We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I just read a post below, about Terry's 200+ rough-turned bowls. Absolutely blew me away. Right now, I have 5 or 6 bowls in the soup... none on a drying rack.
I've tried 'twice-turning' only about 4 or 5 times. All turned to 10% dia. Wrapped in brown paper. Dried opening down. All have failed. Either ovalled to much to round, or split too bad to mess with, or tenon's failed due to concrete hardness. I'm leery about trying it again.
Three questions:
Approximately how many rough-turned bowls do you have in the drying process at this time?
What is your average failure rate?
What is your system for drying... i.e., turning, soaking, wrapping, drying, re-wrapping, etc.?
I've had really good luck with the alcohol method of drying and the plain old cover it in wax and let it sit for a year method. Right now, I am currently using the alcohol method pretty much exclusively. As a rough guess, I would say I have 25 or so bowls on the drying rack in the shop and 10-15 more that are drying but are also "use" bowls. That is, I'll rough it, alcohol soak it, let that dry and then use it to hold screws or bolts or something like that until the mood strikes me to finish turn it.
Along with those, I've got dried timber 12/4 stock, etc for bowl blanks that would probably yield another 50 bowls or so. I've also got probably 15 or so big chunks of logs that are still waiting to be processed into rough blanks.
So, long story short, I've got some from every stage in my shop, from green wood (got some fresh maple on Sunday that was cut down Friday!) to kiln dried to roughed, etc. It's always fun to go into the shop now knowing what you are going to work on that day! Maybe chainsaw a blank and rough a bowl, finish turn a roughed bowl or work with dry timber! It's all fun :)
>Roughouts are a dozen or so, but only because I just ran through a bunch of stuff. Normally, at least 2 dozen.
Failure rate ~1 per dozen.
Drying is in paper bags for stuff I don't care about losing, anchorseal if I feel like it, and alcohol soak if I absolutely want to guarantee results.
When I get into a "roughout mood", I might rough 6-10 bowls in a day. I would probably anchorseal them, but if I'm one off turning, I doubt I do it. If it's too big for my alcohol bucket, it would just get bagged...
>I have about 95 rough tuned bowls waiting for their final turn, thanks to a large Cherry Tree find last Christmas of 2005. Turned my first rough turn bowl last night that was first turned in April. Most of the bowls were turn in June - August as I waited all spring for my Oneway 1640 to arrive in May.
I have the bowls sitting on wire shelving stacked on top of each other. I used achorseal and all the bowls look great. I do have some White Oak and Sassafras twice turn bowls and they look good as well. Perhaps the Florida climate helps "Humid"!
>Allen, right now I have only 3 rough turned. One done today is drying. I rough turn and then wrap in newspaper and place in a plastic bag. I change the paper every day untill it no longer gets wet. I have had no cracks with this process and only lost one out of about 100 to excessive warping. The 10% rule I use as a guideline. Woods that I know are prone to warping badly I will leave a bit larger. And woods that are stable I may go a bit closer to final thickness. Keep after it, you'll figure out what works for you.
>I turn a lot in the winter, pretty rarely in the summer. Right now I have about 20 roughed pieces from last March, down from about 40 in October. As soon as the rough outs are gone, probably sometime in February, I'll start next years collection.
I rough the blanks to about 15% of diameter and then pack them in their shavings inside a paper bag or cardboard box for 6 months. I usually store the bags and boxes under the lathe, or tucked away on a shelf in the corner.
Part of my fall "get the shop ready" routine is to empty the bags and boxes and discard the shavings. I have only lost one blank this year, and that was a piece of white oak crotch that I suspected was not going to make it. My moisture meter tells me the wood is around 28-36% when it is put away. Most of the dried blanks are now 8-12% moisture content. I use anchorseal on my logs, and cut blanks. Never tried it on the rough outs.
>One. I am still trying to turn the dry wood I have before it gets warm in the spring. Of course it has not gotten cold here yet, to speak of. I will probably regret saying that!
