Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Gouge hardening question

Posts

Gouge hardening question

#1

Gouge hardening question

John Lucas

>I have a Henry Taylor spindle gouge that is my favorite. I've had it about 5 years. It's HSS, probably M2 but I don't know for sure. Anyway all of the sudden it seems like it just won't hold an edge for very long. I don't remember it acting like this before, or maybe I'm just getting pickier on my edge sharpness.

I assume that most gouges would be hardened over thier full length by simply placing them in an oven. Possibly the tang might be annealed a little but I would think the entire flute area would be the same hardness. Anyone else have this problem with a tool.

I have seen this problem in older carbon steel tools. An old time turner told me this happened a lot on older tools as you ground them down. He thought they only hardened the first 2 or 3 inches. When this happened he would just reharden the next few inches and continue on. We can't do that with HSS at home.

Re: Gouge hardening question

#2

Yup...

Peter Teubel

>I've got a couple 3/8" detail gouges that are in their last 1.5" of flute. They too are not holding an edge. I believe they are Sorby. I'm waiting on Doug Thompson to produce some CPM-10V spindle gouges so I can replace a few of mine.

Re: Gouge hardening question

#3

Re: Yup...

eliot d

>I hope you won't consider that I'm hijacking this thread, but could you remind me: is Doug Thompson the turner who also makes the hook tool tips? If he's who I think he is, I think he sells them for about $40 each. So is he the guy? And do you have a link?

Re: Gouge hardening question

#5

Re: Nope...

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>The tang could be annealed but my guess is a induction heater is used so the tang would never be exposed to the high temperature. The tool would be case hardened... good idea to reduce breakage.

Thanks Paul. I do think the detail gougesare going to be nice, with this steel they might hold an good edge close to the 30 degree angle... I hope.

eliot, this is a hobby to make a high quality tool. It started with bowl gouges and now spindle and detail gouges. This next batch will sent to be heat treated in about ten days. I'm waiting for some 3/8 stock to be delivered.

Send a email if your interested,

Doug

Re: Gouge hardening question

#6

Re: Gouge hardening question

Fog Tanner

>In a hands-on with Stu Batty, the question of heating the tool when sharpening came up. In the course of the discussion, he mentioned that Sorby left the last 2" of the flute unharded. Supposedly some sort of safety measure to allow some amount of bend in the tool. I would assume all the tool makers in Sheffield follow the same basic practices.

Re: Gouge hardening question

#7

Re: Gouge hardening question

John Lucas

>I would think that would make a lot of sense since most of us don't use a gouge once it gets that short. The safety factor of having a tool bend instead of break would greatly appreciated.

Re: Gouge hardening question

#8

Re: Gouge hardening question

Mike Brazeau

>There was a good article in Woodturning a few months back on one of the Sheffield manufacturers and they showed them induction heat treating tools. I would assume they all do it and only the top four to five inches was heated. Time for a new one!

Mike

Re: Gouge hardening question

#9

Re: Gouge hardening question

john lucas

>Mike I was hoping that's what someone would say. I've been wanting the P@N spindle gouge. This will be a good excuse to get one. Not that need a good excuse. Any excuse at all.

Re: Gouge hardening question

#10

Re: Gouge hardening question *LINK*

MountainMan

>John

You should take a look at this URL:

http://raysknives.netfirms.com/aboutdamascus.htm

this guy makes supurb forged damascus knives... I took forging lessons from him early on... He know lots of stuf about hardening metals... I'm sure he will correspond...

Regards

The MountainMan


steel hardness info

Re: Gouge hardening question

#11

Re: Gouge hardening question

john lucas

>Mountain man. Those are nice knives. I have been doing a little blacksmithing myself. I passed up a damascus class this last summer and I see they are having another one. I may have to look at my dollars and see if I can make it work.

Re: Gouge hardening question

#12

Re: Gouge hardening question

Russ Fairfield

>John,

I don't know of a single M2 HSS tool that is harden over its entire length, and I don't know of a single M4 or higher alloy powdered metallurgy tool that isn't. Its the nature of the tools and how they are manufactured. If there are exceptions, I haven't found them yet.

This isn't saying that an M2 HSS tool couldn't be hardened over its entire length, its just that they aren't. My experience is that the Sorby tools have the longest length of unhardened flute on the market, and that you will start running out of tool when there is still between 1.5" and 2" of useful flute left. It is also my experience that the Henry Talor tools are hardened until the flute starts to disappear. Again, there may be exceptions, but I haven't found one of them yet.