We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I have been known around my club to be brutally honest when it comes to critiquing members work. I usually ask if they want an honest critique or should I be gentle. Lately there have been a lot of pieces shown for critique here. I was wondering how everyone feels about critiques here. Should we be totally honest, or sugar coated? None of my critiques are meant to be mean. I only give critque when asked for and I feel that if asked for any critique would be constructive and help the turner improve his/her work. Thanks all.
>.. parties should always remember that they are subjective as well.Don't place too much ego on either side of the subject and there will be more to gain from another's opinion. And consider the source as you evaluate the worth of the commentary.
>Hi Russ, This is a great topic for discussion. I first proposed the idea of online critiques a couple of years ago, using pieces my own work as an example of how the process could benefit those who post here. I still believe that this process could be of great help to many. There are a couple of problems, however. First we cannot see the actual piece being critiqued, we must rely on a photo. Images that were altered on PhotoShop have been know to occur as well. Second, we cannot guage the person's reaction to the critique done online.... A club critique is quite different than an online critique. The critique must be straightforward and positive, striving to benefit the person asking for the critique.
Any serious critique must be able to identify underlying problems, and show ways to improve upon these. "Attaboy!" or "Nicely done!" have no place in the critique process. Neither do comments such as "the foot's too big"....unless the reason is clearly and adequately explained.
Jamie is absolutely right here....and there are MANY who frequent this site who are capable of doing such a critique. The person asking for a critique must be willing to accept some amount of objective criticism....If someone cannot handle that, Please, don't ask for a critique. A poorly done critique benefits nobody; an emotional tirade over an excellent critique will destroy the process in short order.
>I believe that the "rule" (formal or informal I don't know but it makes sense) here at WC is that if the person specifically asks for a critique then by all means go for it and give your honest opinion. If it's just a picture of "here is what I made" then don't be too critical - but by all means gush if you really like the piece!
If you are giving a critique, be sure to re-read your post a few times - things written in posts (and emails ) often don't come across the way you intended as they are being read and not spoken the way you might have.
>I agree "atta boy" critiques are worthless but I also think some of the "tough honest" critiques are worse than worthless. There have been some I've seen given to new turners that might very well have turned them off from showing any more.
Good old Sam the club/list expert feels it is his sworn duty to point out every flaw and wart he can find. Because Sam says it then it must be true so half a dozen others pile on. When all is said and done the very proud turner is handed back his vase or bowl and is left with the feeling it isn't even good enough to use for firewood.
On the other hand a critique that points out the good, why it is good and where changes can be made to improve the piece can do a world of good.
If you want to examples of what I think are the best critiques look at those Malcolm Tibbetts gives on segmented work. He starts off with a compliment on some aspect and a reason why. He then gives his idea on how to make it better or possibly some caution. This is normally followed up with a positive comment. The turner is left with ideas on how to improve and with a good feeling.
>If I post and ask for comments and critiques. I am hoping to not only to get nice comments but also suggestions on how to inprove my turning or finish.
If you don't like a piece, Tell me you don't like it, but tell me why. and how you would have done it diffently. I may not agree with you but at least I will be able to look at from a different perspective.
not to put anyone on the spot but If a piece is posted for critique and Brad vietje, allen neighbors, john lucas and a few others post comments i look at the piece and then read there comments.
they seam to take the time to look at the pieces, and give comments that will improve the next attempt by the turner. and maybe the turner will see something that they had missed when they were working on the piece.
I know myself I have benifited from that type of comments.
1.) an opportunity to improve your abilities and/or see things in new ways
2.) an opportunity to not learn something
When someone asks for a critique about a particular piece, I try to remove my personal tastes (or at least expose them...) with any commentary I provide. I'm not partial to footed bowls, but I can recognize one that's well executed. If I believe that there's a problem with a shape or something looks odd about a form, I'll point it out.
Many people have been doing this for many years, but that doesn't automatically equate to "better" or more valid opinions. I've made 100's of pieces throughout my turning experience. Some of them were "great" when I made them, but I can barely look at them now. The greatest thing I did to improve my ability was read. Football has a saying: you can't coach speed (you either have it or you don't). In turning, I think you can't coach form- but you can learn it by reading and observing- and you will become you own best critic.