>Hi Allen, At any time I usually have between 300 and 500 rough outs laying around,some have been here for 6 or 7 years and may never get returned.All depends on what I feel like turning.Have them in all different shapes and sizes to meet most any need.Usually kiln dry my blanks,takes about a month,real cheap to do and dont lose many this way.Maybe 2% loss if that.We are lucky up here,we have more wood than we can use.Put Marolyn in the truck and come on up.
>I rough turned about 800 bowls last year, bringing my "stock' of dried and drying bowls to a little over 3,000. This is getting a little much, even for me -- but the wood keeps rolling in. I have about two transport truck loads, mainly of Black Walnut and Cherry, that have to be turned before spring. Then I will shift over to roughing about 400 and finishing about 400 a year. (I am currently finish about 250 a year.) Most of the chunks of wood start out between 18 inches and 28 inches in diameter and I core at least two bowls from most of them. I boil all my rough bowls, Anchorseal them all over, and store it all round the house. The kids have left and their two bedrooms have been turned into drying rooms with library-style racks. There are also racks in the garage, the crawl space, and in a shed outside. Outside they dry slowly, and the quickest place for drying is in the two bedrooms where the electric heat allows me to keep the temperature cool during the winter months. Because of the boiling and waxing, the failure rate is about one half of one per cent. I tried alcohol drying and it works well on small bowls -- but not on anything over 14 inches. As a matter of fact, it was a disaster on the big bowls.
Right now I have about 50 air dried bowls awaiting a second spin on the lathe, about 30 box blanks, about 25 hollow ornament globes, and around 15 hollow forms roughed and air-dried. I'd much rather do rough turning than finish turning, so I often have well over 100 sitting around.
How I treat the wood depends on the species of wood and the time of year, since it can be very dry here in winter, and very humid in spring and summer. Some species like Apple and Black Cherry tend to check more, so I either wax them (paste wax) or bag them separately. I use Anchorseal only for high-value items (usually big or burl) or crack prone woods like Lilac or an Apple crotch.
When I rough turn bowls, I usually make them in batches, and toss them into a cardboard box, then close up & date the box and store it in a cool place. I'll often put 6 - 8 small bowls or 4 - 5 medium/lerge ones in a big box. I only add a few shavings (to raise and modulate the humidity) for really fragile woods, since I tend to get mold and spalting from adding wet shavings. I open the box and move things around when I stumble upon them, usually about once a month or so. I occasionally have to make a bowl a little shorter by trimming away cracks, but only if the rim is too close to the pith. I'd say the failure rate (HA -- from drying !) is ~2 - 3% for bowls and platters, but near zero for boxes and hollow forms.
I generally use alcohol only for items I need more quickly than the usual air dry cycle (4 - 6 months).
I have a lot of wood around (mostly free) so I've gotten more picky about what I turn and what I burn -- as I have gotten better at getting rid of (burning) questionable wood, that has lowered my failure rate some.
>Per the wife, I have to many, but when I see some of the responses of 200 - 500 roughed out bowls, she has nothing to complain about. I typically have about 30 roughed out bowls. Turn them to 10% rule for wall thickness. Anchorseal the end grain and throw them up on the shelf in the garage. I say loss rate is no more than 1%. I am very particular about having a uniform wall thickness all around to the bottom ( except where the tenon is for the chuck). In some cases the bottom can be a little thinner, but never thicker than the side walls. I will use a caliper to get this right. This helps ensure a more uniform drying rate and reduce the stress due non-uniform drying. Always make sure the pith is out of the bowl. Then seal the end grain ( inside and out). I usually wait a least 6 months before returning. I have never microwaved, boiled or soaked in alchol a bowl and probably never will.
