Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

My Take

Posts

My Take

#1

My Take

Ron in Drums PA

>One of the rules of the exchange stated, "This is a fun exchange of turnings between friends, not an exchange of comparative value items or a contest."

The first day of the sign up we had 29 people join. I was surprised that day because there where a few people I didn't know. I took a moment, sat back and gave it some thought. I decided to let them join because of the above rule. I posted an up to date list so everybody knew who signed up and made it available online. I posted on WC and made sure everybody was aware that it existed and how to find it. Nobody complained.

The days continued with more people joining. Just about every email we received said things like "Thanks for taking this on", "You Guys Are Great", "This is going to be fun" "Sign me up I want to be part of the fun" and so on. As the list grew, we received dozens more positive comments. I wasn't surprised, turners are some of the best people around. I knew I had made the right decision.

The list grew to 93 people from 6 different countries. The deadline came and names where randomly matched. Dennis and Colin completed the huge task of contacting everyone. All was good, I was feeling pretty happy.

An exchange like this accomplishes many different things. One of best is that it helps our WC family grow not only in size but also closer. There is a good chance new friends will be made along the way and that is what its all about.

Then I get an email from someone who wants to back out because of the diplomatic thread. His reason, "I don't want to disappoint anybody"

Has WC become a closed group?

Do we really want people to be afraid to join in?

Is this really what we are trying to accomplish here?

There where a group of people who expressed positive comments today and I want to thank them. You really lifted my spirits.

One person backing out creates a logistic problem that effects three people.

To the people who expressed negative views, I want to ask you this.

If you didn't like the rules, why did you sign up?

Or better yet, why did you wait until now to express your views and not before the sign up closed?

I'm disappointed.

The exchange is still on.

Please, no more resignations.

I'll be in touch with those that where effected.

Re: My Take

#2

Re: My Take

George Van

>I did comment when I signed up Ron. �Thanks for getting this started Dave. Due to health reasons I was unable to participate last year, I look forward to this one!�. I still look forward to the exchange. I went into this with one expectation, that it would be fun to give something I turned to another WC�r. Thanks to you all for your time spent organizing this.

Re: My Take

#3

Re: My Take

Cyril Griesbach

>George, you are so right. It will be fun to give something to another WC'er.

Cyril

Re: My Take

#4

Re: My Take

Russ Fairfield

>"This is a fun exchange of turnings between friends, not an exchange of comparative value items or a contest."

Ron, I too am disappointed, not in Ruth for asking the question, but in the tone of too many of the responses. This is not about getting something for nothing, it has nothing to do with the value of the work received, and it is definitely not a contest. This will be the last exchange if those things become important.

I thought Carole's response and calling them "opportunists" was over the top when I read it. But then I read the 99 messages that followed it. Several people implied, but only one of them was brave enough to state that they expected the professional woodturner to "give their highest value work". That is saying they expect someone to send a piece worth several thousand dollars to someone they don't even know, all in keeping with the spirit of the exchange. Now if that isn't being an "opportunist", wanting to get something for nothing, I don't know of a better description.

Personally, I don't see that any of this matters. I wouldn't expect Clay Foster, or someone of equal stature, to send me something worth several thousand dollare, and neither should anyone else. I would be happy to receive Clay's weed-pot, and for no other reason than that he made it, and has signed his name on the bottom. But then, I am not in this exchange for the money, and nobody else should be either.

The opposite is also true. I don't expect a Clay Foster work of art from a beginning woodturner. Whatever and by whomever, it will occupy the same place in my collection of turned wood. And. maybe I will get lucky and receive a piece of the early work of someone who isn't famous yet, and before they command prices I can't afford. It might not be obvious, but even Clay was a beginner at one time. (I sure hope Clay doesn't mind my using his name)

How about getting back to the exchange?? Send what you want. If the recipient doesn't appreciate it, that's their problem. This is not a contest, and it is not about the money. It IS about a friendly exchange, becoming a part of a larger community, and an opportunity to make new friends. Sieze this opportunity, and quit your bellyaching.

Re: My Take

#5

Re: My Take

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Ron, I wouldn't get too upset over the thread. You Collin and Dennis have done a bang-up job. I think the reason the lurker(person who NEVER posts) issue did not come up before was that it probably did not occur to anyone. Who thinks about lurkers; as far as we know they are not there.

As usual when a sensitive issue comes up there are a number of people who skim the original post and those which follow; they get all emotional. All they can think about is defending themselves even though no defense is requested or necessary. It just clouds the discussion and usually ends in misunderstandings.

If a new turner has dropped out because they are afraid of disappointing the recipient of their turning then their fears are self inflicted. Never has anyone said they were disappointed in a beginners piece. Apparently some people received unfinished, defective (hole in bottom) and otherwise sloppy work. I don't think these problems were/are associated with or restricted to beginners.

I would hope that those who dropped out will consider re-joining the group for the exchange. I would also hope that everyone who has taken offense or been hurt by the thread take a deep breath and go back and re-read the original post.

