We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>This Hollowform is West Indian Rosewood with an Ebony collar. Approx. 6"dia x 5.25" tall; finish is 2 coats of lacquer, I expect to add 2 more coats.
I took this photo in my Phrugal setup, using a 500w Halogen Shoplight on the right, shooting through two thicknesses of a white sheet and two thicknesses of a white hankies. I used one white reflector board on the left.
I think the left shot is a bit fuzzy.
I'd like some serious critiques on this form, please.
>Allen, I love it. The ebony collar in the pic on the left really accents the line between the heartwood and new growth. At first it's a little difficult to actually see the outline of the form because that wonderful grain keeps pulling your eye to it.
I can't critique, I'm not qualified, but I really like the wood, the form and the finish.
>Allen It is a really nice piece. I love how you used the grain. I like the little lift area just before the ebony. That sets the collar off nicely. The only thing that bothers me is the curve just below the transitin point about 1/2 way through the vessel. It may be the photography but it looks like this are doesn't flow with the curve from the foot to the transition. In the photo on the left it looks like a better curve. The one on the right looks like there are is a slight flatening of the curve just below the transition from the top curve to the bottom.
>John, thanks for the critique! :o) When I read your post, I went to get it, so I could look at that area, also. I held it in my hands, and turned it around so I could feel it. I did feel that flattening of the curve. Can't see it in the left photo, but it is definately on the same spot as the right shot.
I don't think it was there when I brought it in from the shop, and it's right to the left of that pith area where a limb was located. Do you think it could be caused by some wood movement due to that pith? If it moved there, wouldn't it have to move somewhere else to compensate? I think the wood was dry enough to turn.
Maybe I caused that flat spot when I finished turned the bottom....
It's been over a week since I turned it... suffering a little from CRSAWAIUTRS. (Can't Remember Stuff As Well As I Used To Remember Stuff)
>Thanks, Gil, I was pretty well satisfied that I had finally nailed it, then John Lucas busted my bubble. :o) (I say that with a smile on my face, John. I do appreciate the critique.0
Gotta get me some cardboard and paint it black....
>The yellow shows the discontinuity area of the curve. The line is not a suggestion of the shape, it's just to show the area. Like John, I do like the uplift in the top before the collar. A very nice piece, no doubt.
>Beautiful work Allen. I like the form and shape. However, if you draw a line from the center of the base up through the top the collar appears to be offset to the right. This could be wood movement. It's still a beautiful piece.....Ron
>A limb section can definitely warp a little as can any really wild grain areas. I did a ball once and went to great lengths to make sure it was perfectly round. It was roughed out, dried and returned. It still warped a little. When you remove wood you often relieve stresses in the wood and it will move even when dry.
I do see the TINY deviation from an ideal curve, but, in general, this is an excellent little vessel -- and a nice job.
I've had a few HF's warp just a little differently near figured wood, and sometimes a flat-ish area can result. I usually finish 'em green to accentuate this, while Wally would have you twice-turn it as you have. Maybe with a few highly-figured areas, you could take it almost to completion (after air drying for a few months, per usual), then wait a few days more before doing any "final" finish turning...? I've done this with boxes from air-dried wood, so it might help with slightly warped HF's, too. By finishing up between centers you should have enough support to make small tweaks to the profile even on pretty thin-walled vessels.
>I think that's an optical illusion, because I didn't have my camera straight when I took the shot. I had the little tripod sitting in a chair, and had to adjust one leg a little longer than the others, and got it too far, or not far enough. To me, it makes the whole form appear to be leaning. :o)
>I appreciate the comments, and the suggestions. Question for you: How do you put the tailstock against an already finished bottom, if you want to tweak the form a little?
If I have the collar in a small Jam Chuck, in order to make slight changes to the form, I want to be able to see the bottom edge, but don't want to mar an already finished bottom. Maybe a piece of wood, shaped to a small size... say a dime... with rubber facing?
Would that put enough pressure on it to keep it from coming off?
(My jam chuck has a leather padded rod that goes to the bottom of the piece.)
>I think you would get enough pressure to hold it. But, I wouldn't try it. I know I would screw up what is a very nice looking piece trying to make that one cut.
>I'd say it depends on the shape of the bottom. I usually recess the base a little, with a distinct step. I can then turn a mating shape to drive the piece from the foot end.
I also drive them the other way -- I have a live center with interchangeable tips that can help with this. I can usually find one of the tips to support the underside enough to use friction from a tenon that fits into the spout for very light cuts, scrapes, or sanding. One of the tips is a raised, sorta sharp ring, about 1/2" in diameter, and without a central point. Sometimes I cut a pair of grooves in the foot so one will match this ring. If so, then very gentle pressure with this center at the tail end works very well. I've also used a pretty thin circular piece of leather between the bottom of the foot and the ring-tipped tail center.
>until it is completely finished except on the bottom. Then a careful parting would leave only a tiny nub to smooth and sand. Ok, I am old fashioned but it could be done.
Peter has found the problem. Same flattened areas on both pics. Thought I'd nailed this one, and sure 'nuff, I hadn't. :o)
Thought it might be from the pith of the limb in the lower portion, and sure 'nuff, it wasn't.
The problem is with my eye. Wish I could learn to see these things before I take it off the lathe. :o( I've tried the straight edge thing... can't do it. Got to get a black cardboard... (I keep saying that... maybe I'll get to it now.)
Sure thought I'd nailed it.. oh well... maybe one day....... sigh..... back to the lathe...
Anyway, thanks for the comments, critiques, and for just looking. :o)
>Don't worry. Your work is very nice even with a little flat spot. I've been turning for years and I still am chasing that elusive "perfect shape". I get close but never seem to get it perfect. I guess if we could get it perfect every time it would take a lot of the fun and challenge out of turning. I've often thought that turning must have been boring for Bob Stocksdale because he made turning the perfect shapes look so easy!! For most of us, we just have to hang in there and keep trying for that one perfect piece. And you are SO close!