Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Spalted Maple Vase

Posts

Spalted Maple Vase

#1

Spalted Maple Vase

George Van

>This is the first hollow form, in this case a vase, that I have finally sanded and finished. I saw a similar shape in ceramic and thought I would try it in wood. This was fun and will motivate me to finish more of the ones I have already roughed or are in one stage or another of completion. Comments or critiques are welcome as these are new to me and I know I have a lot to learn.


img

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#2

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

George Van

>The vase is 4" high x 3.5" wide.

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#3

Don Pencil

GREAT 1ST WORK!!!!!!!

Don Pencil

>

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#4

Brad Vietje

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

Brad Vietje

>Excellent little hollow form, George. Nice flowing shape, beautiful little reverse curve at the foot, and a very nice rim treatment. Its also an excellent finish, which can be tough on a spalted piece.

Great job all around, in my book !

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#5

Re: GREAT 1ST WORK!!!!!!!

George Van

>Thanks Don, it was hollowed with the Stinger tool. This shape was good for practice.

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#6

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

George Van

>Thanks Brad, I appreciate the comments. I am still uncertain on the reversal at the base. I want to try a similar one with the curve tucked to compare.

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#7

Re: GREAT 1ST WORK!!!!!!!

joaz

>Very nice. Classic shape.

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#8

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

Allen Neighbors

>Well done, George. It looks like it's made out of marble. I like the rim, too; it looks cast.

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#9

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

Mike Nelson

>George, considering this is your first completed hf and with detail line and finish like that, I believe many of us will be looking forward to future pieces.

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#10

Steven Antonucci

I agree with you

Steve Antonucci

>Somehow, I think it would work better with the curve following through the foot. I'm not a big fan of reverse curves in wood vessels, don't ask me why?

If that's your first vessel then I'd say your off to a good start.

Steve

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#11

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

Phil Powell

>George,

Looks real good!.............for an amateur. I like the full shape and ending at the top.

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#12

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

George Van

>Thanks Joaz, Allen, and Mike for your kind comments.

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#13

Re: I agree with you

George Van

>Steve, I saw the reverse curves in the pottery books I have read. We have a potter in our turning group that does a lot of the pottery shapes and I find a lot of them interesting. I have about 50 different forms roughed and a couple waiting for final sanding and finish. This one sat on a tenon for a year before I got around to parting it off and finishing. I am in the process of finishing my house and getting turning time is scarce.

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#14

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

George Van

>Hey Phil, you had to sneak in there while I was answering the others. Now everyone will know who the potter is! Will you be at Wednesday's meeting?

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#15

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

Sean Troy

>It has a beautiful flow to the shape. The finish is nice and as always, you use great looking wood. You getting hit very hard with all this winter weather? We expect 5-6 inches of rain through here by Monday. No snow. Where the heck is the snow?

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#16

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>I like it, George.

Gary

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#17

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

Neal_Addy

>Fantastic! Very nice hollow form.

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#18

That is exquisite, George *NM

Jim Rutten

>

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#19

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

George Van

>Thanks all for taking the time to comment.

Sean, we have very little snow after an all day rain New Years Eve, maybe you could send some of the moisture up this way now that it is cooling off up here. We have not even been on snowshoes yet this year and last weekend we only had 5" of good ice for the fish crib building project, normally we would have had over a foot for sure. El Nino, global warming, coinsidence?

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#20

Steven Antonucci

Nothing wrong with it George-

Steve Antonucci

>I didn't mean to imply that there was a problem. Reverse curves are a time tested form that has broad appeal across many people. You've done this well. It's just that my personal opinion is that wooden forms "look better" when the curve follows through the bottom.

It's funny because before your post yesterday, I took down a hollowform I made over 2 years ago, and turned away the reverse curved foot. It just always irked me, and I like it much better now with the curved under foot. Both forms were valid- I just relate more to the undercut form in wood than most people.

No bad intent intended- just my 2 cents.

Steve

Re: Spalted Maple Vase

#21

Re: Nothing wrong with it George-

George Van

>I understood what you meant Steve, I appreciate your input. I have to try the next one with a tucked base with the next similar shaped one that becomes dry. When I was at DWR in Phoenix I was told by Paul Fennell to make a bunch of forms to get a better understanding of which I like or do not like. I certainly have enough roughed to follow this plan.