Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Chat

Posts

Chat

#1

Keith Tompkins

Chat

keith tompkins

>To answer a couple of questions, the last time I communicated with Ellis, nobody he contacted was interested in hosting the Wed. nite chat; at least not on a regular basis.

I believe the chat must be structured, and topics for the chat must be posted in advance. Perhaps on a temporary basis, interested parties could post ideas for a chat during the week....the most popular idea becomes the topic for the chat AND whoever proposed the idea is host for that week's chat.

As far as I'm concerned, any turning related topic is fair game, and all opinions and ideas should receive the same consideration. And, everyone who frequents this site should feel welcome to sit in on the chat sessions.

I don't make it to many chat sessions, there just isn't time in my schedule, but I wouldn't mind hosting once in a while. I may be able to line up a few guest turners if there is enough interest.

I'm open to any other suggestions here.

Re: Chat

#2

Re: Chat

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Carole Valentine suggested in the earlier thread Captured hollowing rigs for a topic of discussion. If people want to show their rigs, I volunteer to set up a photo album on my personal webspace, and to try and steer the discussion from one entry to another. So, whether that happens in the next chat or some future chat, I offer that much for one session and possibly others on occasion.

Re: Chat

#3

Re: Chat Organization

Jim Swank

>Chats were better attended and lasted longer when we had TD as a host. I think that was partly as a result of having a topic and some attempt to stay on topic, and partly because people knew there would be good attendance.

I'm not convinced we need the same host each week. I am convinced we need a single point of coordination to schedule hosts and topics with a seal of approval from Ellis.

Re: Chat

#4

Re: Some observations about the Chat Room

Russ Fairfield

>There seems to be a universal law about Chat Rooms. They begin as a small group, they grow and flourish, and they fade away. Having been with the Chat Room since the 1st Wednesday night when there were 3 people there, through the good years when there were still 10 there at midnight, to now when everybody goes home before dark, I would like to offer some observations and opinions that could have nothing to do with reality of the Chat Room. You can read them, use them, or ignore them.

The turning and finishing Chat Rooms were spin-offs from Ellis's Sunday night chat. The turning Chat was a good group when the numbers were less that 12 or so. It became unwieldy when the numbers reached 30 or more. 12 or less, and people can carry on A conversation. 30 people can only carry on several conversations.

Chat Rooms are limited to written conversation. Instant pictures, video, or a sketch pad are still out of the question for a public forum. That means that, unless we are using one of the programs that allows us to communicate by voice, we are limited to the written word. That means we are limited by our ability to communicate with words alone, and how fast we can type. Most of us have a problem with one or both of those.

The mixed group is always a problem, and our different purposes become a bigger problem as the group becomes larger. It is difficult to carry on a serious conversation when half of the people are there to BS about their cars, kids, the weather, or what they had for supper. There were many nights when TD was the only person in the room who wanted to be serious.

Our biggest problem is that we expect too much from the Chat Room. This is a place to "chat". but we expect it to be a "classroom" or a serious conversation. It can be neither. A worthy response to a serious question takes time to compose in both thought and word. BS is instantaneous. Guess which one is the most popular Chat Room topic.

Most people wander off to other things while a response is being written and it is irrelevant by the time it is posted. The larger the group, the more often this happens, and the more often we communicate in short phrases with little to no forethought. There have been many times that I have given up posting a long reply because the conversation had moved on before I could post it, and when I did post the message, it was irrelevant to the current conversation and nobody read it, or at least nobody acknowledged it.

We tried to get around this time restraint by posting a lengthy discussion on the forum during the days before the chat, or posted a link to a website. It was sort of like a homework assignment and introduction into the topic, and the Chat Room couild be used to field questions. This was a total failure because either nobody bothered to read it before coming into the Chat Room, or the topic on the Messageboard became the discussion. If they didn't read it, it had been a wsare of time' If they did read it, they stayed away from the chat. I think we tried that 3 times before giving up.

