Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Flushing out the Lurkers

Posts

Flushing out the Lurkers

#1

Flushing out the Lurkers

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Ha ha, I know this is going to get some attention! I did not post this to throw bombs, but I am posting it seperately so that it will not be lost in the huge thread on lurkers.

I have my own perspective on lurkers, since I have met many over the years. People write me, people come to my shop for lessons, and they come to my picnics. It is just that interaction - especially the class time and the picnics - that often serves to draw people out and into posting on this and other forums. I read through the other thread quickly, and all I am going to say is I personally know some lurkers who do very nice work, and I have seen some very well known names on stuff that would go into my wood furnace - nobody here you understand, but well known just the same.

I don't think anyone should be made to feel ashamed of their work, unless of course, they are misrepresenting it themselves. I for one live in dread that one day people are going to finally realize that my stuff is nowhere near as good as they thought it was. I am always thrilled when people admire the things I make, and it should be so with everyone here, regardless of their skill level. We all started at the beginning. Some of us go one way and some another. Post count is not related to skill at the lathe. I elected not to participate this year because of being so busy I would not have time to do this exchange justice, but I wrote Ron this morning and offered to step in and replace whoever it was that dropped out. So watch out, you might be stuck with something from me if Ron takes me up!

And to all you lurkers, keep on lurking if that is what makes you comfortable. There are no rules for reading, and the rules for the exchange were clearly posted. And one day maybe we will entice you into posting some of your own thoughts and work. See you at the picnics!

Bill

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

#2

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

Dawn Adams

>Bill -

I would be lucky if you got my name to send to. I can always hope!

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

#3

Steve Kubien

Well said Bill...

Steve Kubien

>As a newbie to turning and a mostly lurker who needs to absorb more info than he can possibly add, thanks for this Bill. I was starting to worry that no matter what I produced (certainly won't be 'gallery' quality but I'll do my best) it may not be appreciated because I'm a nobody.

Again, thanks.

Steve Kubien

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

#4

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

Bruce Forrest

>I don't know what the precise cutoff for defining a "lurker" is. But on this site, I probably am one. I pipe up infrequently, probably less than half a dozen times a year.

This whole discussion reminds me of the story of the 7 year old boy who has not uttered one word in his whole life. His parents are frantic and have dragged the lad to all sorts of specialists to no avail.

Suddenly one morning at breakfast, the boy shouts out "This toast is burnt." His mother bursts into tears and hugs him. When she regains some sort of control, she asks him why he hasn't talked before.

The little boy replies, "Up until now everything's been OK."

I thnk there's a bit of an analogy, but what do I know? I'm just a lurker.

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

#5

Welcome: Lurkers, Takers, Newbies

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>I welcome all of the above because I are one or have been! With forty years of industrial, commercial, and institutional maintenance experience I am much more qualified to tell you how to fix your furnace than how to turn wood. I have taken two bowl turning classes during the last twelve months, but finished my first one ONLY two weeks ago!

I brought a door prise to the WC lunch at Louisville and assisted in the kid's room, we attended TD's Gathering, and I donated ambrosia maple to the auction at the Florida Symposium last weekend. Therefore I am NOT a taker anymore.

I am larger than Bill Grumbine, however turning bowls has intimidated me. I guess that all 390# of me are afraid of a little ol' bowl. However when Lyle Jamison picked up my very first finished bowl during the Instant Gallery at the Fla Symposium this past Saturday, I got really scared. But he thought that I had turned an excellent bowl. Hallalujah, I guess that I can claim to be a turner now also! Now I need to become better at pictures. My first bowl is spalted, wormy, ambrosia, curly red maple from WNC, 6.75" x 1.5" finished with three coats of Liberon oil and Renaisance wax, hand buffed. Single turned from dry wood.

IS IT TOO LATE TO GET INTO THE EXCHANGE??

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains


img

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

#6

Re: Welcome: Lurkers, Takers, Newbies

David Galloway

>Congratulations Bill. Where in WNC are you? Have you taken any course at the JCCampbell Folk School?

Again, congratulations!

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

#7

Re: Welcome: Lurkers, Takers, Newbies

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>We are close to Hendersonville. Wife and I took a weekend bowl class at Arrowmont this October. We really loved the school, and plan to go again after we save MORE money,

Bill in WNC mountains

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

#8

Bob Moffett

Re: Welcome: Lurkers, Takers, Newbies

Bob Moffett

>Bill,

The Carolina Mountain Woodturners club is in your area. It is a great club which regularly has big name demonstrators. If you could attend their meeting, I think you would enjoy them.

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

#9

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

Mike Nelson

>Thanks Bill. I did not join the exchange because of a medical condition, chronic procrastination but I am beginning to regret that indecision after reading and viewing the latest post. I wonder how many more unique personalities not to mention talented turners are out there. I say come on in, the waters fine.

