Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

What a difference a day makes

Posts

What a difference a day makes

#1

What a difference a day makes

Ron in Drums PA

>I bet this is the busiest Sunday WC has ever had.

Re: What a difference a day makes

#2

What the heck happened?

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I _wish_ I had the time to browse through every message for the past few days on the subject, but I don't. From what I gathered while browsing the turning exchange subjects is that a firestorm started over participants who we may not recognize, and whether the top quality work of the most accomplished turners should be what one could expect. Not to minimize the situation, but if that is the thumbnail version, well thats just sad.

I, too would love to be the receipient (to use Russ' example) of one of Clay Foster's "signature" pieces. But I would not expect him to donate one of those amazing things to the exchange. That doesn't mean that turners won't surprise you with their best work - a couple years ago I was delighted and amazed to find not one but TWO Mark Kauder's in my mail, for no reason! I will never forget that kind of generosity and the surprise it brought, and because of that I will be sending one of my best pieces to the receipient who's name I have been sent, even though I have never heard of him, couldn't find a single post from him, nor find his name in any search of this site, or the web in general.

Would I rather send one of my best works to someone I know personally? Sure. But thats not in the spirit of what I signed up for, it would simply be a happy coincidence if I drew a name of one of the people I have met in person here. Do I think I should send something I turned round in a single morning instead? No way.

Perhaps we could at least get a brief bio of the participants next year along with their "registration" into the contest, because I would like to know a little about the person who's receiving something I spent many hours on. I don't care how accomplished they are in this woodturning thing, but it'd be nice to not simply drop my work in the mail, never to know a thing about its final disposition other than a delivery address.

If folks have dropped out, please reconsider, and help to refine the process for next time around.

Anyway, thanks for organizing this, and I hope whoever the guy is that receives my work 1. enjoys it, 2. will let us know a little about himself.

Re: What a difference a day makes

#3

Hey, wait a minute...

Raymond Overman in SC

>What do you mean you couldn't find any of my posts Mike? I've posted some recently. You did get my name didn't you? All you have to do is a quick Google and you can find out all about me. :-)

Re: What a difference a day makes

#4

Mike, everything got changed around

Ruth Niles

>I started the thread and, just like that party game of whispering a saying down the line and it comes out totally unrecognizable at the end of the line, people took what they "thought" and got all bent out of shape.

You wrote: "that a firestorm started over participants who we may not recognize, and whether the top quality work of the most accomplished turners should be what one could expect. Not to minimize the situation, but if that is the thumbnail version, well thats just sad."

You didn't minimize, you maximized! It was not just "not recognize participants", it was not be able to find anywhere, through searches, no opinions posted, no "hi" posted, no pics posted, no nothing! And I clearly stated the top quality work of the most accomplished turners should be what one could NOT expect but rather just one of their fine pieces........meaning everything they do is fine, good, nice and better than I could ever possibly do!

Of course you did state it correctly in your next paragraph, so I forgive you! : ) Referring to Clay Foster signature pieces, you wrote; "But I would not expect him to donate one of those amazing things to the exchange."

The subject of the "quality" of a turning was brought up because of an item that one of the very active members received last year from another active member who did post pics of his/her work and the exchange piece was literally disgraceful. I probably should have said that in my original post so all that rampant misinterpretation didn't happen.

You made a very good suggestion: "Perhaps we could at least get a brief bio of the participants next year along with their "registration" into the contest, because I would like to know a little about the person who's receiving something I spent many hours on. I don't care how accomplished they are in this woodturning thing, but it'd be nice to not simply drop my work in the mail, never to know a thing about its final disposition other than a delivery address." You said it, Mike! That is exactly all anyone asked.

Thanks for the clarity.

Re: What a difference a day makes

#5

Re: Mike, everything got changed around

Russ Fairfield

>Ruth, look at the bright side of this. They were standing outside in the cold and looking in through windows. You got them riled up enough to come in and particilate in the conversation. Many of them brought pictures, and some of their work is good. I hope they will stay.

Almost 300 messages on a Sunday in January, when 50 would be expected, has to be a good thing.

Re: What a difference a day makes

#6

I'm mostly a lurker...

Clem Wixted, Jonesboro, AR

>...and I will probably remain one.

And, I'm not going to get involved in any exchange so no one will be getting any of my lousy work! :-)

Clem

Re: What a difference a day makes

#7

Re: It is a shame that things got ...

Jamie Donaldson

>... all changed around to lurkers, etc. but as I am an optimist, I would like to think that all participants would send examples of their best work- why represent yourself any other way? I have a suggestion for consideration-as a collector I want a bio or some artist's statement from the artist for every piece. This provenance is an important document and adds value to that piece. When we make exchanges, each person should include a similar bio or artist's statement in the exchange. It might be a good incentive for some of us to spend some time recording and updating our journey down this path paved with shavings!

Re: What a difference a day makes

#8

Re: Mike, everything got changed around

Rick in Colgate, Wi

>I decided not to enter the exchange for exactly the reasons that Mike and Ruth have brought up. How could they or any other active member of WC feel comfortable sending a piece of their work off to someone who has seldom or never represented themselves on the WC forums either thru comments or pictures of work?

If there was a "lurkers gathering", would anyone show up?:)

Back to the shadows, for now!

Rick

Re: What a difference a day makes

#9

Notice of Acceptance

Ron in Drums PA

>Mike, Ruth and Jamie

Thank you for volunteering to help with this new project.

Your new duties are as follows.

Accepting Bios

Reviewing Bios

Validating Bios

and of course making sure the Bios are posted in the proper place.

Considering that Dennis and Colin spent at least 6 hours each dealing with addresses and making sure everyone received a proper mailing address, you have a daunting job in front of you. One that I do not envy.

I would guess that each of you have at least 35-40 hours worth of work in front of you. Please feel free to solicit as many volunteers as you see fit to make your job easier.

If I can be of assistance, please let me know, I will do what ever I can to make your task as simple as possible

Yours Truly

Ron Sardo

Re: What a difference a day makes

#10

Re: Notice of Acceptance

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Ron, I very much hope you didn't take my message this morning to be one of criticism for your work as nothing could be further from the truth.

My suggestion that a bio be given with the piece does not need any sort of acceptance/review/receipt procedure. All it takes is a little note inserted with the exchange piece as it mailed to the receipient. I was simply conveying my desire to know a little more about the person than simply a name and an address.

BTW, I believe you have a picture of the piece I am sending to my exchange partner but did not see it listed with the rest. Please let me know if you need another copy.

And thanks once again, I was really excited to see the exchange happen this year and appreciate your hard work.

Re: What a difference a day makes

#11

Re: The only documentation required....

Jamie Donaldson

>.. is generated by the exchanging parties and travels with the work. No committees needed, so you can't pass the buck because there is none! Just keep on keepin' on-you're doing fine! Meeting adjourned.

Re: What a difference a day makes

#12

Please read ....

Ron in Drums PA

>the fifth bulleted rule.

http://www.simplyturning.com/wte07/rules.html

Re: What a difference a day makes

#13

Jamie, that is such a perfect suggestion!

Ruth Niles

>