Some of the better chats were those where photos were posted on another site where they could be used for discussion and critique. The problem here is someone has to post the photos to be discussed. No photos, no discussion. This started off with a lot of photos for the first session on bowls, but the mumber of photos trailed off to almost nothing after a couple sessions, and it became a lecture with TD and Wally talking about their own stuff. If I recall, the attendance also trailed off after that 1st session on bowls.

Somebody could use this double access to post a lesson on one site and discuss it in the Chat Room. I see 2 problems. The 1st is getting somebody to do all of that. This is not an easy thing to do. The 2nd is that this falls apart when the discussion and questions in the Chat Room strays from the prepared photos and sketches.

The worst of the Chats were those with a famous guest. There were 2 problems. Everyone was scared to just carry on a conversation. Everyone felt a need to be profound and ask serious questions that required serious answers. Serious answers take a lot of time to compose, whether the guest was doing that themselves or Ellis was doing the typiong for them. I don't know about anyone else, but I wandered off to other things while waiting, and often didn't come back.

The 2nd problem was that a serious answer is long, and that requires some serious reading by the rest of us. Those who had waited, started asking questions before they had read what the guest had written. If they did read the response, it was obvious they hadn't gotten the message.

Personally, I have a 3rd problem with the famous guests. I already knew what they have to say about almost any topic. These folks have produced a lot of written and spoken words already. It is already there and available.

Finally, all is not bad. The best Chats were those where the "guest host" carried the topic of the evening. Everyone could comminicate in short bursts and nobody was bored. An example of this was one of the early Chat sessions where Mark Kauder was the host for the night. His topic was segmented bowls. We asked a lot of questions. Since nobody was intimidated by Mark, we could ask stupid questions and there was no need to appear educated or be profound before the "master". I think this connection is important.

Chat Rooms are no different from the Messageboard forums. Some of us leave because there is no longer anything there for us, and we find ourselves among the BS'ers. Some of us leave because the people have changed and the character of the room has changed. Others follow. When that happens, it is time for a new group with a new enthusiasm to start the cycle again.

Re: Chat

#5

Here is what I think...

TDaniel

>Managing a chatroom is like managing a company....if you have an employee that can't follow the rules you get rid of him (or her). It only takes two or three to ruin a chatroom. Egos come into play and those who try to use the site to promote themselves will ruin the site. If the host could ban (fire) the ones who won't play by the rules then all is well but if the host cannot get rid of the ones who are causing the disruption then all is lost. A person who thinks his or her opinion is more qualified than the others needs to be ejected. We are all turners, we all have thoughts that are revelent, and we all need to respect each other. We all have different turning styles. This does not mean any one of us are wrong, we just do things differently. We have to listen to each other and take whatever we can from the conversation without bashing someone for doing things differently. The old saying, "there are many ways to skin a cat" applies. We also have to understand that when a host picks a topic that topic may not be of interest to the entire group. On the night that the topic is not of interest to you simply don't log on. Remember, a host is not paid for hosting...he (or she) does it for fun. When the fun stops you have lost a host.

Re: Chat

#6

Thanks Guys!

Steve Mushinski

>I will never grow tired of reading common sense posts by many of our members. Russ sometimes I do need to make a pot of coffee before I sit down and read yours ( ops that is BS right ). :)

I was only able to attend a few chats and they were under Russ's guidance. They worked well as there was around 12-20 on the nights I was in the rooms. I learned and enjoyed. The technology has not kept up with our wants and needs at this time.

Within in the next few years the average house hold will have some kind of tele conferencing as a main stay. For the cartoon fans, remember the Jetson's (First eposide 1962). We have some forms of it now, but it is choppy and the software support is not the best at the consumer end. Once it becomes one speaker at a time and one picture or view is set as dominate then we will have a medium in which to teach and ask questions. Just as with desktop computers it will take time to catch on and we will laugh about chat rooms of old.

Re: Chat

#7

Well Said Russ

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I haven't been on chats as long as you but still it has been about 10-11 years I guess. You are right on the mark.

Re: Chat

#8

Re: Chat

Ron in Drums PA

>All I'm going to say is, when you folks are ready and need photos, just let me know.

Re: Chat

#9

Re: Some observations about the Chat Room

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Fully agree Russ. Thanks for putting in print for us.