Re: My Take

#6

Re: My Take

john lucas

>Russ Nailed it again. This is an exchange among friends. Some we don't even know are friends yet. It you get a piece from someone you don't know that is an opportunity to make a new friend. It's not really about getting the piece, whatever the level of skill, it's about making friends.

Thanks everyone for organizing this thing. I know it's a lot of work but a lot of people are going to enjoy it.

Re: My Take

#7

Re: My Take

Raymond Overman in SC

>I sure am glad a semi-lurker (and I mean no offense by that) joined last year. I had never seen Bill Stehman post here nor had I seen his work here last year, yet I feel like I was extremely lucky to receive his exchange.

Just because someone doesn't like to type but enjoys reading doesn't mean he/she doesn't produce quality work. My recipient this year couldn't be found in the post searches. However, a quick google says that whoever is recieving his peice will be getting a gem.

I for one am all in and will be sending a piece that is representative of my current work. Whether it's perceived as good, bad, or ugly, it will be sent with the best intentions and I will feel like I'm giving to a personal friend.

Re: My Take

#8

Re: My Take

Barry Irby

>I did not participate in the exchange. It brings up "issues" for me. I really struggle with gift giving and end up often feeling badly about it. If I give you a key ring and you give me the car and the keys, I feel awful. I don't feel like I "Won". I feel that somehow I took advantage of you. OTOH, if I give you the car and you give me the key ring, I feel like I have been had.

It would be ridiculous for Clay Foster or Any other turner who commands big prices for their work to exchange one of theirs for one of mine. What makes this hard to fathom is that people who command big prices have worked hard to position themselves in the market and develop the skills and reputation to command those prices. Now they are in a touchy spot. If they send you the weed pot or sort of off the cuff piece, it contributes to their body of work and their reputation. They are under pressure to hold their standards high.

I have been sitting here thinking about this. I said �It would be ridiculous for Clay Foster or Any other turner who commands big prices for their work to exchange one of theirs for one of mine.� There is an exception. That is: unless they wanted to. They play the game, they take their chances. They are big boys and girls and should have sense enough to know what they want to do with their turnings. Next time one of these happens I think I will participate.

Re: My Take

#9

Thanks go to Ron, Colin and Dennis

Jake Niedling

>Ron - You, Colin and Dennis have done a wonderful job in organizing and making this exchange happen. It is very much appreciated. I look forward to this and perhaps getting to know a few people a little better. Thanks again to Ya'll.

Re: My Take

#10

Re: My Take

Rick Bane

>Ron,

I want to start out by saying thanks for all the work to get the exchange going. I'm glad to have entered-untill reading the thread from yeaterday! WOW!! I entered that exchange as someone who wanted to get to know more people on this site. But people will be people and I see that some cant seem to play well with others!!! I am so disappointed with all the people who are looking to what they receive instead of what they are giving. Thats not what the exchange was about as far as I was concerned. Rick Bane

Re: My Take

#11

Barb Siddiqui

good conclusion

Barb Siddiqui

>That issue is for Them to decide. It is a little intimidating to think of a beginner's work being "added to my collection." On the other hand, it may be a fine example of early efforts, and could be followed up later by another example. Next year, when I have something to offer, I'm definitely in on this. It just sounds downright fun, and I appreciate the effort to keep it going.

Re: My Take

#12

Re: My Take

Fred Bearman

>From my point of view, I am so glad that you have continued this exchange. Like last year, I will be participating as an observer - health issues happened, and though I wanted to participate, it is not possible this year. I don't post much here, and to a large degree it is because all I would have to say has already been said, or my comment wouldn't add anything positive - but I am here everyday looking and reading, usually more than once a day. There are people here that I particularly look for their posts, and maybe consider them to be friends. But just because somebody is not a regular poster doesn't make them anything less - I saw pieces in last year's gallery by people that I had never heard of that just blew me anyway. Some participate in one way, some another. One of my biggest sources of enjoyment was the Katrina auction - the pieces that were put up and the spirit in which they were put up was incredible, and I was fortunate enough to obtain pieces by Carol

Valentine and Steve Antonucci. I enjoy those pieces very much and consider myself fortunate to have them, but even more so, I enjoy reading their posts and seeing their work, because of what has now established some sort of a bond (at least on my part). Steve was so generous in including several other pieces and an assortment of beautiful oak pen blanks with his piece, and I think fondly of him and the experience every time I turn one (and I am constantly amazed by the beauty of this wood). But you know, one of the best and most interesting things about this current discussion, and I think one of the things that sets WoodCentral apart, is the fact that there are different opinions, different enough that in some groups people would pack up their sandboxes and leave, but here we listen with mutual respect, feel free to express our opinions, and when it is all over, we are still here together, as much as before. And now you see why I don't post much - I tend to be wordy and would use up too much bandwidth.

Thankful for this group, and the opportunity to be me within this group.

Fred Bearman

Port Huron, Michigan

Re: My Take

#13

Re: My Take

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>3 cheers for you folks that organized this event. Here is the way I look at this exchange. I will turn and finish a piece to the best of my ability. I can't do better than that. If I receive a piece from a less experienced turner but that person has turned and finished to the best of their ability, then it is a fair and good exchange. I know that I will not be disappointed.

