Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Is this oak spalted?

Posts

Is this oak spalted?

#1

Is this oak spalted?

Pat

>I rough-turned a small bowl from some oak that I found locally (MD) and it looks spalted, but I don't have any experience with that. Is this spalting? (It is wet, the photo was post-removal from an alcohol soak.)


img

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#2

JL

Re: It may be, or maybe not

JL

>You might possibly have an iron stain. Oak reacts in such a fashion with iron.

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#3

Re: It may be, or maybe not

Pat

>I cut this myself from a full log with a chainsaw, and the streaks were apparent throughout the wood immediately. How exactly would an iron reaction occur?

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#4

JL

Re: It may be, or maybe not

JL

>It may be spalting. Whenever I see dark stains or streaks in oak, I usually get "suspicious". I had several nice pieces of straight grain white oak in a water tank to keep them wet. A piece of steel had dropped in the tank. Voila - nice dark stains and streaks when I took them out a couple of days later. I was not a happy camper! I was planning on staining that oak!

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#5

Re: Is this oak spalted?

Dave Belser

>I would call this stain but the distinction may be moot.

Personally it bothers me the way people toss "Spalted" around. There are many ways that streaks of color can be introduced into wood, ants and bugs for instance. The section of a tree above an ant colony can have all sorts of black and brown streaks. In order of me to call it spalting I want to see some deteriorating of the wood (rotting). Spalting is the different coloring of the wood depending on how rotten it is and the streaks of mold and fungus that penetrates. Again this is just my opinion and it's kind of spliting hairs.

The photo is of an oak box that I tunned from a small 4" dia branch that was dead on the tree and dried very well without checking. The color is from where the branch was lying on the ground and the bark stayed wet.

Is it a fungus? I don't know but the wood was still very sound. If you leave an oak board or chair out in the weather it will turn the same nice dark similar color.

I also acquired a huge oak trunk section (original tree was 5' across) that was partially hollow, with ants, punky sections you could crush with your fingers, and plenty of scab growth. I'll post a picture of a a bowl that contains a white section that was starting to get punky and has brown streaks in it.

- Dave


img

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#6

Re: Is this oak spalted?

Dave Belser

>The color balance is off on this photo, but the section front and center is white with brown streaks through it. As I said the wood was soft and a little punky - I would call this spalt. The dark section below is more of a water stain. To the left is a bark inclusion followed by a white scab growth on the left edge of the bowl. As I said, this wood had a lot going on.

Scab vs. Burl is another area that people tend to not be too precise. To my mind, a burl has a very unusual growth pattern to it. A lot of times a tree will grow over an injury and the growth is actually very organized, just not in a vertical direction! This tree had a huge buttress that grew between to trunks around where an earlier trunk broke off.

Another common place to find scabs is over a trimmed or broken branch.

To me a burl is a roundish bump growth that has a conical growth pattern to it.

Once again this is largely just my opinion :) I really like terms that describe wood to be precise, especially when used by people who are woodworkers. The general public often doesn't really care why or how a piece of wood got to be so pretty looking!

If we are talking and I offer to give you this "piece of birch burl" that I have I'd like you have the same image in your mind as I have..

The same sort of thing applies to discussions of figure.

Anyhow, I guess I'm just in the mode to post my opinion tonight :)

Enjoy your oak!

- Dave


img

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#7

I guess I am not sure.

Don Henthorn

>Here is a pic of a bowl I turned from a chunk of red oak that had lain on the concrete floor of my storage shed for about six months. I figured it was spalted.




img

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#8

Steve Kubien

I like it

Steve Kubien

>I think I will try that "experiment" someday soon. I really like that look.

Steve Kubien

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#9

Sticking my neck out even further.....

Dave Belser

>That looks like spalt to me. On the left edge the dark lines appear to be around an area of that is starting to decay. Before you turned it what did the outside of the piece look like? did it show signs of organic decay.

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#10

Re: I like it

Pat

>I like it too, so I have no complaints.

Could it be anything else? I assume it's not a natural oak coloration. If it is staining, it happened before the local power company dumped it, so I kind of doubt it.

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#11

Re: Is this oak spalted?

Brian McInturff in SC

>This is a piece of spalted oak I did awhile back


img

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#12

Re: Is this oak spalted?

Pat

>Thanks for all the good information, Dave. I'm brand new to this, so that's exactly the type of clarification I was looking for.

Based on your statements, I'm guessing that the streaks are fungal because of the wetness of the wood, the softer texture in the dark area, and being pretty sure that the log sat out in the rain for a while after it was dumped by the power company. Also there are not any signs of bugs, at least that I can find.

It doesn't really look like the other examples posted, but I don't see any other explanation that is as likely.

I was pleasantly surprised to find the streaks, and again pleased to see the prominent placement near the rim. Hopefully when it's dry and gets the final turning it will look even nicer.

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#13

Re: Is this oak spalted?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Brian,

Your pic doesn't show for some reason on my computer.

Gary

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#14

Re: Is this oak spalted?

Jim King

>This is a classic fungal spalt. Your peice in my opinion looks to be a type of stain.


img

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#15

Re: Is this oak spalted?

Jim King

>This is a classic fungal spalt. Your peice in my opinion looks to be a type of stain.


img

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#16

Re: Is this oak spalted?

Brian McInturff in SC

>Gary,

Let me know if you still can't see the pic. I checked the properties and it should work. Can anyone else see it? Thanks, Brian

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#17

Re: Is this oak spalted?

Dale Stansbery

>Since it was cut by the power company, It may have been in a fence row and was cut right above the ingrown fence. I cut a walnut onetime that had stain that ran a couple feet above the fence wire.

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#18

Re: Is this oak spalted?

Ralph Watts

>Pat,

One way to "maybe" tell if it is spalting or stain is to bleach a piece. Typically the bleach will not remove spalting stains (the black lines) while bleach will remove a stain such as mildue. If it is iron stain, oxalic acid will remove the iron stain. I used the acid to remove nail stain on some chestnut. It will not remove mildue.

A nice piece anyhow... Best regards

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#19

Re: I can see it.

Al Crandall (N.E. of Indy)

>

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#20

Brian, I see it OK

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#21

It wasn't punky yet,

Don Henthorn

>but it wasn't as hard as I expected.

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#22

Got it now, thanks.

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Nice work and some beautiful wood. Don't know why it wouldn't work before.

Gary

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#23

Re: Is this oak spalted?

Pat from MD

>Very interesting. I was trying to think of how it could be stained, but I hadn't thought of that. Thanks!

Re: Is this oak spalted?

#24

Re: Is this oak spalted?

Pat from MD

>Good tip. If I get a chance, I'll test it. Thanks for the input.