Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

The next step

Posts

The next step

#1

The next step

Steve in NC

>Two years ago I started turning with a used 14 inch Delta. A year ago I added a Jet mini for my daughter. After fighting with the Delta for my larger pieces, I am ready for a new (and hopefully my last) lathe. And fortunately my supportive, understanding and patient spouse agrees.

I turn mostly faceplate items, bowls hollow forms, lamps... but I do occasional spindle work as well. I plan to sell the Delta but keep the mini for smaller work.

My budget will not tolerate a Oneway so I am leaning towards a PM3520B. Given a $3000 unbending limit, is there another option I should be considering.

I know this a dangeous question to post but this is the largest tool purchase I have ever made and I would appreciate your thoughts.

Thanks

Steve

Re: The next step

#2

JL

Re: The next step

JL

>Depends on how much you are into spindle work (and how long) your spindles are. The 3520B is a nice lathe. It's maximum capacity is 35" though. The Jet 1642 2hp EVS has less capacity for bowls/platters, but still plenty of power. If most of your work is faceplate and bowl work, with no spindle over 25-28" you'll be happy with the 3520B. If you want longer spindles and smaller bowls, consider the Jet.

Re: The next step

#3

Re: The next step

john lucas

>The bed extension was only $175 when I got mine. That gives you a much longer bed and with the 3520B is can also be mounted lower to give you a much larger swing. The other option I would consider is the remote switch. Quite handy when turning big stuff or hollowing because you can put the switch where it's safest.

Re: The next step

#4

Re: The next step

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi Steve,

I envy your position! I have been spinning about 5 years on my Jet Mini and just cannot (yet) justify the money for a new one. In the the $3000 range, I think the 3520 is a great lathe. You can get a bed extension for not too much more $$ if you ever need to spin a long spindle.

Of course, my advice is what you've paid for it and since I've never spun on a PM3520, I imagine better advice will come from others.

Still, if the lathe fairy dropped $3k in my lap and said buy one, I'd bring home a 3520 :)

Good luck with your decision, let us know what you pick!

M

Dreaming in mustard yellow in Apex, NC...

Re: The next step

#5

Re: The next step

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>Can't beat the PM 3520B for the $.

Re: The next step

#6

Re: The next step

John Cahall

>Love my 3520a and the B adds features I wish I had. Recommend it highly.

John in Ohio

Re: The next step

#7

Re: The next step *LINK*

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Consider the Vega 2600 if you only need to do short spindles, but mostly do bowls.

Mark


http://www.vegawoodworking.com

Re: The next step

#8

Re: The next step

Sam Dean

>I have a 3520B, and was in the same boat you are a few months ago. The bed extension makes it all worth while for doing long spindles and larger diameter turning. I've been able to turn several 26" to 28" bowls, and I'm doing some 42" hickory legs for a bar in our kitchen this weekend. It's a good machine compared to what's available in the current market, and is able to perform a wide range of tasks with ease. If you have $3k to burn, it's about the only thing that fits the bill.

Thanks,

Sam

Re: The next step

#9

Re: The 3520 can't be touched...

Jamie Donaldson

>... in that price range and up another $2K!

Re: The next step

#10

Andy DiPietro

Re: Love my 3520B! but but

Andy DiPietro

>just to stir the pot a little since you had to step into the deeper water. You may want to consider the Vega 2600 bowl lathe for $2800. It is very limited for spindle work though. Bill Grumbine likes his Vega for bowls and hollow forms.

If I had to decide today I would still buy the 3520B and I do mostly HF's and bowls. My motto about buying woodworking tools is as follows. If you are passionate about working with wood then buy more then you can afford now so you do not regret it later. I would bet that most of us have tools in our shops that we regret buying because we need something better now. IMHO