Terry

Re: My Take

#14

Russ, I have Changed My Mind

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi,

I have read every post, looked at them all and I have decided to revisit my decision to not participate, I am going to change my mind, Ron, put me in please, send me the link..

I think this all has been a good discussion, we needed to clear the air and for the most part we have. I feel that Turning part of WC has needed a boost for the last few months, I think that Ruth's post has been the catalysist to get this going..

take care,

Jim

Re: My Take

#15

Re: My Take

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>At this time I would like to thank all three of you for the time and effort to pull this event off. Last year I was affraid that my work wasn't good enough. this year it won't be perfect but I will try.

I don't understand why the issue of price is even involved with this event. It takes the same amount of time and effort to turn a bowl weather your a amature or pro. Just because someone wants to place a high value on their work is only supporting their ego and missed the point of this event. My work is priceless but a simple thank you or a smile on someones face means more than a dollar bill.

That's how I was raised...

Re: My Take

#16

Re: I contend that much of the concern....

Jamie Donaldson

>.. expressed in this whole thread is "much ado" about nothing of real substance. I am optimistic that participants in an exchange would try to send a piece representative of their best efforts-why would they send out a piece that would do otherwise? I am a serious collector-maybe I should say not "too" serious collector! Among my favorites is a piece resembling an apple core made by a 9 yr. old former student, daughter of my CPA. The joy of exploration and accomplishment when she started turning is captured in that piece and known only to me, and thus its value. Lurkers are just unknown faces in our crowd, and we should not place value, or lack thereof, just because we don't know them personally. Their interest in participating in an exchange is the opportunity to welcome their faces out of the shadows and share in the fun of our mutual turning passion.

Re: My Take

#17

Steven Antonucci

Ron, Colin, Dennis- No good deed goes unpunished!

Steve Antonucci

>I've personally met Ron and Dennis (someday, Colin?) and I know that they both embody the true spirit of WoodCentral.

I wasn't sure what I was going to give- I have a ton of unfinished projects around the shop and I figured I'd just finish something and send it out the door. Then I saw all of the heartache yesterday and thought if I'm going to be sending someone my best work, I better make something new, since I've gotten better every day.

I spent a few hours yesterday and a couple this morning finishing my Exchange gift. I'm proud of it. I hope the recipient enjoys it as much as I enjoyed making it (it's headed to Tennessee-).

Steve

Re: My Take

#18

Miss a few days visiting, now I am a lurker?

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>There are too many post in the original thread for me to read so I will make a few comments here.

Disappointment is the biggest thing I feel right now. I see the turning exchange as an opportunity to expand the interaction of Wood Central visitors. I use the word visitor because I believe that anyone who visits the forums more than once is part of the family. I have never considered a "Lurker" to outside the "Group". If everyone who visited pontificated on every thread there wouldn't be enough bandwidth or server space to accommodate the traffic. On the other hand "Lurkers" account for the vast majority of the unique visits each day which translates into advertising incentive. In other words more "Lurkers" means more advertising revenue to help keep Wood Central on line for the "Group."

I have met a large number of Wood Central forum participants over the years. Very few of them are in the category of professional high end turners who command a high price for their work. One of the very accomplished turners, Wally Dickerman, sent me a small hollow form from out of the blue. It is not a large turning but it is light as a feather and I treasure it because he gave it too me. I can purchase a larger piece of Wally's work for several hundred dollars but the value to me would be less than the one gifted to me. I am saddened to think that there are people who will not participate in the turning exchange because they are labeled "Lurkers" or because they a worried about being ripped off.

I will be sending a small bird pecked apple bowl to my recipient I do not yet know thus forging an other link in the Wood Central community. In my little way I will be lighting a candle because I am getting to old to waste time cursing the darkness.

Dave Smith

Looking forward to a turned gift in Longview, WA.

Re: My Take

#19

I thought it was a typo

Stuart Johnson

>one of them was brave enough to state that they expected the professional woodturner to "give their highest value work".

I actually thought the person that posted the comment made a typing error and meant didn't expect.....

Re: My Take

#20

Re: My Take

Larry In Lima

>Well, I consider myself a lurker, because I've only posted a few times. I can say though that I have checked and read this site probably twice a day for over a year. Eventually I might consider myself more "worthy" and able to contribute more knowledge.

If a site is friendly, and stays friendly, eventually the lurkers might become productive, helpful "members". If the site is all buddy buddy and part of the good 'ol boy club, I usually leave pretty quick. That is the biggest reason I never joined (or once participated) in the elite penturners site. ;) Larry

Re: My Take

#21

Re: I thought it was a typo

john lucas

>That's what I thought also Stewart.

Re: My Take

#22

Perfectly stated Terry

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>

Re: My Take

#23

Re: Miss a few days visiting, now I am a lurker?

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I was the recipient of Dave exchange piece last year. A wonderful natural edge rhododendron burl vase that I was proud to receive. Even though Dave lives in the upper left corner and I live near the middle, I had the pleasure of meeting him this past October at IndyFest. I consider him one of my many woodturning friends.

Had it not been for the exchange last year, this might not have happened.

keithz