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

#10

Re: Welcome: Lurkers, Takers, Newbies

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>I have been a member of CMW for four years, there yesterday. I am just scared of bowls. I can make toothpicks with the best of them

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

#11

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

Allen Neighbors

>That's one of my favorite stories. :o) It's always funny, no matter how many times you hear it.

Welcome, Mr. Lurker.

Welcome, all Lurkers.

I used to couldn't spell lurker. Then I found out I was one. Then I began to post a few. Now I aren't.

Well said, Bill Grumbine!!

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

#12

Re: Bill- I'd love to have you in my class....

Jamie Donaldson

>.. at the Folk School in March. I'll have you turning square bowls in a week, and the food at J.Campbell is better than Arrowmont! Give it consideration, and check out the opportunities for your wife to take a class as well.

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

#13

Re: The other thread was so wrong

nathan murphey

>The other thread is the reason I would not get into one of the exchanges. I hardly ever post---normally only when no one else will comment then I will try to answer if I can. I have never had a class or posted a picture, but know how to read and surf the web to find answers to almost any question. I believe my work is as good or better than a lot shown here. I will probably never sell my work because I just would just rather give it away and keep it a hobby.

As always everything I've ever seen on this forum and others points to Bill as being one of friendliest people out there.

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

#14

A better term?

Carole Valentine

>Bill, I had to laugh at your subject line. I am actually tickled to death that so many folks have come forward and posted pics, questions or comments as a result of the various threads. You always get sparks when you throw a log on the fire, but it sure brightens up the room on a cold January day.

I have been thinking about this term "lurker." There are several definitions of the word. In the Internet Culture it is generally defined as "a person who reads discussions on a message board, newsgroup, chatroom, file sharing or other interactive system, but rarely participates." (multiple sources) Another, non-Internet related and more sinister definition is "someone waiting in concealment", thus the negative connotation even when the term is used as first defined. I seriously doubt anyone who frequents WC falls under the second definition. At least I hope not! Perhaps a term that would not offend anyone is a "ROM" - a Read Only Member. And being a ROM, by the way, has absolutely no correlation to one's skills as a turner, and a certain level of turning skill is in no way a prerequisite for participating in the exchange. But, as with any gift exchange, it sure would be nice if each sender and each recipient knew a little something about the person on the other end.

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

#15

Exactly , Carole. My definition of a lurker

Don Henthorn

>is one who has never posted. I hope my comments yesterday were viewed in that light.

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

#16

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

DD

>Why is there a need to identify them ("lurkers", "ROMs", whatever) in the first place? Don't understand it.

Doug Dubowski

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

#17

Re: A better term?

DD

>I initially posted this to the wrong response, so I'll repeat it here where I wanted it in the first place.

Why is there even a need to identify or label those who either don't post or post infrequently (lurker, ROM, whatever)? I don't understand it.

Doug Dubowski

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

#18

Ellis Walentine

To paraphrase Sting...

Ellis Walentine

>... lurkers love their children, too. :-)

"Lurker" is really an unfortunate term -- ugly sounding and with negative connotations. It doesn't do justice to all the quiet readers that frequent the forum. Visitors who seldom post are as welcome as the most prolific posters; that's the beauty of the forum format as a vehicle for sharing information. We're all somewhere on the learning curve -- many curves, actually -- and I think I can say with certainty that even the most advanced turners among us learns something new or finds inspiration in reading others' posts.

I'm not sure what to think of the relevance of lurking to the turning exchange, but uncertainty has never stopped me from rattling off a few thoughts. :-) I suspect that most people joined the exchange because they (consciously or not) think they do nice work and would like to trade a piece of theirs for a piece of someone else's, without expectation of gain or advantage. Such an exchange is always going to be lopsided and something of a crapshoot, but that's part of the fun and it speaks to the mutual respect that people have for each other, regardless of turning experience or ability. I prefer to think that nobody is consciously taking advantage, whether or not they post a lot. This forum and community have always been governed by the more-or-less unspoken rules of decency and fairness and respect. Everyone gets the benefit of the doubt.

I think the concept of doing your "best" work for the Turning Exchange should be tempered by common sense. Personally, I view it as applying my current standards of design and workmanship to a piece that I can complete in a day or less. I simply don't have the time to do more than that. My "best" work might be something that involves construction or carving or extensive decoration or something that could take days or weeks to accomplish -- clearly too much work for an exchange item -- and I don't think anyone expects it.

I applaud Ron and his team for their prodigious efforts on this project, and I'm delighted that WoodCentral can help facilitate it. And, I welcome all well-intentioned lurkers to join in. Strangers are only friends we haven't met yet.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Flushing out the Lurkers

#19

Re: To paraphrase Sting...

Halsey

>Thank you Ellis as I was starting to feel unwelcome as I always enjoy reading and learning from the forum. Halsey