Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Lathe not turning 'true'

Posts

Lathe not turning 'true'

#1

Lathe not turning 'true'

Stephen Gehres

>Hi. I just got my first lathe and attempted to turn my first pen with it and I seem to have a problem. I have 2 adjustable MT2 double-mandrels, and a single 'shortie' mandrel that uses a MT2 drill chuck. Problem is that all three don't turn 'true'. They are all BRAND NEW, and they all have a slight wobble. All three roll smoothly on a flat surface, so I don't think the mandrels are the problem.

When I finished turning my first pen I ended up with the brass tubes not perfectly centered in the turned blanks. This makes the pen parts not line up correctly, and look sloppy. The blanks were pre-drilled, and I squared up the blanks with a barrel trimmer after gluing the tubes in. It seems to me that whatever I put in the Morse Taper doesn't spin perfectly.

Is there something I can do about this? Or do I need to try to return it. It is an M-Power 10" x 18" midi lathe from Rockler, but I purchased it in November. I just now got around to giving it my first spin-up.

Thanks for any helping hand you can lend.

~Steve Gehres

stuff@Woodworking.Spunky-Monkey.com

Re: Lathe not turning 'true'

#2

Re: Lathe not turning 'true'

John Kyler

>I know that Rockler has a 2 year warranty on that lathe.

Take it back and they should trade a new one out for you.

Re: Lathe not turning 'true'

#3

Re: Lathe not turning 'true'

Jim Swank

>Make sure the MT is clear of all preservatives, dust, and other crud first. If the problem persists, return it as suggested. You might take your mandrels along with you when you do...

Re: Lathe not turning 'true'

#4

Re: Lathe not turning 'true'

john lucas

>Stephen Move the tailcenter up to the drive center so they almost touch. Be sure and clean both morse taper surfaces before inserting the centers. Then rotate the drive spindle by hand. It should stay pointed at the tailcenter without rotating in a circle. The two centers should also line up. If they don't line up try cleaning the ways of the lathe and if the headstock has any adjusment mounting bolts holding it in place loosen these and see if you can get the two points to align.

If none of this works then you might have a lathe problem.

Re: Lathe not turning 'true'

#5

Steve Kubien

Re: Lathe not turning 'true'

Steve Kubien

>Ok, bear in mind that I am a newbie as well. I may not be understanding you exactly. If you line up the spur centre in the headstock with the live centre in the tailstock and all is well, it sounds to me like you've got the tailstock tightened up too much and it is causing the mandrel to flex giving you the wobble.

Just a thought,

Steve Kubien

Re: Lathe not turning 'true'

#6

Not a bad thought!!

Bill Howatt

>

Re: Lathe not turning 'true'

#7

Re: Lathe not turning 'true'

Stephen Gehres

>Ok. Here's more on this subject...

I returned that lathe to Rockler and got a replacement. They said they have had NO returns of these models, and have had no problems in their classroom. Take that for what it is...

The new unit seems to be the same, or maybe a slight bit better. But that's not saying much!!

I setup my dial indicator w/ magnetic base on the lathe bed and did some measuring. All measurements were done with a bare mandrel rod with no bushings. Here's what I came up with:

- PSI Woodworking MT#2 Pro adjustable mandrel

-- Adjusted so the length of the rod is 5 15/16"

-- and 7 1/2" total length from the faceplate to tip

--- Measured @ 4 19/32" on the rod

---- Deviation=0.016" without tailstock

---- Deviation=0.0035" with tailstock livecenter secured

--- Measured @ 2 7/8" on the rod

---- Deviation=0.004" with tailstock livecenter secured

..

- Woodcraft MT#2 Pro adjustable mandrel

-- Adjusted so the length of the rod is 6 1/4"

-- and 7 7/8" total len from the faceplate to tip

--- Measured @ 5" on the rod

---- Deviation=0.032" without tailstock

---- Deviation=0.009" with tailstock livecenter secured

--- Measured @ 2 5/8" on the rod

---- Deviation=0.018" without tailstock

---- Deviation=0.010" with tailstock livecenter secured

..

- Woodcraft MT#2 fixed length mandrel

-- Length of the rod is 6 7/8"

--- Measured @ 5 5/8" on the rod

---- Deviation=0.020" without tailstock

---- Deviation=0.005" with tailstock livecenter secured

--- Measured @ 2 7/8" on the rod

---- Deviation=0.011" without tailstock

---- Deviation=0.003" with tailstock livecenter secured

Now, am I supposed to see deviations like this? I didn't turn a pen with this one yet because I don't want to waste two more blanks and tubes. If this unit is still not acceptable (and I really need some advice here since I'm VERY new to turning), I'm considering returning it to Rockler and spending another $100 to get a Rikon model 70-100 12" x 16" mini-lathe. I think I'll skip the Jet 1014 because I'm told that it and the M-Power are both made by the same people.

Your thoughts??

Thanks again,

~Steve

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Spunky-Monkey Woodworks

stuff@Woodworking.Spunky-Monkey.com

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Re: Lathe not turning 'true'

#8

Re: Lathe not turning 'true'

Bill Stehman

>Stephen,

I'm not an experienced pen turner by any means however, if your head and tail stock are aligned it is not your lathe. As mentioned, too much tail stock pressure will cause your mandrel to bow, also a common problem is over tightening the thumb screw or nut on the mandrel. Once you have your blanks rounded, back off the pressure and rotate each half 180 degrees. I've had to do this several times in the past while learning the correct pressure without bowing the mandrel.

