Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

A true beaut, for your pleasure

Posts

A true beaut, for your pleasure

#1

A true beaut, for your pleasure

David Breth

>I turned this thing out a couple of days ago, experimentally, just to get a feel for putting a finial on a box (my first finial). It is so painful to look at, that I felt compelled to share. I'm thinking you can offer comments, try to name it, or maybe post photos of some of your ugliest. Either way, lets have a little fun.

The box is about three inches tall including the finial. The finial is cucumber, I have no idea what the wood of the box is, it was given me some time ago as practice wood, and I think it was an old handle or something.

Here's my critique. It looks like a round-topped garbage can with a hopelessly disporportionate giant Christmas Tree sticking out the top of it. I don't think the photo does the contrast between the two wood types justice, but you can believe me when I tell you it is severe, perhaps painful. The cucumber is very, very green, the box is very very not. My wife's response (ever the optimist and eternal encourager) said "I like the shape of the box." Proof positive that you can't get an honest critique at home. I mean, if I can bring it out of the shop and barely stand to look at it....

Recommend that you put on your rose-colored sunglasses before you look...

David B.


img

Re: A true beaut, for your pleasure

#2

Re: A true beaut, for your pleasure

John Bussom

>I agree with the wife, the box looks good!

then you put the finale on! finale? whats that mean..... the end?

I'd show pic's of my uglys but I found a way around them, just keep turning till it breaks or stick the skew right to it and gouge it deep, then I have an excuse for it going to the firebox!

John

Re: A true beaut, for your pleasure

#3

You're a brave man, Dave

Cyril Griesbach

>

Re: A true beaut, for your pleasure

#4

Porn Alert: Moderator remove this post.

Barry Irby

>Looks a little phallic to me. Perhaps you could "cover" it with one of those latex devices meant to prevent disease that may or may not prevent pregnancy. Haven�t seen one in a long time, but don�t some of them have a little �receptacle� in the end that would be just right for the finial?

Can�t believe I posted this under my own name.

Re: A true beaut, for your pleasure

#5

Re: A true beaut, for your pleasure

john lucas

>David I like the box. I'll agree the finial is ugly but hey we've all done that. Hopefully you can pop it off and make another one. I think the finial color is at least part of the problem it just doesn't work with the color and grain of the box.

I would like to see just a little more taper to the box or possibly a slight curve going all the way to the bottom.

I've probably made a dozen boxes over the years that don't look as good as yours. The important thing is you've learned to evalutate it. I think that's the best thing we can do with or without outside critic's. Just look at every piece, good or bad, and say what could I have done better.

Re: A true beaut, for your pleasure

#6

Re: A true beaut, for your pleasure

Carole Valentine

>David, I agree with you wife. I don't think the shape of the box is that bad. It's just that the "thing on top" is uh....well never mind. ;)) Just keep making different finials/knobs until you come up with one that complements the box. I have a whole bowl full of those things and still have not learned to do one to my satisfaction, but I keep trying.

Re: A true beaut, for your pleasure

#7

A Little Thing About Women.............

Barry Turner

>I like the shape of the box. The finial is way too big and thick. I'm not sure these two woods are meant to be together, either. The colors don't seem to comliment each other. How about something out of cocobolo or ebony?

Appreciate your wife, but don't rely on her for an honest critique of your work. Mine always says she likes mine......no matter what it is or how crappy it is. Wives are just not gonna tell you the painful truth.

Like I learned, painfully, many years ago, if the wife ever asks, "Honey, do these pants make by butt look big?" Well, my good man, the answer is always, "No." End of story.

Re: A true beaut, for your pleasure

#8

Re: Porn Alert: Moderator remove this post.

David Breth

>Barry - that was pretty hysterical. I was laughing as I read it. "Why are you laughing, daddy??" "Nothing, nothing, honey."

David B.

Re: A true beaut, for your pleasure

#9

Re: A true beaut, for your pleasure

David Breth

>Thanks for the notes, everybody. I thought a little levity was in order.

I appreciate the constructive notes within the comments as well. My wife and daughter love everything I spin on the lathe - even the total junk. I pretty much look at each piece and evaluate - what could I have done differently/better. It's only been two years, and I'm trying to show myself a critical eye to improve.

I thought the box was ok in shape, taper woudl have helped, though I wasn't really paying much attention to that. And I paid less attention to the interior, which mysteriously isn't photographed.

The little box does have a home now. It belongs officially to my daughters' doll. Ella seems to be very happy with it, but then her eyes are plastic and shut most of the time anyway.

Thanks again -

David Breth