So much of a "good" critique comes from the reviewers experience and knowledge that unless you are intimately familiar with them, you really can't place a value on their opinion. We all have a valid opinion built upon our own experiences and our own beliefs. When asked to express it, we should do so freely and without consequence.
>a young woodturner. :o) When I post a picture of a piece I've fashioned out of a chunk of wood, I want nothing but praise. NOT!!!
I always enjoy a pat on the back, but if I don't get an honest critique, it won't help me improve my eye, or my technique, either.
Just telling someone the things you don't like about a piece isn't enough information... if I don't hear something in the way of technique improvement, the critique won't help me to improve.
As an example, (you're up, Jennifer) I read a critique that she wrote for someone else that was awesome; she included some information on technique that helped me, and didn't even know it. I can't even count the times I've been helped by an honest critique that someone gave to another turner on this forum. I don't know enough about turning yet, to give someone a good critique, that's why I either just say what I like about a piece or just don't say anything. :o)
That said, I believe a critique should help someone improve the art of woodturning, rather than just name what's wrong with the piece. :o)
>There are several problems with on-line critiques. We have an unknown person of unknown qualifications giving a critique based on a single view in a poor quality photograph to a person they don't know and can't see. That looks like the perfect formula for failure to me.
I think we should all agree to limit critiques to those that ask for comments or critiques. I never want to crush a beginner's enthusiasm with comments about the size of the foot, etc, but if asked what might make a piece better, I may mention such a thing. I try to take into consideration the turner's experience and also try to be respectful and polite, though I'm sure I have failed occasionally. The hard part is trying to understand what the turner was trying to accomplish, or in artsy terms, what statement they are trying to make. If the whole point is to express mass and weight, then a huge foot and a thicker, chunkier design might be perfect.
Using myself as an example, last night I posted 4 pieces, and asked for comments or critiques. Some people liked the pieces, but didn't like the design of the foot on a few of them. That's absolutely fine with me, and I hope my responses weren't taken as rebuttals. I think a round robin on design, using specific pieces as working examples, is very helpful to beginners and more experienced turners, too. The more we dissect and re-assemble a turning, the more we all learn.
If I were a more skilled computer guy, I would love to be able to digitally manipulate the photos to illustrate what a modification would look like, or to clarify a question. I'll have to learn that stuff someday.
Having a separate critique page hasn't worked much for me -- I rarely go to any part of WoodCentral besides this messageboard, so I will probably just offer comments when requested, and try to be supportive when doing so.
>Online critiques done properly are very helpful. For example read Allen's post about learning from a critique Jennifer gave. Even a poor photo with blue background can be used to give an idea of form. Knowing the turner might actually be a drawback. Have you ever wondered if some of the critiques given to some of the big names (which are usually just atta boys) wouldn't be different if the piece had a different name attached?
>The bottom line seems to be, if you ask for crtitique you will get a polite honest opinion of the reviewer. That should include what the reviewer likes and dislikes. The dislikes might recommend changes the reviewer would like to see. Above all the reviewer should be polite and considerate and the artist/turner should take the critique as an effort to improve ones work. Thanks all, this was good. In my opinion, of course.
>I've only posted a couple of pieces on this board, but each time I ask for critiques and comments. Anyone who posts a piece with the expectation of someone looking at it critically should expect some of those comments to be in the vein of, "I don't like...." or "The form would look better if..." Some of those comments may be because the person looking at the piece just doesn't like _________ (insert "footed bowls", "segmented turnings", "natural edge bowl", etc.). And there's nothing wrong with that, especially if the author of the critique states that as part of their critique.
Other comments will come from the many people on this board who have the experience, the eye, and the ability to express WHY something should (or could) be done differently.
I take all comments and critiques as a chance to look at a piece (mine or someone else's) in a different way. And we don't HAVE to agree that the critique is the only way the piece should be looked at, just a different way of looking at it.
Critiques open my eyes a bit wider and give me another perspective on my (and your) work. I welcome them.
