Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

shopvac & sanding

Posts

shopvac & sanding

#1

shopvac & sanding

Leppikallio

>Hello folks.

Sanding dust, the final frontier. In fact noice is the worst problem at the moment. I have one of those cheap dust collectors where is shavings go lower bag and all that dust which should be captured also goes right through that upper bag. Ok, replacing that upper bag would help of course so that dust wouldn't escape. However noice is such a problem that I'm not sure what to do. Basically I can't put in the another room. Moving it to outside is not an option either (5 F degrees this morning and they are seying it will go to -13 this night).

I have been thinking about those (cheap) shop vacs, wet-n-dry vacs, but do you have experience how they work with turning and specially with sanding? I assume those are more quiet (they have to be) but do those move enough air?

Re: shopvac & sanding

#2

Re: shopvac & sanding

Rick Allen

>The top and bottom bags are usually filters. Exceptions to this are when the bottom bag is a plastic trash bag. The point being that both bags should be replaced to limit the migration of sanding dust.

The shop vacs are usually noisy. The noise primarily being high pitched from the universal motor. Some of the shop vacs are not so noisy.

Shop vacs have high static pressure (they suck hard) but low volume (compared to a DC). This makes a shop vac good for cleaning up around the shop but poor for capturing airborne dust. Capturing airborne dust is primarily a function of containment and volume.

The less expensive shop vacs, which are also nosier, are not made for constant use. They are cooled by the same air that passes through the filter. If the input becomes clogged the motor will burn up quickly. If you operate the shop vac for long periods of time (you will go deaf anyway) the motor is likely to overheat. The expensive shop vacs have a fan, which is separate from the exhaust, to cool the motor.

Good Luck

Re: shopvac & sanding

#3

Re: shopvac & sanding

john lucas

>I've sort of gotten use to the noise but don't like it. I just got a noise suppression set of headphones from Bath and Beyond. They change the pitch but don't really get rid of the noise. However they have an amplifier that works with my stereo so I can hear the music very clearly an the noise from the dust collector is reduced somewhat. The problem now is I have to be corded to the stereo. I'm going to buy an MP3player with FM reciever. That way I can tune in my Serius Radio.

I'm not familiar with all the shop vacs out there but all the ones I've worked with are very noisy except the Fein and it's expensive.

I'm going to replace my top bag with a finer micron bag. The bottom bag doesn't seem to loose as much dust through itself but it's really hard to change when full so I'm probably going to rig up a way to put a steel garbage can under there with some sort of adaptor. That will solve the emptying problem and the dust throught that bag.

Re: shopvac & sanding

#4

Re: shopvac & sanding

Jack Savona

>When I first started turning, I used a shopvac. Noisy! Then I invested in a DC and use a "worktunes" headset which allows me to listen to the radio as it quiets the DC noise.

Another alternative I once used near my lathe was a cheap 20" box fan with a washable .3 micron filter in front of it. (The filter came from the Borg.) I now use it continuously on a low setting at the other end of my cellar shop. If you have space for it on the other side of your lathe, I would think it might be a quieter, inexpensive alternative to use with a respirator.

Re: shopvac & sanding

#5

Re: shopvac & sanding *LINK*

Bob Fawcett

>You can probably find a cartridge filter conversion here.

I put one on my DC and it now stops all of the dust I can detect.


Cartridge conversion

Re: shopvac & sanding

#6

Re: shopvac & sanding

Carole Valentine

>My DC for sanding consist of a box fan with a pleated filter set right behind my lathe when I am sanding. Works like a charm. I can blow the filter out a time or two before replacing it. A few months ago, I read an article on one of the mags about DC and the box fan and filters ranked right up there when it came to pulling fine dust out of the air. That's basically all an air cleaner is, I think.

Re: shopvac & sanding

#7

Re: shopvac & sanding

John Lucas

>Carole I think the box fan at the lathe makes more sense than an aircleaner in the ceiling. Your collecting the dust at the source rather than letting it circulate throught the room before it finally reaches the ceiling.

Re: shopvac & sanding

#8

Re: shopvac & sanding

David Breth

>My shop is a small basement shop, beneath our family room. I wasn't able to put my dust collector in another room either, however, I did create some plywood walls to separate it from me. used hard insulation glued to the inside of the walls, and a bunch of insulation in the joists to keep the noise down. Works well. I wouldn't classify it as quiet, but it is way better than it was when unprotected.

The difference was initially being able to hear it in every room of the house, to now you pretty much can't hear it on the second floor. I wear hearing protection.

David B.

Re: shopvac & sanding

#9

Re: shopvac & sanding

Leppikallio

>Thank you very much!

That boxfan with filter sounds good, I think I have to try that. I do have one of those cheap dust filters on ceiling and I could try to move that to closer to lathe & carving "station"... Could be possible to put it on the shelf too. I just don't believe it will be able to catch that ddust cloud but that has to be tested.

Thanks again friends.

Re: shopvac & sanding

#10

Re: shopvac & sanding

Allen Neighbors

>I got a large Heating/AC Squirrel-cage type blower, encased it in plywood, over my lathe. It draws air through 4 AC filters, and the circulated air is such that you can't see any dust in it. In the summer, in addition to the homemade cleaner, I have a floor fan blowing over my shoulder, toward two exhaust fans in a window. Seems to work well for me. (I wish I had used them when I was turning that West Indian Rosewood HF the other day.)

I also have a sanding area built into an old maple meatcutters table. The sanding top is pegboard, the bottom is drawn into a dryer vent hose that is propped against the exhaust fan in the window. It draws the dust down, through the hose, and exhausts it outside. Works well when using a hand sander - off the lathe, of course. :o)