Fairfield

>The beginner has several problems getting started with bowl turning. The bniggest is that they don't have the ability to sharpen the tool or with any degree of repeatabil;ity. The other problem is that most of them are starting with a Mini-Lathe that restricts lowering the tool handle much below horizontal.

My advice is to stay with the "Old Fashioned" straight across grind with a 45-degree bevel. It is an easy profile to grind on a flat tool rest on the grinder, belt sander, or disc sander. It is still the best bowl gouge profile for turning with the tool held horizontal, or parallel with the lathe bed.

Forget about the side grind, and the techniques or jigs to make them until after you have learned the basics of making a smooth cut and sliding the bevel of the tool along the contour of the bowl. There will be plenty of time for jigs and fancy tools after you have learned to do those two things.

If you want to spend the money, the basic Wolverine has a good tool rest that is better than anything that comes with the grinder, and a support for the end of the handle that will make grinding the straight profile easier. If you don't want to spend the money, get a copy of Rowley's book, "A foundation course", and make the adjustab;e tool rest he shows. You will also find this the best beginning woodturning book available (mu opinion). If you want to spend even less money, there are several ways that you can cut a block of woof to make a tool rest that is either fixed or adjustable.

You will have a hard time finding anyone agreeing with me, because they all love their Ellsworth Gouges, and most of them have never used anything else. But, believe me when I tell you that there were a lot of bowls turned by a lot of people using the gouge I describe, and for a lot of years before anybody discovered the side-grind gouge; and the old gouges still work.

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

#15

Re: Another advantage

Russ Fairfield

>Another advantage of using the basic "Straight across" profile is that you can buy a better quality bowl gouge and not have to worry about grionding it all away while learning how to sharpen it. Just make sure to buy on that has that profile already.

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing?

#16

Re: Beginner Bowl Gouge - is there such a thing? *LINK*

Darrell Feltmate

>Joe

A good "beginner" bowl gouge is virtually any 1/4" or 3/8" bowl gouge, sharpened straight across at 45*. For simple sharpening, make my jig and set it up the same way as for a roughing gouge, roll it left to right and you will be done. I would advise against using the holding blocks to form an Irish or long winged grand at first, the straight 45 is far easier to get used to.

That said, I like an Oland tool for bowls and would start with a 1/4". It is easier or at least as easy to use or sharpen. It is also harder to carch. Check my web site for either or both.


Around the Woods