Re: Chat

#10

Re: Here is what I think...

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>TD, I've been to many of the chats, granted not all of them, but I can't recall any of them where someone was so egotistical, or had an agenda to promote themselves to the point that they should have been "banned" from the chat? Perhaps I was lucky and missed those chat nights? For the most part I think everybody knows each other that join in on the chats and I would find it odd if someone took on a different persona in the chat room than they have on the forum?

Just an observation.

Jen

Re: Chat

#11

Re: Here is what I think...

TDaniel

>Jenn, we wish! It is pretty obvious when someone is on the chat or the messageboard primarily to promote themselves and I have seen it several times. I don't have to call names because everyone knows who I am talking about. Everyone should feel equal on the chat or the messageboard. We are all turners, period. That should be it. I hate it when anyone tries to explain why their opinion is worth more than the rest of us. The chat does not work when anyone takes a position of being better than the rest of us.

TD

Re: Chat

#12

Re: Here is what I think...

Ron in Drums PA

>You have me stumped TD.

Re: Chat

#13

Re: Here is what I think...

Jim Swank

>Me too, but best let bygones be bygones.

Re: Chat

#14

I don't know about being banned...

Stuart Johnson

>but more than once it has turned into "I said it so it is fact". The same few seem to fall into this category and are present, stating their facts regardless of the topic. I usually use my ignore button when they start. The sad thing is they usually have very good input and would be a great asset if it wasn't for personality. I won't even say it is their personality. It is just theirs and mine clash.

Re: Chat

#15

I agree Stu

TDaniel

>In my former life I was a field troubleshooter of high speed packaging at a time when solid state electronics was rather new. We frequently had problems that crept into the logic panel. In order to solve these problems my first question would always be "when did this start?". Knowing when it started would often lead me to the cause. Doctors do the same thing. If things were going great in 2003 and fell apart in 2004 then we need to look back and see what happened in 2003. I agree with Russ, the larger the group, the larger the problem of keeping everything on track. When Badger Pond shut down we had an immeditate substantial increase in numbers. I remember asking Ellis for his thoughts on how to handle the larger numbers. It has been difficult to host from that time on. Other problems have occurred since then and some of these can be traced back to a new person who came on and tried to change the world. And you are right, there are some personalities that just clash. I will not say anything more on the subject but I suggest if anyone wants to solve the problems they must first identify the problems because that is always the starting point.

TD over and out

Re: Chat

#16

Directions

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi TD,

I guess I am reading this post over and over and part of me feels that I really do not care for the tone of your post. You say it's the last you have to say on the topic and yet you continue to drag it out. Frankly I am very dissapointed in this, sour grapes solve nothing.

WC has grown through a variety of avenues, Badger Pond's closing was indeed one of them but the widening access of the internet has also been a large part of Woodcenral's growth. Regardless of where an individual comes from or what they bring to the table we can all learn from each other...even with tolerance.

We are a community and we all have a voice, it's up to each individual here to decide what they like and do not like, who they wish to be friends with and not, it's a big imperfect world. Where I take issue is when I feel the tone of a post is not in tune with the direction of the site.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Chat

#17

No tone intended

TDaniel

>Hi Jim

Jim, I have always been taught that to solve a problem you must first identify it. My only reason for saying anything is that that is how you solve problems. If you can establish a time line and figure out what was done before and after the point where things changed then you can solve the problem. Sorry Bud, I was just offering and opinion along with everyone else. This whole issue is like walking through quicksand.....the more you try to do the less you accomplish.

TD

Re: Chat

#18

Re: No tone intended

Ron in Drums PA

>Please don't take offense TD.

But you seem to be the only one who has identified the person who seems to be the problem.

Re: Chat

#19

Stumped?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Okay....will the REAL self promoting,know it all please stand up! Becasue I'm clueless?

Sorry TD...maybe I'm blind?

Re: Chat

#20

Re: Stumped?

john lucas

>Jennifer OK i'll admit, I know it all. I just haven't been able to convince anyone else. :)

Re: Chat

#21

I knew it was YOU!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>You fit the description to a T!

Ha!

; )