Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Tool Rest Problem

Posts

Tool Rest Problem

#1

Tool Rest Problem

Jim

>I have a Powermatic 3520A. I've used the the stock tool rest and had great success with it. The only problem was that it nicked easily and I was always having to file/sand the edge. It's also too long for most bowl work. A few months ago, I switched to the round bar stock tool rests from Best Wood Tools - both straight and curved. I feel like a beginner again. I have more catches, more torn grain, more vibration and chatter and I'm sanding more. Is it me? What's the overall opinions out there on round tool rests? I'm frustrated after a bad catch today - the piece literally broke in half and barely missed my head. I could sure use some advice.

Re: Tool Rest Problem

#2

Re: Tool Rest Problem

John Lucas

>Jim I haven't had any problems with my powermatic tool rest getting nicked. i have 2 of them the short one and the standard one. I also own 2 bestwood tools tool rests. The 9" offset rest almost stays on the lathe it's my favorite. I don't notice anything that will cause more catches or vibration with that tool rest. The other one I have is the long adjustable curved rest. It will vibrate when you get out toward the end. However when I hang the tool over a straight rest when cutting the bottom of a bowl I probably get about the same vibration.

Oneway makes a really great curved tool rest that I think might work.

Re: Tool Rest Problem

#3

Re: Tool Rest Problem

georgetroy

>A round tool rest puts you farther from the edge of your work. You don't always know where you are. An experienced turner will make out ok with it. The Powermatic requires a long tool 1" post. Robust has a tool rest which will work, also the Oneway. You could go back to your old tool rest and just keep it filed and smooth. If you are using scrapers relieve the edges on the two bottom sides. WD 40 makes the cast iron rest slide easy, also John Jordan will use paraffin to help tools slide. GT

Re: Tool Rest Problem

#4

Tool Rest Problem

Jim

>Thank you very much guys!

Re: Tool Rest Problem

#5

Tool Rest Problem

Jim

>Thank you for the advice.

Re: Tool Rest Problem

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Tool Rest Problem

Keith Tompkins

>HI Jim, it's always a good idea to keep the tool rest filed, even polished...especially when you start using the skew chisel. Easing sharp edges on tool shanks helps as well. Duane Leach showed me how he polishes his tools...they glide extremely well, and worth the effort.

The new rest may be bringing to light some flaw in your technique that was not apparent previously, especially if you're hanging over the rest a bit more.

Re: Tool Rest Problem

#7

Re: Tool Rest Problem

Russ Babbitt

>Like Keith said. Filing of the tool rest is a common practice. I do mine almost daily. Just a light touch is needed. Some tool rests are softer than others. It keeps the tool rest clean and the tools sliding as they should.

Re: Tool Rest Problem

#8

Re: Tool Rest Problem

john lucas

>I second the Robust tool rest. I looked at them very closely and had planned to order one but forgot about it later. I think that it's an extremely well built rest. I would like to hear some first hand usage reports from someone who owns one.

Re: Tool Rest Problem

#10

Re: Jim... or everybody, even...

Allen Neighbors

>I took a piece of round steel and used NP7 (sort of like JB Weld) to attach it to my Old Griz toolrest, to make it stronger. It also didn't require resurfacing as much. I'm thinking about using a Screwdriver shaft or some 1/4" drill rod to add to the top of my other rests... that way they won't nick so easily. If it makes them too tall, the post can be ground off a little to make it the appropriate length again.

Just a thought.

Re: Tool Rest Problem

#11

Re: Tool Rest Problem

Phil Powell

>John, I have a Robust 25" and love it. I also have three Robust tool rests and I have to say

they are the most comfortable tool rests I have used. My hand fits the cuved area of the rest

and tools slide very easily accross the top. They seem to be made of mild steel and are easy to keep smooth and polished. They are a joy to use. By the way I rough several bowls most

every day so my rests get continual work outs.

Re: Tool Rest Problem

#12

Re: Tool Rest Problem

Cyril Griesbach

>Jim,

I have the Best Woods adjustable tool rest system that I use on my PM 3520B and I don't get any vibration from it. My only issue is that when I get to the bottom of a bowl I have a problem with the gouge coming against the system's mounting block. I guess I could re-adjust the rest but I don't like to interupt the cut at that point. Perhaps someone could offer a suggestion.

Cyril

Re: Tool Rest Problem

#13

Re: Tool Rest Problem

john lucas

>cyril I have the same problem with the block getting in the way. When I was at their booth at the AAW they had curved tool rests that were fixed with no block. I want one and will probably buy one before long.

Re: Tool Rest Problem

#14

Re: Tool Rest Problem

Rick Allen

>I have one of the Robust "comfort" tool rests. I got it at the KC symposium. The overhang, the distance the support edge is from the post, is less than I like as I can't get as close to a platter as I like using that tool rest. Other than the overhang the tool rest works fine, giving good support and great access for your hand on the tool. The ends of the tool rest are sharper than I like. There are enough sharp things in and around my lathe without adding another one.

After the first 6 months I find that I don't use the Robust tool rest much. When I bought the tool rest I intended to evaluate it for the purpose of adding additional "comfort" tool rests to my collection. I never bought a second tool rest from Brent. Not so much displeased with the tool rest just that I have little use for it.

I have two Oneway ductile iron tool rests, 6" and 14" which are used for 95% of my turning. The other 5% goes to the outside curved Oneway tool rest.

Funny how something as simple as a tool rest can evoke so much interest and concern.

Re: Tool Rest Problem

#15

Re: Jim... or everybody, even...

John Kyler

>I know some have done this. Cast iron has some give.

When you get the tool rest hardness towards the hardness of the tool then wont you be risking damage to the tool, where with cast you can just file the damage out of a rest?

And what does this do to the tool integrity?

Maybe nothing to worry about but just a thought.

John

Re: Tool Rest Problem

#16

Re: Tool damage? I don't think

Allen Neighbors

>you will ever get a catch hard enough to damage the tool, even if the rest is hardened steel. I think it would break the piece (wood) prior to breaking the surface of the steel. JMHO.

It's true that cast iron has more give to it, but I haven't seen any difference in my adding the rolled steel to the Old Griz toolrest. Except for the fact that I haven't broken anymore toolrests. :o)

Another plus is the fact that most of the time when you touch up your grind to make that final pass, that's usually the time you discover the ding in your toolrest. Right now, I'm trying to locate some 5/16 drill rod in this area, so I can fix my other toolrests. :o)