Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Techniques for sanding spalted woods?

Posts

Techniques for sanding spalted woods?

#1

Steven Antonucci

Techniques for sanding spalted woods?

Steve Antonucci

>I have some spalted/punky/wormy/almost too far gone maple that I grabbed from a large tree on the roadside a year or so back. There are spots that are too far gone (pinch a handful), and others that are spectacularly spalted.

In the past, if I sand this type of maple, the spalt dust muddies up he clear sections and it doesn't have the same visual appeal. I have used pretty good technique to turn a form, but some areas were so soft that even Ellsworth couldn't cut them cleanly!

Before you say that life is too short to turn bad wood, you'd need to see this. It's not bad wood (most of it...) Does anyone have any hints for sanding (by hand) on wood this delicate? Would it help to spray a coat of lacquer or CA first to cut down on the dust staining?

All thoughts appreciated.

Steve

Re: Techniques for sanding spalted woods?

#2

Re: Techniques for sanding spalted woods?

Dennis Yoder

>Steve, I've had good luck applying 50-50 reduced Deft. Dennis Y

Re: Techniques for sanding spalted woods?

#3

Re: Techniques for sanding spalted woods? *LINK*

Derek Andrews

>If I have punky wood like this, I rough turn to nearly the right shape, then soak the wood in acrylic floor polish which will harden the wood quite well once dry. It should make the turning go better so you will have less sanding to do.

Another problem with sanding spalted wood is that it is very easy to sand the soft spots flat, so the less sanding the better.


The ToolRest - a blog for woodturners

Re: Techniques for sanding spalted woods?

#4

Re: Techniques for sanding spalted woods?

Dave Belser

>Steve, I've had good luck with 50/50 deft and thiner. Soak it good. You can even get close to final shape and soak it before the last cuts. Sanding will still take some finesse so you don't over sand the soft stuff but not nearly as bad as not soaking at all.

When I hear people say "life is to short to turn crappy/rotten/bad wood" I hear "I'm not creative enough to figure out what to do with this piece". Of course there is always wood to far gone or just not good looking enough to bother turning, and some people either need to be making money or don't have a lot of time to turn - but it still gets used as a dismissive statement to often

- Dave

Re: Techniques for sanding spalted woods?

#5

Steven Antonucci

A picture of the wood in question

Steve Antonucci

>This egg was cut with a razor sharp skew. I've carefully picked out the bug crap, and now I'm facing a decision of "high finish" on the wooden surfaces contrasting the rougher bug/spalt effected areas

OR

roughing the whole egg form with a wire brush to give it an overall texture.

OR

Filling the holes with some crushed stones and going high finish on the whole piece.

Opinions welcome, again. For the record, the piece is about 4"x6" and was going to be a hollowform until the egg shape emerged. Box of chocolates...

Steve


img

Re: Techniques for sanding spalted woods?

#6

Re: A picture of the wood in question

Dave Belser

>Steve, that looks like it will be beautiful.

I don't think you should fill the holes, I've rarely seen an inlace that actually looked better than the holes. If you must fill the holes, how about copper or gold.

As far as gloss or rough, I don't know, it looks pretty good now and I think gloss might take away from the ancient artifact look.

- Dave

Re: Techniques for sanding spalted woods?

#7

Re: Techniques for sanding spalted woods?

ben d.

>I usually do everything backwards from anyone else but I finished some spalted sycamore that looks like what you have minus the worms and this is what I did.

Turned down to about where I wanted sanded with a 100 grit sanding wheel in a drill applied lacquor sanding sealer took 3 coats before it quit soaking in re-turned the bowl to get rid of most of the flat spots then hand sanded to 600 I think waxed and buffed it out.

Re: Techniques for sanding spalted woods?

#8

Re: A picture of the wood in question

GaryG in MD

>Steve,

Interesting piece. I'd vote for "none of the above".

I agree with Dave -- no fill. It already seems to have some texture. If it were mine, I'd do a low-gloss (satin) finish with something that won't darken the color. Maybe a couple light coats of lacquer rubbed out gently to Abralon 1k or 2k.

Let's see it again when you're done. ...Gary

Re: Techniques for sanding spalted woods?

#9

Re: A picture of the wood in question *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

>Steve, there is a product pool cue and knife makers use called Nelsonite. They soak the item and then let it dry. I've had very good luck painting it on very heavy using several coat, letting it soak in with each coat. Keep it wet until it looks like it has soaked up as much as it is going to. The stuff does smell pretty strong while wet so proper ventilation is a must. The link is a source to buy it by the gallon. You can get it cheaper from the mfg. but they have a 4 or 5 gallon minimum.


Nelsonite

Re: Techniques for sanding spalted woods?

#10

Roger Dunn

Re: Techniques for sanding spalted woods?

Roger Dunn

>I had a real bad piece of Spalted Alder and tried one of Wally Dickerman's techinques: soaked it with BLO and the sanded with BLO from 100 up through 600 grit. The BLO and dust creates a wonderful slurry that fills peckish spots as well as tearout. This bowl is about 13.75 inches in diameter and was sold at Xmas time.


img

Re: Techniques for sanding spalted woods?

#11

Bet that made the hen's eyes water

Clay Foster

>It's is finished. Have some one take it away from you before you mess it up.

Re: Techniques for sanding spalted woods?

#12

Re: Techniques for sanding spalted woods?

Robert Simmons

>I've salvaged some pretty punky wood by giving it a good soak in Minwax Wood Hardener. Let it soak in good, dry thoroughly and turn away. It's been good for smaller pieces, too expensive for really big stuff.

Robert