One last thought, do your mandrels require a 60 degree live center in the tail stock? If so it will help prevent wear on your mandrels and allow for truer turning. Also check out some pen turning sites and ask the pros.

Bill

Re: Lathe not turning 'true'

#9

Re: Lathe not turning 'true'

John Kyler

>What is the deflection at the live center?

It almost sounds like the tail stock may be too tight, as noted above?

You bring it up and tighten it just enough so that the live center snugs up and spins with the mandrel. It doesn't need to be real tight like we are use to doing in other applications.

The deflection as described with out the tail stock is normal, since the pen mandrels all seem to be a little off square. But if the deflection out of round and at the live center is that much I would suspect the live center point may be bad?

Re: Lathe not turning 'true'

#10

Re: Lathe not turning 'true'

Stephen Gehres

>OK. If I'm reading this correctly, deviation is normal when the tailstock is not brought up to even touch the end of the mandrel? I've taken the rods out of all three mandrels and they roll on a flat surface like they are perfectly flat/true. I guess they could be off by a few thousandths and I wouldn't even notice it with the naked eye. But when I put that same flat rod back in the mandrel's MT (without pulling up the tailstock) and the wobble is 0.032", it makes me wonder why.

When I bring up the tail center to just seat into the end of the mandrel, are the deviations I'm getting normal? I never measured the first model before returning it, but the blanks were really crappy after they got turned. There is a difference of 0.013" in the wall thickness of the blank from one edge to the other (one spot is 0.038" thick, and another is 0.051" thick).

Here are my responses to what y'all have mentioned:

> As mentioned, too much tail stock pressure will cause your mandrel to bow

<<

I'm just barely seating the tailcenter's cone into the concave in the end of the mandrel. For my measuring I had *NO* pressure on it at all.

> also a common problem is over tightening the thumb screw or nut on the mandrel.

<<

When doing my measuring, I didn't have blanks, bushings, or the thumb nut on the mandrel.

> Once you have your blanks rounded, back off the pressure and rotate each half 180 degrees.

<<

I'll give this a try when I turn a couple test blanks.

> One last thought, do your mandrels require a 60 degree live center in the tail stock?

<<

I have no idea. The manuals are always very lacking in details.

> Move the tailcenter up to the drive center so they almost touch. Be sure and clean both morse taper surfaces before inserting the centers. Then rotate the drive spindle by hand. It should stay pointed at the tailcenter without rotating in a circle. The two centers should also line up.

<<

As far as I can tell using my magnifying desk lamp, both centers are almost touching and seem to be lined up just fine.

>But if the deflection out of round and at the live center is that much I would suspect the live center point may be bad?

<

This is a brand new live center and the point is still perfect.

Someone emailed me directly and one point they made is: "My personal opinion is if you have a lathe that will not stay in adjustment and/or run true, the frustration will be terrible. You will either get discouraged and quit, or spend more money on a better lathe." That sums up my past couple weeks. I've been VERY frustrated. For the extra $90, the Rikon might ease some frustration... Or might I end up fighting the same problem???

Still open to suggestions...

Thanks again,

~Steve

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Spunky-Monkey Woodworks

stuff@Woodworking.Spunky-Monkey.com

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Re: Lathe not turning 'true'

#11

Re: You asked for my thoughts so here they are.

Al Crandall (N.E. of Indy)

>As I undersand your situation, you have put a mandrel holder in your Morse taper and installed a straight mandrel in it. The mandrel does not run true, and the runout increases as you get farther from the spindle. If the rod is truely straight, the only explanation is that the holder is not holding it true. The cause could be slop in the hole (it is adjustable for length as I understand it) or the hole is not machined true with the Morse taper or there are burrs or dirt on the holder or inside the spindle taper. Didn't you state that a non-adjustable unit ran more true than the adjustable units? I suspect the mandrel and holder combination is mostly at fault here.

Now you state that when you bring up the live center, things improve. Doesn't surprise me, they should. But they don't go to dead nuts true, so what could cause this? Certainly alignment of the tailstock with the headstock isn't it. Even if the two were mis-aligned by 1/8", when you put the point of the test indicator on the rod near the center, it will show no deviation provided ...and here is the rub...the live center is running true and the center drilled hole in the end of the mandrel is drilled on center. When either of these two conditions run amuck, you will get runout of the mandrel at the tailstock end. Engaging the live center will somewhat help the runout in the middle of the mandrel regardless of the accuracy of the rotating tip and the hole it engages. Try taking a reading at the end of the mandrel, and then rotate the mandrel by hand while you hold the live center tip stationary. If the reading changes, you know you have a problem with one of the two machining operations near the indicator. I haven't seen tolerances listed in woodworking catalogs, but in metal working I have seen live centers listed as "less than .0039 TIR at tip" or "guaranteed less than .0005 TIR". I doubt our centers are held to the same degree of accuracy. I also imagine that for some manufacturers of pen mandrels, total indicator runout less than the city limits is close enough for woodworking. My guess is that your problems are caused by your accessories, not your machine. My opinions only.

Re: Lathe not turning 'true'

#12

Re: You asked for my thoughts so here they are.

John Kyler

>I don't have much more to ad to the above. I would be more than happy to help you out if by chance you are in Colorado?

If not I bet you could find and AAW or International Penturners Association member in the area and they can come over and walk you through. But doesn't sound like there is any problem with the lathe after see the info. Keep in mind the shaft may be dead straight, but if the threaded hole is off half a thousands it provides for a lot of problems when you get 5" out.

I no longer buy the less expensive mandrels. I ended up with a good one from Crafts Supply.