We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I posted last week about making an urn. Lidded boxes were suggested. So I looked into that. I know there are other ways to do it, but this is also a new tool opportunity(!)- I want a scroll chuck and my B-day is fast approaching. My wife asked me the other night what I wanted and I answered her just like Ralphie did in the Christmas Story movie about the BB Gun. I replied quickly and without hesitation "A scroll chuck for my Jet mini!". She had no idea what I was talking about. I think she thought I was swearing at her. Not sure.
I was about to order the Teknatools Precision Midi Scroll Chuck Kit from Lee Valley. Then, as I looked into things further by going to the Teknatools web site, I find a Nova G3 Chuck. What the heck is that? It's only slightly more and appears to be 'geared'. What's that mean? Is it better then the other Tekna chuck? I thought the Nova stuff was a different company. Is it the same as OneWay? Guess not. I'm so confused....
So, if I buy this Nova G3 1X8tpi, do I need anything else to start playing around making boxes and small bowls? Are there other parts that go with this G3 that are must haves? I suppose a bowl gouge, but other than that, anything else?
>I have the Nova for the Jet Mini plus the Nova G2 and the OneWay Talon. The latter two I use on my DVR XP for bowl turning. My favorite and most used chuck is the Artisan from Craft Supplies which is the same as the Barracuda2 from Penn State. It's also the cheapest and comes with pin jaws right up to the #3 jaws. I make a lot of small items such as lidded boxes, chain pulls, etc., and the assortment of jaws makes things real easy.....Ron
>The G3 is a newer model from Nova/Teknitool. It is a geared chuck. You should be happy with it. Most chucks are supplied with only one set of jaws. Usually you get a midsize typically #2 jaw.
You can use the chuck just as it comes with no additions required as long as what you want to grip fits in the range of a #2 jaw. The jaw information should be available from the seller. The #2 jaw is probably right for your box/urn project.
>I don't want to discourage you from getting a chuck, but you don't need one for making boxes. Bonnie Klein, who's known for her boxes and other small sized work, prefers using face plates and glue blocks for turning boxes. Every time you remove a turning from a chuck, it's difficult to get return it to the chuck in exactly the same manner it was originally mounted. This results in the piece not running true and requires you to waste some more wood to get it back running true. With only one chuck, most of us pop the lid and box in and out of the chuck several times -- making it more difficult to get a good fitting lid. By using two face plates with glue blocks, one for the box and the other for the lid, this problem is reduced.
Here's a link to Bonnie's web site. It's got a lot of good information:
>Bonnie Klein is a great person and a wonderful turner. David is right you do not need a chuck for boxes or bowls. It just makes it easier. Get a look at Bonnie's series of videos and she does a great job of explaining the process of boxes bowls and other items. Chris Stott also does a great job of boxes in his book and videos. Now if you have the ok to buy a chuck I don't want to stop you. The chucks mentioned are good quality. Also an option is the Vicmarc 3 1/2 chuck. For a mini a smaller chuck is recommended. Like the ones mentioned.
>All the scroll chucks I'm familiar with come with a wood-worm (screw) to convert the scroll chuck to a screw chuck, which can be used with a glue block. In my opinion a screw chuck is much easier to use than a face plate for small to medium size turning. A screw chuck would certainly work with any turning you would want to do on a Jet Mini-lathe. My recommedation is go with the scroll chuck (I like the small Vic Mark but the others are also good chucks) and you get more options for all the types of turnings you will want to do on a mini-lathe.
>you need it. But don't neglect to try the glue block on a face plate. I would far rather turn with a glue block on a face plate like Bonnie turns than with a scroll chuck although I do own a scroll chuck. A scroll chuck will limit you in ways that a glue block won't. I never liked turning with a block on the screw that came with my chuck. Just my preference. Heck, you might mike it.
>Ed, good idea about the notches. Thanks. My SN2 jaws are not numbered as well as I'd like. I'll notch them, now, and end the straining to see those little numbers.
I also mark my No 1 Jaw so I can re-chuck the same every time. It works!
For me it is easier to learn from visual on complicated steps.
North Coast Woodturners Club meets on the 1st Saturday morning of every month at your backyard - Cleveland suburb. Next month Dick Sing is going to demonstrate for two days. You may be able to see him how to turn a box in person.
They also have a great collection of library material for members to check out.
Chris Stott, Richard Raffan, Ray Key and Bonnie Kline are just a few who make beautiful boxes. Each demonstrated several methods to make perfect boxes. You may want to watch them all and adapt whatever method you like. I personally think each method has their pros and cons, you just have to choose whatever you are comfortable.
You can find the list of videos: (BTW, there is a $10 deposit for each video checked out; you will get your money back next meeting when you return the borrowed material.)
http://ncwt.org/Library/Videotapes.htm
The $20 membership fee gets you the best tool.
Tom Knapp, a regular at Wood Central here, is the new VP of the Club.
I think a chuck is a good tool just for the sake of convenience.
Short answer: I'd get the chuck. Other tools needed: spindle gouge and square-end scraper if you want flat bottoms.
Longer answer: you don't NEED a chuck to do boxes at all, but it does make it easier and a little faster. For removing and re-mounting work to run true, dovetail jaws are FAR superior to those with teeth or grooves (which are better for gripping other things, like green wood). Oneway calls these "smooth jaws, BTW.) A little experience with just how tight you need to grip things helps a lot, too, as you can crush the wood by over-tightening, and the wood won't crush evenly in most cases. The G-3 comes with 2" (50mm) dovetail jaws, so you're all set there. you need to make an accurate dovetail tenon for the chuck jaws to grip optimally.
If you want to use a waste block, you can also mount one in your chuck, but you will be that much further away from the spindle, so waste blocks on faceplates are often more stable, creating less vibration & chatter. In your sequence, I'd add step 1.5: true up face of glue block before gluing on the work piece. In answer to two other questions that came up, 1) your final foot size is not limited by the size or shape of the chuck jaws (at least with these #2's...), as you can shape the foot as large or as small as you like if you leave a little waste. 2) Afer you part off the pieces, they are usually mounted on a "friction chuck" for finishing the top of the top or the bottom of the bottom. A "friction chuck" is a fancy way of saying a carefuly sized piece of wood attached to your faceplate or held in your chuck. This is sized with a small step that snugly fits into the box part you're working on, and if you can get a perfect fit, the piece is held by friction alone, though you can also use the tailstock for most of the procedure -- removing it for the final shaping and sanding.
Best of luck and safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
PS: hope my typing is OK -- its -4F outside (finally winter), and probably only about 20 degrees warmer in my office until the heat catches up!
I'm sorry. I gave you a link to Bonnie's website without going there myself to verify it had the information I thought it did. The information I recalled being on her website is actually in her book, "Classic Woodturning Projects with Bonnie Klein".
Here's how to turn a box using glue blocks: Bonnie makes glue blocks out of 1" pine stock and a hole saw. Take a 1x4 piece of pine and a 3" or 3.5" hole saw mounted in your drill press and cut a bunch of holes. (There's nothing magical about 1" pine stock -- other than it's cheap. You could use another wood or plywood or MDF.) The holes become your glue blocks. Center a glue block on your face plate (or screw chuck, if you have one) and attach it firmly. Bonnie uses double stick tape to do this, but screws will work, too. Mount the face plate onto the spindle of your lathe and, while the lathe is turning, use a pen or pencil to make a series of concentric circles on the glue block. Use the circles to help center the blank for your box on the glue block and glue it in place. Bonnie uses medium CA glue, but yellow glue would work, too. Bring up a live center mounted in the tail stock to support your box blank and turn the blank round. Determine which part of the blank will be the top of the box and which will be the bottom and part off the bottom, leaving the top mounted to the glue block. (This assumes the top and bottom will be from the same blank. If you are going to use different blanks, skip this step.) Establish where you want the tennon from the bottom to fit into the lid and turn a recess to match that tennon using a scraper or a skew. Make sure the sides of the recess are parallel to the lathe ways -- it must go straight back if you are going to get a good fit -- and make the recess about 3/16" deep. Establish a small shoulder at the bottom of the recess that will rest on the top of the tennon of the bottom of the box when the box is closed. Then finish hollowing the lid and rough turn the outside of the lid. Sand and finish the inside of the box lid. Remove the lid from the lathe (still attached to the glue block) and mount the blank of the bottom. Carefully turn a tennon that is a tight fit in the lid's recess. Then hollow the box, sand and finish the interior. Check to see that the tennon is still a good fit for the lid. (Sometimes hollowing the interior will cause the wood to move enough to affect the fit.) Once it fits with firm pressure, remove the bottom from the lathe (still attached to the glue block). Remount the lid onto the lathe and finish shaping the outside as much as you can with it on the glue block, and then part the lid off from the glue block. Remount the the box bottom on the lathe and mount the lid onto the box bottom as a jam chuck. Carefully finish turning the lid's top. With the lid still mounted on the box's bottom, establish the exterior lines of the box. (Having the lid on the box helps you "see" the form of the box.) Remove the lid and finish turning the box's exterior as much as you can with it still on the glue block. Now, carefully chamfer the rim of the box's tennon. Using the long point of your skew, carefully relieve the bottom third of the tennon. The goal is to reduce, but not eliminate, the amount of force required to get the lid to slip onto the tennon. Try the fit of the lid and lightly sand the tennon as necessary to get the fit you desire. Then, sand and finish the box's exterior and part it off of the glue block. Turn a recess in what remains of the glue block that the box bottom's tennon will fit into with firm pressure. Then, carefully finish turning the box's bottom. Sand and finish, you're done!
I'm fully aware that some turn a box in slightly a different order, using slightly different methods. So do I, at times. Rather than explaining all the options, I thought it best to just explain one way it can be done.