Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Drying bowl blanks Question?

Posts

Drying bowl blanks Question?

#1

Drying bowl blanks Question?

Barry Irby

>A new member of our club told me the following. He made a green bowl blank and cut it into four pie shaped pieces. Put on in a brown paper bag. Put another in a doubled brown paper bag. Third one went in a plastic bag. Last piece was the control and left in the open. Weigh each piece at regular intervals over a two week period. Said the one in the brown bag dried exactly as quickly and the one in the open. The one in the double bag was slowed slightly but not much. The one in the plastic bag basically did not dry at all in two weeks.

Clearly he is a methodical thinker and I have no reason to believe he screwed this up or made some obvious blunder. So if this is correct, why does bagging the blanks in brown paper help? Does it really help or do we just think it does?

He is now drying his blanks in plastic bags with about a 120 eighth inch holes punched in them. Says it slows them down some but still lets them dry.

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

#2

Bob Moffett

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

Bob Moffett

>I put my rough turned bowls in a brown paper bag stuffed full of shavings from the turning and leave 6 months or until I get around to it. The shavings are the same moisture content as the wood and I was told that slows down the drying process. I lose very few bowls using this method. I tried the soap method and didn't like that. I haven't tried the other methods you mention, they may work just as well. O think there are probably as many good ways to dry wood as there are turners. I just found one that works for me.

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

#3

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

Russ Babbitt

>I would think that two weeks is not long enough of a test.

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

#4

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

Bill Weber

>I dry my turnings in a plastic bag with a dry towel or rags and every day or two I change the towel. As the drying continues you need to change the towels less ofen. A completely green wood piece may take several months to dry, but I have had great sucsess with this process. I know this is a slow process but it works very well.

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

#5

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

r thomas

>Barry the paper bag should control/reduce air movement and reduce the cracking.

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

#6

Long, slow (but sure) method

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Barry,

Back before Dave Smith introduced me to Alcohol Drying my roughed out bowls, I used to air dry everything. I would rough turn to 10%, then coat the end grain with anchor seal. After that it got wrapped in a paper bag for a couple weeks. After that, I'd unwrap it and allow the blank to sit for the appropriate amount of time. If it was a BIG bowl, some times that meant a year!

Anyway, about the bagging. It slows the drying process down so that you don't get rapid drying and/or cracks. As others suggested, storing the roughed out bowl shavings does the same thing. It's a matter of controlling the drying rate.

BTW, are you using Alcohol (DNA) to dry your bowls? If not, you might want to give it a crack. I've been using that method for about 2 years (or more) and haven't had an issue with it. Email me if you want more details.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

#7

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

Barry Irby

>I have used paper bags dozens of times with good success and have also used the alcohol method, with good success. I have not tried soap, but only because a friend told a really "funny" (not) story about spilling a huge amount of soap.

I just posted this because I thought it was interesting that Dave had taken so may measurements and that he was sure the paper bag did not slow drying.

I am wondering if it is not about slowing the drying, but evening it out. Perhaps the bag creates a micro climate at fairly high humidity around the blank allowing it to dry evenly, thus not developing as much internal stress and cracks. What do you think?

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

#8

Bob Moffett

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

Bob Moffett

>I think that the paper bag filled with the bowl surrounded by it's shaving does, creats a microclimate the same high humidity as to wood.

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

#9

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

Mike Nelson

>I put the blank upside down on a piece of spindle or what ever that is now permanently glued to a slab of plywood and pour white glue right out of the bottle(a gal. goes a long way) over the bottom. It will flow over the blank evenly. I use my finger to spread the drips around the top and a little into the edge, let it dry, set it on a shelf (also upside down for a week or so) and when it quits loosing weight, turn it.

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

keith tompkins

>Hi Barry, As a turning instructor and demonstrator,I have the opportunity to see lots of turners, and I also get to see pieces they bring to me that have failed. A couple of curious observations:

1. Many of the cracked pieces I've seen were doomed from the start. A close examination of a cracked piece may reveal that a previous check in the wood did damage not obvious to the naked eye...and revealed itself as the blank dried. 2. The blank was unsound in the first place, cracking on a structural fault. 3. Sometimes the turner ignored an obviously flawed or cracked piece that would have been better discarded in the first place. For example, lets say we have a log section with a huge check...I wouldn't attempt to use any wood near the check, even when the checking is cut away and sound wood appears.

What I'm saying is that using sound stock will result in far fewer failures, no matter what method of drying is used. Nothing will save a bad piece of wood. As far as bagging is concerned, I think the paper bag becomes saturated, and cannot disperse moisture as fast as the blank can give it off...a vapor barrior of sorts, slowing the drying process.

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

#11

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I mainly use the method Bill Grumbine suggested many years ago. I put Anchor Seal on the end grain of the roughed out bowl and put it in a paper bag. The top of the bag is rolled down and then put on a shelf in the unheated part of my shop. Since I live on the coast of VA the humidity is usually nice and high for slow drying.

I go back in about a year, unbag the blank and put it back on the shelf until I want to finish turning it. Everything is dated so I always know how long ago the blank was roughed out. I rarely loose a roughed out bowl. I also do this for roughed out hollow forms.

If I am in a hurry I use Dave Smith's alcohol drying and just follow his directions.

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

#12

Dick Hines

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

Dick Hines

>I am still useing the DNA. I don't live to from Barbara so I have the same weather conditions. I have dries cherry, oak pecan, maple,ect. It only take about a month or so to dry the roughed out blanks.

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

#13

Brad Vietje

YES

Brad Vietje

>

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

#14

Brad Vietje

In humid areas shavings ==> Mold

Brad Vietje

>

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

#15

Brad Vietje

Re: Drying bowl blanks Question?

Brad Vietje

>While this method may give you good results, it seems to me like overkill to put white glue on every bowl, but that depends on how big a bowl-drying problem you are trying to solve. Using PVA glue (like Elmer's) is fairly common in the UK, from what I hear. Anchorseal or paste wax seem much more common here. I only wax pieces that are particularly fragile, or rare & expensive. Paper bags and/or cardboard boxes work fine for me in almost every case. Whenever I've added green shavings, I get a moldy mess -- but then it can be pretty humid in spring & summer in Vermont. This is also a decent way to get pieces to spalt if you get a hot, wet summer.

Like Russ wrote above, 2 weeks isn't much time. First you lose free water, which doesn't take very long, but bound water takes a few months.

As Keith wrote, the bag can act to slow down moisture loss, and you'll get more even drying in most cases.

My 3 cents,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT