Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Soap soakers - HELP!!

Posts

Soap soakers - HELP!!

#1

Soap soakers - HELP!!

Ed Moore

>I have been told about the drying method for bowls in which they are soaked in a solution of water and Costco dishwashing liquid. Well, there are no Costcos around here, so I went to Sam's Club and bought several large containers of orange Palmolive liquid dishwashing detergent. After putting a lot of water into a large container I started adding the Palmolive. Before long I realized that the liquid soap was concentrated and I have a LARGE container of orange gel into which I have placed several large bowls. I have more than twice as much water as soap, but the gel consistency is persistent.

My questions: 1. Is the Kirkland liquid dishwashing detergent from Costco concentrated?

2. Is there a snowball's chance that this concentrated solution will have the desired effect?

3. Should I withdraw some of the gunk and add more water until I get a more dilute solution?

Ed

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#2

Tiny Bubbles!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hmm...Ed, I've never known that it had to be certain brand of soap? I usually use anything that is cheap...like from the Dollar Store...and that isn't brightly dyed with color. I try to stick with clear or that very pale yellowish one. I'm sure you'll be okay with what you've got going on there, but you may have wasted a little bit of money.

You may want to avoid wet sanding when you get to that point! Ha!

That was suppose to be funny :)

....am I the only one chuckling?

Jen :)

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#3

AHAH!

Ed Moore

>Hi Jen,

Of all the possibilities, I never considered the Dollar Store. Hmmm!

Anybody have any dishes they need washed?

Ed

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#4

Re: AHAH!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Let me make it very clear Ed...that I am not CHEAP....just THRIFTY!

Heee-hee.

:)

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#5

Re: AHAH!

Ed Moore

>Jennifer! When telling the guys about you I have NEVER used the word "cheap". Honest!

Ed

Chuckle, chuckle!

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#6

He He, A Free Lesson

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>In Boi-chemistry is what you have, Ed.

That blob you have (I had 16 GALLONS of the stuff) is the result of combination of the extractive proteins from your wood forming long-chain organic molecules. In a word, you've made Slime. Much like the stuff they sell to kids in colors. Sorry, adding water won't help.

You should have seen the look on the guys faces when I showed up at the county homeowner hazmat clean up day with that load. They were looking like they was afraid the stuff was going to crawl out of the bin and eat their truck. Wouldn't take it until the resident chemist came over to see what the fuss was all about. Dude walked away laughing after I explained exactly what I had.

Now you know (partly) why I don't "soap soak" anymore.

|;-}}}}}

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#7

Re: AHAH!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Whew! Thank you Ed :)

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#8

Re: He He, A Free Lesson

Barry Irby

>One of our frequent contributofs here let a batch of this sort of stuff "escape" in his shop. (I'll let him confess if he wishes) Tells the story of trying to clean up gallons of it. Be careful and don't spill it.

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#9

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

Allen Neighbors

>Ed, I use Ivory Concentrated Dish Washing Soap. I mix it 50/50.

As far as the Orange Palmolive, I don't know what it is. You say it is a "gel". It is really a 'gelled' substance, now that you've added the water? If so, here's what I would do:

I would take out a measured amount of it... say 1/2 gallon... then I would add 1 quart of water, mix it up and check the consistency. If that needed thinning more, I would add another quart. I'd keep doing this... keeping track of how much I had to add to the half gallon. That way you can know how much to add to the rest of it to thin it down properly. The idea is this -- when you get it right, and it works, you need to know the exact mixture.

My mixture isn't gel, but it is thick enough that you can't wipe it off your hands easily.

I soak my roughturned bowls for one month minimum. Then I turn them wet. I have less cracking this way. They oval out pretty much, and do some strange things :o) but they don't crack much. I've got one batch of mixture that I've been using for about 6 months, and another batch that's fresh. After 8 or 10 average size bowls, I add a half gallon of DNA to the mixture, and will toss it after about a year. It works pretty well for me.

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#10

Re: I confess, Barry, I'm one;

Allen Neighbors

>I spilled about 15 gallons of it one day... took A WHILE to get it cleaned up. After it was all over, I spread a half ton of sawdust around on my wooden floor to keep from slipping. It stunk, too.

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#11

Re: Soaking wood in the dish water causes insanity

Russ Fairfield

>

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#12

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Allan, do you really go to all of that trouble and mess to keep your rough-outs from cracking? I very liberally coat all of my rough-outs with Johnson's paste wax, which takes about 1 minute, and I have very few problems with cracking. If I'm turning a wood that's prone to cracking, cherry or fruit wood, I paper bag it for a few weeks.

I live in hot dry Arizona and I don't have AC in my shop, so drying conditions are tough.

Wally

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#13

Wally: Where Do You Find Johnson's These Days?

Garrett in Victoria BC

>

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#14

Then, Jedi, there is another, the Force is strong.

Barry Irby

>....In that one.

They ahd a big mess too. Somewhat like foaming the runway.

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#15

Russ, You may use me as a new example!

Ed Moore

>

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#16

Re: Wally: Where Do You Find Johnson's These Days?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I buy direct from Johnson's, 6 cans to a case. Check their website.

Wally

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#17

Re: Wally: Where Do You Find Johnson's These Days?

Ron in Drums PA

>I just picked up a can at Loews

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#18

Re: Yep, sure do.

Allen Neighbors

>I do, Wally, because all my roughouts (not many, because I quit this) that I wrapped in paper cracked pretty badly. Since then, I have always soaked in the soap solution, and turned them wet. Haven't had as much bad luck with them.

I have some Honey Locust that I'm intending to rough out and coat with Anchorseal, and see how that works for me, but I haven't tried it yet. I copied and pasted all those answers in my Roughout Post, and will take it to the shop when I get it printed, so I can try the ones I think will work for me. I'm going to keep a lot of notes, so I will be able to know for sure.

Your living in a hot dry climate gives me hope for the Anchorseal route.

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#19

Re: I misread your post, Wally.

Allen Neighbors

>I thought I read Anchorseal... but I see that you use Johnson's Wax. I can get it in WalMart, and I still have part of a can, so I'll try that, too.

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#20

Re: Me, too, Russ, I guess that's

Allen Neighbors

>why folks look at me funny these days. :o) I always thought it was because my hands looked and smelled so nice!

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#21

Maybe you should...

Bob Fawcett

>be making those dish soap commercials, Allen :-).

Had me LOL.

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#22

Re: I misread your post, Wally.

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Allen, be sure that you really slather it on. 2 coats if you're in doubt.

Johnson's doesn't seal the wood better than Anchorseal (in fact not as much). The whole idea is to slow the drying to prevent cracking.

I've posted this pic before. It's in John Jordan's Tape on wood. It shows about 75 of my rough turned pieces....not one is cracked.

Wally


img

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#23

I'll sneak in here. Wally do you

Don Henthorn

>coat the inside as well? How do you do the hollow forms?

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#24

Re: I'll sneak in here. Wally do you

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Don, wax is applied to the outside of hollow forms. On bowls I do them both inside and outside. Some turners do only the outside on bowls.

Wally

Re: Soap soakers - HELP!!

#25

Re: HELP - Maybe

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Ed,

This issue happened to come up in a conversation I had with a chemist last evening. He suggested, depending on the components actually used in the LDD, that the addition of a bit of sodium cloride might break the "chains" and reliquify the mess. I'd "spoon out" a cup or two of goo and give it a few shakes and a bit of brine to see what happens.

|;-}}