Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Turning Chisels

Posts

Turning Chisels

#1

Turning Chisels

C.W.Stivison

>I am going to buy first lathe this weekend. Is it better for a beginner to buy carbide tipped chisels or HSS chisels.

Re: Turning Chisels

#2

Re: Turning Chisels

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>HSS. Even if you're a pro.

Re: Turning Chisels

#3

Re: Turning Chisels

Rick Davenport

>I would suggest getting an inexpensive HSS starter set from someplace like Penn State or Harbor Tools.

When you get hooked, and start to find exactly what and how you want to turn, then you can start buying the expensive, specific cutting tools.

And don't forget to join your local woodturning club.

You can find it by going to www.woodturner.org

Welcome to the club!

R

Re: Turning Chisels

#4

Dick Hines

Re: Turning Chisels

Dick Hines

>You did not say what you will be turning. Like bowls, spindles, or pens. You will need different tools for spindle turning than you need for bowls.

Buy HSS and get the best you can afford. Check with a club close to you. I am sure they will be able to help you out. Check to see if you have a Wood Craft close too.

Enjoy turning.

Re: Turning Chisels

#5

Re: Turning Chisels

Bill Crommett

>Here comes that odd opinion again: Don't waste your money on good tools until you find that you are going to be using them more than once in a while. If you will get an inexpensive set of High Carbon tools, you will have cheap steel to practice your sharpening on, and you will grind away a lot of steel learning to sharpen. If yopu find what your addiction is you can buy good tools in the configuration you need and you can regrind your High Carbon for special purposes that will be only used on occasion.

A bonus is that some High Carbon steels will actually sharpen up to a finer edge than HSS, but not all. But they will not hold an edge as long.

Re: Turning Chisels

#6

Re: Turning Chisels

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>You didn't what size lathe you were going to buy, if it a mid size lathe I would start with one tool to turn green bowls.

The Ellsworth gouge, his sharpening jig and his video. IMO it's simple and has clear instructions.

I started on Glaser tools and only lost 1/2 inch learning to sharpen.

Re: Turning Chisels

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Turning Chisels:HSS my final answer

Keith Tompkins

>

Re: Turning Chisels

#8

Brad Vietje

HSS

Brad Vietje

>

Re: Turning Chisels

#9

Steven Antonucci

Ever try to sharpen carbide? Buy HSS.

Steve Antonucci

>

Re: Turning Chisels

#10

Re: Turning Chisels

eaglesc

>HArbor Freight has a set for $12.00.I have been using them for 2&1/2 years.

Of Course if you are a tool snob they have a set that goes for $40.00.

In a pinch I have ground and hones a screwdriver.

When it comes to the battle of wood versus steel, steel usually wins.

I don't think the wood cares where the steel came from or how much you paid for it.

Get the carbide set if you plan on turning a lot of steel.

HF has a set of those for $5.00

Re: Turning Chisels

#11

Re: Turning Chisels

Russ Fairfield

>Stay with the High Speed (HSS) tools. I am one of those who recommend the less expensive HSS tools until you have learned to grind them. Sharpening a cutting edge is the biggest obstacle to many [people learning how to turn wood. Learning to do that is best done on cheap steel, unless you have a desire to grind away a lot of that $100 gouge while you are learning to create and duplicate a tool profile that you can use. The wood will nebver know how much you paid for the tool.

There are a lot of reasons for not using carbide turning tools. Unless you are paying big bucks for a super high grade of carbide, they are usually made from a C4 grade. While a C4 might be a good explosive for blowing up bridges, a C4 carbide is not a good grade for a turning tool. You can grind away at it with your grinding wheel, but you will never get it as sharp as the same tool in HSS and it is much more brittle than the steel.

There are grades of carbide that are suitable for turning tools, but you can't buy those at Harbor Freight, and they will require a diamond grinding wheel to sharpen them.

Re: Turning Chisels

#12

I do. It takes a green sharpening wheel.

john lucas

>