>Russ, I've learned most of my woodturning by standing in front of my lathe and turning. But the second most prominent place that I learn is here on WoodCentral and other spots on the web. I feel like one can learn a ton by reading critiques of their own and others work. I think we need to keep in mind that when someone critiques a picture of a piece, that their comments are based primarily on the form, or the embellishment of the piece. We can not, for the most part, see sanding scratches, feel wall unevenness and so on. But I feel like there is a ton to be learned about form and design by just looking at a picture.
When I toss a piece up and ask for all comments and critiques I know that I need to be able to take the good with the bad. When I get a "stinger"...it does just that. But you know what, it just might make me think and see something that I missed, or might try on the next one. When we are in our shops working alone and can't bounce stuff off hundreds of other people like we do here...we only have one opinion. That's one of the real treats about this place is that we can get relatively instant feedback on what we do and make. That given, I do also take into account the qualifications (in my own opinion) of the person delivering the comments and how much of the critique I want absorb. Sometimes I take it deep to heart...other times I toss it out with the garbage :)
>Every club has whiners and ours is no exception. As Program Director the Show and Tell sort of fell to me. Sometimes a person would ask for a critique and I would give a gentle, but honest one. But after a few whiners I fell to doing the Jackie Kennedy critique - "Here's this one and there's that one, and here's nice bowl." It was about as useful as airbrakes on a turtle.
Now we have a new slate of officers and someone else has the Program Director slot. At the first meeting of the new board someone mentioned S & T and sure enough, here came the whiners again. No critiques. But at the first meeting during a break, a person who wanted honesty came up and asked to have his bowl critiqued. I walked him through the process and at some point I said "Now we must look at the curve to see if there are knuckles or flats." He immediately said "Here's a flat." So, he made the observation and I didn't have to be the bad guy this time.
I'm willing to help, but I'd rather catch javelins than do a club critique.
>Would you rather have a friend lie to you and tell you how wonderfull your piece looks,or a stranger tell you the truth no mater how brutal. If you can,t take the heat maybe you should stay away from the fire.
>I have to agree with Jennifer, she saved me a lot of pick and peck typing! I live in a remote area where initially the nearest AAW meeting was 120 mile, many winter nights at midnight under lake effect snow warnings and � mile visibility. Thanks to WC and WOW I was able to have people critique while I sat in front of my warm fireplace. Most of the critiques were right on the money, some expressed a personal dislike of a design feature but through those I also learned other design options. Others improved my photography. One from Mike Schwing changed the way I looked at sanding and finishing forever, not that every piece will be finished with micromesh but I am now aware that some pieces may deserve it and all that I was doing at that time could be greatly improved. I have been fortunate to have people point out the good and the bad and have hopefully not wasted the valuable time they donated to participate. Where else could I get this timely feedback by many that I consider much better in design that I? Not to mention ideas on what changes to make to improve the design. I feel some would be less apt to critique in a face to face situation, although I would hope not. Turning is a continuing learning process.
>Seems a touchy subject. For beginners as I am, all opinions are an education, if not in technique, at least in observation. I see many pieces here welcoming comments, and when the picture loads I'm thinking "nice", then the comments lead me to see bulges, uneven openings or disproportionate feet. I'm wondering, though, how much of the criticism involves 'fad'. For a few years, it seems, all opinion is to "elevate work off the table", then later a perfectly 'grounded' round bottom bowl is the perfect form. This is always evolving, or swinging back and forth over time. I don't mean to imply the comments are not useful, just that perfect form seems so very opinionated. The usefulness of the critiques and comments, is in taking the turner out of isolation, as Jennifer mentioned. And to a beginner, the comments are a goldmine. I hope they keep coming.
>Barb, you are correct in the fact that popular forms evolve or even regress to previous styles sometimes. However, in my opinion, the style of the turning should not really affect a good critique. I may not care for a particular style of turning but I try to look at balance, proportion, transitions and overall execution. These thing apply no matter what the current "fad" happens to be.
>Are style and form different aspects? My view is that good form is a pleasing balance that changes little over time. Style seems to be in a constant flux and constantly changes over time.
An example might be a fine turning of excellent form in Victorian style. I appreciate the form but don't care for the style.