Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Dust Collector Muffler *LINK*

Posts

Dust Collector Muffler *LINK*

#1

Brian McKearney

Dust Collector Muffler *LINK*

Brian McKearney

>This is slightly off the topic of turning, but I do use my dust collector while power sanding my bowls. Yesterday, I received a copy of Penn State's catalog and noticed that they carry a "Dust Collector Muffler" that claims to reduce noise by 5-10db (up to 50%).

First question - is this a gimmick or will it really work?

Second question - Anyone know of any plans for how to make one myself? I think I've seen plans for shop vac mufflers, but can't remember where - I would imagine that this would just be an overgrown version of that?

Thoughts and suggestions?

Brian


Suppressor Dust Collector Muffler

Re: Dust Collector Muffler *LINK*

#2

Re: Dust Collector Muffler

Carole Valentine

>Thanks for asking that question, Brian. One of the reasons I have not installed a DC yet is the noise. I will be watching the replies to this thread.

Re: Dust Collector Muffler *LINK*

#3

Re: Dust Collector Muffler *LINK*

Bob Fawcett

>This may be the muffler plan you saw.

Its built similar to the old glasspack car mufflers.


Bill Pentz's muffler

Re: Dust Collector Muffler *LINK*

#4

Re: Dust Collector Muffler

Harvey Brooks, Victoria, BC

>When WOOD magazine published their plans for a shop made cyclone, they had a muffler attached as part of their system. It was in issue 100, Nov 1997. Should at least give you a starting point to fabricate your own.

Harvey

Re: Dust Collector Muffler *LINK*

#5

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Dust Collector Muffler Don't bother

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>I bought one for my Penn State 2hp DC last Spring. Took sound level readings before installation (92 dBA, regardless of PS's low noise claim) and then installed the muffler. Same 92 dBA after installation. NO CHANGE!

Called Penn State, and was transferred to 'engineering.' "Engineer' said I should have talked to them first, because the muffler wouldn't work on a cartridge DC - it's the cartridge that lets the most noise through. I commented that their ads didn't mention that, I wanted to return the muffler. 'Engineer' said no. After a bit heated conversation, I was transferred to Customer Service. CS rep finaly authorized the return. I paid return shipping. PS then charged me a 20% re-stocking fee. So, MY MISTAKE (according to PC) cost me shipping both ways, and a restocking fee - about $35.00.

I wouldn't bother with the muffler. OTOH, the DC-2000 does work pretty well.

Jim D.

Re: Dust Collector Muffler *LINK*

#6

Brian McKearney

Re: Dust Collector Muffler Don't bother

Brian McKearney

>Jim,

The Penn State DC2000 looks pretty much the same as the one that I have - mine is the Delta 1.5 HP, but I have bags instead of the cartridge. You mentioned that the Penn State engineer indicated that the muffler won't help with a cartridge system, but do you think that it would reduce noise on a unit with two bags?

Just curious...

Brian

Re: Dust Collector Muffler *LINK*

#7

Re: Dust Collector Muffler Don't bother

Jamie Donaldson

>I seriously doubt that this type of device used in this manner could affect any noise reduction in a DC system. A better practical solution I devised is a sound absorbing 3 sided baffle around my DC, shielding my work area from the majority of the direct sound.

Re: Dust Collector Muffler *LINK*

#8

Re: Dust Collector Muffler

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>As one of the only two people here to post a reply, that actually has/had a Penn State DC Muffler, I add my contrary opinion.

I bought it last year to add to my 1.5HP Grizzly DC. My DC is in a storage room attached to the shed. The whole reason for building the storage room, was to move the DC and the Air Compressor out of the shop because of the noise. The DC was converted to a cartridge filter a few years ago (good move), and uses a regular heavy duty garbage bag on the bottom that I throw away with each pile of dust.

I did not run a decibel check before and after, just my perception while listening.

MY OPINION: I find the DC to be much quieter. I feel that it has taken away much of the high frequency noise. The lower frequency noise, is about the same, but I find it much more tolerable - it usually fades into the background noise of the tools, wind, traffic, etc.

It is quiet enough, that I now have to have red light on the DC switch in the shop, so that I do not leave it on when not needed.

Just my opinion. Does it cut down the noise, yes. Is it worth the cost? Only you can say.

Mark

Re: Dust Collector Muffler *LINK*

#9

Mark, Could you 'splain that one more time?

Barry Irby

>I read your post two or three times. Let me get his straight. You have the muffler. You have your DC in a separate closet. It�s quiet enough that you have a reminder light on it. You BELIEVE it knocks out some of the high pitched stuff. What is the �contrary� part? Sounds like �yes, we have no bananas.�

I also put my DC and Air compressor outside and am pretty happy with that. Gets the noise and dust out there.

Re: Dust Collector Muffler *LINK*

#10

Brian McKearney

Re: Dust Collector Muffler

Brian McKearney

>Thanks for all the great replies - sounds to me like it may at least be worth a try. I know that the muffler makes a huge difference on my Ridgid Shop Vac. Haven't decided if I'll purchase or attempt to make my own, but seems worth consideration.

Thanks!

Brian

Re: Dust Collector Muffler *LINK*

#11

Re: Mark, Could you 'splain that one more time?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Barry,

I was stating a contrary opinion to Jim D. Who also had one.

BTW, Look for an email from me.

Mark