Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

OK, I'm hooked

Posts

OK, I'm hooked

#1

OK, I'm hooked

Pat from MD

>I posted pictures earlier today of my first bowl, which I turned and finished last night. Tonight I turned another small bowl, and I'm totally hooked. Thanks to everyone for the feedback on the first bowl. Here's the second. It's oak, ~5 inch diameter, with a wall thickness of ~1/16" and I have a photo of the translucence at my (non-commercial) site here: http://www.beadsandcoves.com/2007/01/second-finished-bowl.html

The finish is not quite as nice as the first bowl, but I much prefer the shape of this one.

Comments encouraged, escpecially (constructive) criticism.

Thanks everyone,

Pat


img

Re: OK, I'm hooked

#2

Re: OK, I'm hooked

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>I like the shape, Pat, although I think a bit more bulge in the side would look nicer--it looks kinda straight between the foot and where the rim starts to curve. You sure picked a hard wood to play around with ;)

I hate oak, also, as you said on your website. Speaking of which, that is a very good example of using a 'blog for a website. Lookin' good there!

Re: OK, I'm hooked

#3

Steven Antonucci

Constructive criticism

Steve Antonucci

>I will follow the comment below on how Malcom T. might approach a critique.

First, I applaud your finishing efforts. If you saw my first bowls, I'm embarassed to have made them. Your attention to finishing will absolutely be critical to the overall outcome, and it appears that your doing it very well.

However, as Ken has pointed out, the shape is a traditional beginner shape. Not being mean-spirited, but "dog-dish" and "UFO" tend to be the first things we all produce because of 2 primary factors: 1.) we're just happy to be cutting wood so we're not paying attention to shaped and 2:) beginners tend to not move their bodies very well and get all kinds of flat spots.

I highly recommend that you do two things. First, buy 500 Wooden Bowls (book) to get an example of shapes and form. It is a great investment. Second, with the lathe off and your eyes closed, run your hands over the form and let them guide you. You'd be amazed at what you'll feel vs. what you see.

Finally, you've got the right attitude. The only way we get better is to turn and seek opinions. If you practice your craft and seek the help of others, you'll improve in leaps and bounds.

Looking forward to #3 tonight.

Steve

Re: OK, I'm hooked

#4

Re: Constructive criticism *LINK*

joaz

>I agree with the recent critiques. one thing that has always helped me is a simple technique. Turn the piece upside down and see if the shape is as pleasing as right side up.

Keep up the good work.


http://www.maine-web.com/woodturning

Re: OK, I'm hooked

#5

Re: OK, I'm hooked

Pat from MD

>Thanks Ken, I agree about the bulge, but didn't really see it until you mentioned it.

The blog is fun to do, and acts like a show and tell to friends and family. I hope that someday I'll go back and read it and enjoy laughing at my beginner's mistakes.

Thanks for the comments.

Re: OK, I'm hooked

#6

Re: Constructive criticism

Pat from MD

>Thanks for all the comments and suggestions. I appreciate you taking time to write it!

Funny to hear that I'm falling into the typical beginner's traps, but I guess that's good because it suggests I'm headed in the right direction. I'll look for that book, and I like your tips on getting better shaping.

I also agree that getting fully honest criticism is the best way to improve. This forum seems to have a great wealth of knowledge that it's great to be able to take advantage of, and I fully intend to do so!

Thanks for the help.

Re: OK, I'm hooked

#7

Re: Constructive criticism

Pat from MD

>Thanks for the tip, I'll try that.

By the way, the pieces on your site look beautiful.

Re: OK, I'm hooked

#8

Re: Constructive criticism

Peter Hyde

>Hi Pat

A great start to a new passion! Welcome to the club!

I checked out your Blog and am impressed.

Observation. Seems you are a little preoccupied with thin walls. The cedar bowl you show rough would be nice with the walls finished about the same thickness. Bowls are nice to pick up when they have a bit of heft to them. Something you loose when they are thin.

Also try the microwave for drying things this size. First weigh the piece and record the weight. On full power, zap for around 2 minutes. Remove and allow to cool completely and re-weigh. Then repeat the process until there is no further weight loss.

Form and shape is a thing that is learned and entirely dependent on the eye of the beholder. If you leave enough thickness to allow a third or fourth turning later on, you can catalog the changes and observe the results. Also always try to seek an independent unbiased opinion. Find out what you like and also what pleases others.

Good luck!

Re: OK, I'm hooked

#9

Re: Pat's starting to show the ....

Jamie Donaldson

>....symptoms- another turning addiction victim!!!Find some user friendly soft maple, cherry, etc. and practice making shavings, without getting caught up in the quest for beautiful wood just yet. I recommend not even sanding or finishing- not every piece needs to be a keeper, because the turning practice will help prepare for the special ones later. This is a much improved bowl design, to go with the mug you already have.Have fun!!! ;-))))

Re: OK, I'm hooked

#10

Re: Constructive criticism

Pat Taylor

>Thanks for the advice. I've thought of trying the microwave, instead of the alcohol soaking, to compare results. The cherry one I finished was still wet, and it warped a bit but that's fine.

Re: OK, I'm hooked

#11

Re: Pat's starting to show the ....

Pat Taylor

>I just hauled home a TON (perhaps literally) of maple, beech, and locust (all green). There's no shortage of wood for me to practice on anymore, so stay tuned for more pictures with bad lighting!

Addiction, huh? Well, that explains why I keep scouting for wood while I'm out and sneak away to the garage while I'm home....