Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Bad news, Good news

Posts

Bad news, Good news

#1

Bad news, Good news

Ed Moore

>A little over 4 years ago I bought a Stihl MS310 with a 20" bar. I have been harvesting some red oak that is about 3 1/2 feet in diameter. As I was finishing up a cutting session I couln't restart the saw, so the next day I took it to a Stihl dealer to be fixed. I got a call today and was told that the crankshaft was broken and that the cost to repair it would be almost the same as the replacement cost. Not good.

I went to the dealership and asked for a recommendation. I felt that it wouldn't hurt to have a little more power and came home with an MS361 with a 20" bar. It has more power and is actually slightly lighter. The 310 is a middle grade saw and the 361 is in the pro range. I like the upgrade. I came home and attacked the red oak again and was impressed. The only pain is in the wallet, since there is a $200 difference in price. The good news is that the chains I have will also fit the new saw.

The repairman said that he has never seen a broken crankshaft on a Stihl before. And a bearing was apparently slipping also. Anyone else have a similar problem?

Ed

Re: Bad news, Good news

#2

Re: Bad news, Good news

Russ Babbitt

>Did they take the saw apart to make their diagnosis?

Re: Bad news, Good news

#3

Re: Bad news, Good news

Ed Moore

>The saw came home as a cardboard box of parts. I was shown the crack in the crankshaft and was shown how the bearing was slipping.

Ed

Re: Bad news, Good news

#4

Re: Bad news, Good news

Cyril Griesbach

>Ed,

I've got to say, with hope for continued performance, that my two Stihl "Farm Boss" saws have gone on flawlessly for many years and tons of wood. I have not heard of others having the problem you describe. Did your dealer have any opinions on the cause of the trouble?

Cyril

Re: Bad news, Good news

#5

Re: Bad news, Good news

Ed Moore

>Cyril,

I was given good evidence of the problem, but the repair guy was stumped and said that he had never seen anything like it before. I have found this dealer to be honest and straightforward. One of the original owners is in our woodturning club.

I have been harvesting red oak and the 310 was doing fine. We were making simple crosscuts and rips, and I wasn't trying to see how fast I could get it done. I have used only Shell Premium gas and Stihl oil and things "looked good" as far as I could tell. But I was shown how the bearing was slipping and how something moved where it wasn't supposed to move. I plan to check things out more carefully this morning as I reorganize and clean up the chainsaw box and the box of parts which used to be my saw.

Ed

Re: Bad news, Good news

#6

Re: Bad news, Good news

TDRice

>I've been using Stihls for about 40 years. Except for mainanence and wear issues the only problem I ever had was when some complete idiot (don't ask me who) used straight gas instead of the gas/oil mix.

Re: Bad news, Good news

#7

Re: Bad news, Good news

Mike Nelson

>Ed, you might consider contacting Stihl and explaining your problem, also mention your discussion with other Stihl owners on this forum. I have had several things replaced or repaired at no charge by talking to the manufacturer. They may well be interested in what went wrong considering their reputation. Worth a try.

BTW, hows that learning curve going with your articulated hollower? Mine is much better but not mastered. I stripped out the tiny hex screw on the cutter, had to drill it out! I wonder if we can replace them with harder screws? Mike

Re: Bad news, Good news

#8

Good idea, Mike!

Ed Moore

>I was thinking about contacting Stihl, but inertia was winning. You have added to my incentive.

The learning curve is steep when you don't go to school. ;^D I have been focussing on other things and haven't spent enough time with the Munro to become confident or proficient.

A large poplar tree up the street fell over a while back, about 2 1/2 feet or more on the trunk. It's not in the way and the owner, in a wheelchair, insisted that he was going to cut it up when I offered to help. We attend the same church and I offered again after I saw little progress following a work day by him. He agreed that I should cut it up if I wanted to. I took the new saw and attacked it for a little over an hour. All but one cut was crosscut and the new 361 cut it like butter. And it didn't do badly when I split the crotch - which yielded the two pieces I took home. I left the main trunk untouched for another day. But I am pleased with the increased power of the 361. And somehow cutting poplar seems to go quicker than red oak. ;^D

Ed

Re: Bad news, Good news

#9

Re: Bad news, Good news

Bill Crommett

>I have been using my 031 for close to thirty years, and the only problem I have had is with the oil pump which was repaired under warranty.

Re: Bad news, Good news

#10

Re: Bad news, Good news

Greg Mitchell

>I don't know much about chainsaws. So when I bought my still 025 I went to a friend of mine. It came with a 16 inch bar, I wanted to put an 18 inch bar on my chain saw. Jim told me to stay with the 16 inch bar that the 18 inch bar would put to much strain on the motor if i wanted in 18 inch bar i need a bigger saw. I don't know if this had anything to do with your saw, just thought i would pass along the imfo. [ps, jim and his dad have sold hundreds of still saws over 40 years and jim will tell you the way he see it weather you like it or not].