Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

bowl gouge grinds

Posts

bowl gouge grinds

#1

bowl gouge grinds

john lucas

>Description: These are my bowl gouge grinds. The top one is an off brand similar to a Sorby. I ground the wings way back. The way this gouge is shaped the wings grind to about a 25 degree angle so they cut extremely clean when used in a pull cut. The tip is ground around 50 degrees. I developed this grind for turning my hand mirrors . I can use the tip in a push cut and then when necessary switch to a pull cut for really curly grain or other problem areas. I built my own "Ellworth" sharpening jig but the leg is at a steeper angle and is longer than Davids jig.

The next one down is a packard 1/2" gouge. It has more or less an Ellsworth grind. The flute is thicker on the sides and the shape of this grind gives me a wing sharpening angle about 50 -55 degrees. Tip angle is closer to 65 degrees. The thicker side grind means that It will cut longer without getting dull.

The 3rd one down is my deep bowl hollowing tool. The tip is ground pretty blunt to allow me to turn the bottom of deep turnings. The tip is about 70 degrees.

The bottom gouge is a Henry Taylor ground in a Stewart Batty grind of 40 degrees all over. I'm learning to like it a lot but it does require a learning curve to really master. I'm getting there. When I use it correctly the piece requires virtually no sanding.


img

Re: bowl gouge grinds

#2

Re: bowl gouge grinds

Russ Babbitt

>Thanks for those pictures. That 3rd on looks a bit iffy to me. The ears look kind of high, do you use the wings on this one?

Re: bowl gouge grinds

#3

Re: bowl gouge grinds

Jorge Castaneda

>Hi John,

I pretty much use the same three grinds as you, now I will have to look at one with the Stuart Batty; which one does best for you for the final cuts on the inside of the bowl?

Thanks for posting

Jorge

Re: bowl gouge grinds

#4

Re: bowl gouge grinds

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>John,

The Batty gind is interesting. Does the bevel burnish the wood after the cut is made?

This is a standard Henry Taylor bowl gouge... yes/no... what size.

Thanks,

Doug

Re: bowl gouge grinds

#5

Re: bowl gouge grinds

eliot d

>John, It may be just the pictures and not the actual gouges, but it appears that all but the last are not quite right. They appear to be slightly concave -- not convex or straight, as they should be. You may be getting away with it because the problem appears to be slight. If I'm right( and one other responder noticed it , too) you will have to regrind the profiles first and then get back to sharpening the edges. You'll get an even better cut if you do. More sharpening as you have been doing probably won't get you there without wearing away a lot of metal. I apologize if I have misread your images.

Re: bowl gouge grinds

#6

Re: bowl gouge grinds

john lucas

>The third one down is for deep bowl bottoms and I don't use the wings so I don't worry too much about the shape of these. About every 4th or 5th sharpening I'll shape them so they aren't badly concave or convex.

Re: bowl gouge grinds

#7

Re: bowl gouge grinds

john lucas

>Eliot I've been using these grinds for years and they cut very cleanly . Sometimes they do get a little off perfectly straight but I haven't been able to tell a problem in actual use. The photo may make them looke a little off. I didn't take the time to set up good lighting for the bevels and they may not show the edge accurately.

Re: bowl gouge grinds

#8

Re: bowl gouge grinds

john lucas

>The top gouge is usually my inside gouge except the shape requires a moderately open bowl. I like the stewart Battey grind but the 40 degree bevel won't always fit the shape of my bowls which tend to curve up more than this gouge will allow.

Re: bowl gouge grinds

#9

Re: bowl gouge grinds

john lucas

>It doesn't burnish the wood any more than any other gouge. You'll notice I grind the bottom of the bevel off on all my gouges to keep from burnishing a line into the wood.

This is a 1/2" Henry Taylor bowl gouge. I has a long flute and is a long piece of steel but the handle is too small and needs a longer handle.

Re: bowl gouge grinds

#10

Re: bowl gouge grinds

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I first learned using the "Stuart Batty" grind, but that was long before people were talking about swept-back grinds. It is still the grind that I use today, mostly because I haven't seen any real advantage to the other grinds. The only times I've had trouble with it is when I can't ride the bevel on the bottom of a bowl. That usually only happens with deeper closed form bowls. I use a blunter bevel angle in those areas.

Re: bowl gouge grinds

#11

Re: bowl gouge grinds

Barry Irby

>John, Where can I get more info on the Stuart Batty grind and using the tool. Does he sell a video. I am interested in anythng that can reduce sandign to practically nothing.

Do you sharpen it by setting it in a guide and rolling it like you do a roughing gouge? Without the sort of complex swing required fo the Ellsworth grind? Then change the setting to knock off the bevel?

Re: bowl gouge grinds

#12

Re: bowl gouge grinds

John Lucas

>Barry I'll have to do some searching to see if I can find more info on the Stewart Batty grind. The most important thing to do is to start with a sharp tool, increase the speed of the turning a little and slow down the feed rate of the cut. There isn't a magic grind out there. The sharper the angle the cleaner the cut (most of the time).

Most bowl gouges are sharpened on the nose from about 50 to 65 degrees and the wings come out whatever unless you've purposely changed your jig to grind the wings differently. This means that your not getting the cleanest cut off the nose and as you rotate the gouge the cut changes because of the different angles presented.

The Stewart Batty grind is 40 degrees no matter where you are on the cutting edge. This means that as you rotate the gouge the cut quality doesn't change. The 40 degree grind is sharper than most bowl gouges, some spindle gouges are sharpened this way or even sharper.

Even with this grind proper technique is essential.

Re: bowl gouge grinds

#13

Re: bowl gouge grinds

Chuck Engstrom

>Mike Mahoney had an article in FWW several months back which described, I'm pretty sure, the elements of this 40-all-around grind. He and Batty did a demo together in Louisville with some discussion of its advantages.

Best--

Chuck Engstrom

Chestertown MD

Re: bowl gouge grinds

#14

Re: bowl gouge grinds

Scott Hurley in N. VA

>In the video he made with Mike Mahoney "Two Ways To Make A Bowl", he explains his grinding technique and shows how it's done.

Scott