>There are a dozen or so sitting around in grocery bags, some have been put in DNA and others boiled. I like the boiling for smaller pieces and find it completely reliable. The DNA process works like a charm but I tend to put pieces in the soak that are risky to start with, and miracles do not occur in the soak. I should be burning some of those before they are turned! OTOH, finials for ornaments can be dried in the microwave pretty quickly, just don't burn them by overheating. Phil
>I just finished turning the last bowl from my second batch of boil water treated rough outs. I used the alchol method 3x with no success. Boiling seems to work the best for me, so far no loses out of 18 rough outs. The one thing that I think helps in this case, more is better... boiling time that is. Water is already boiling so an extra 15 minutes won't hurt. Also I bring the rough outs inside my house in the paper bags. I don't leave them in my shop which is in my garage.
>1- A rough count would be around 100. Most are bowls but there are a few hollow forms.
2- I have almost a 0 failure rate (at least before I start re-turning :-)). I think that since I have been turning I may have had 5 rough turned pieces that I threw away because of severe distortion. I have had only three crack so they were unusable.
3- The bowls are rough turned to 10% rule. I Anchor Seal the end grain, put it into a paper bag where it will dry for about 1 year or more. My shop is not heated in the bowl drying area. When I start finish turning the rough bowl I will take a little off the outside and inside. If it begins to move I will let it sit around a little longer.
I have had good luck with the denatured alcohol drying of bowls, 3" solid stock for rolling pins, and the occasional hollow form. I use this method only when I am in a hurry or with holly.
Without going out and actually counting them I'll say around a hundred bowls, a couple dozen boxes a dozen platters and a dozen hollow forms.
I do not have severe distortion since I learned to judge the log and cut the blank in a way to minimize it and to stay away of the ones that I can read as trouble makers, that includes wood that is not sound, no matter how pretty. It is very humid here so when I rough green wood, I coat them with paste wax completely and spread them around so they can dry some before they mold, I did away with the paper bags and cardboard boxes because high incidence of mold, yes I get some cracks, but generally it only means a smaller bowl; boxes and hollow forms I never start with green wood, but I still rough and wax them and let them stabilize for at least a month before final turning.
I work on batches, if I am roughing boowls, I'll do at least a dozen that day, or 4 or 5 boxes, or a few platters; when finishing I tend to do the same, repeting the same action in a number of bowls.
I hate sanding, so I am more inclined to rough things than to finish them.
A long term goal of mine is to learn to leave a perfect finish with the tool and never sand...
I use DNA on all my bowls and have less than 2% failure. I stick them in a brown paper bag, roll it over the edge and dry on a wire rack. Roughing is much more fun than finishing. Besides I don't have much of a venue for sales of finished pieces. Maybe I should sell rough bowls.
>I tend to turn either dry wood or turn to completion so I never have very many roughed out pieces now. I would guess I have around a dozen bowls and few hollow pieces.
One problem I have is getting rid of the shavings. My garbage men won't pick them up if they know that's what it is so it's hard to sneak more than 2 or 3 rough outs past them. If I take it to the dump I have to pay for it. I can take it to the chip mill but it's only open when I'm working. I burn what I can but technically it's illegal to burn without a permit and it's almost impossible to get one. If they have a 1MPH wind they won't give you one. I thought about a mulch pile but there isn't really a good place to put something like that.
All of that and the huge mess it makes mean Idon't turn that much green. I plan to put up curtains around the lathe to control the chips and that should make it better.
>Hi Allen, I turn about 30% dry wood. With the wet wood, I have about 20 pieces in rotation. I use methele Hydrate (denatured alcohol in US)and lose maybe 1 in 40.
I have about 60 - 75 bowls in bags now. I put them in brown paper grocery bags stuffed with the shavings and leave for 6 months or until I get around to it. I have left some for 2 years. I then take them out of the bag and let them sit in the shop for about a week or so unless I want to do that one then. I probably lose about 1 - 2%. My shop is in the basement so I keep them there and turn them to about 10% thickness of the diameter of the bowl. I am careful to keep the thickness uniform.
>Allen, I have 1600-1700 roughed bowls ( walnut, birch, white birch, hard maple and soft, cherry, and black ash) and about 50 hollow forms roughed and dry. These were all turned to standard 10% rim thickness with a slightly thinner bottom, Anchorseal the inside and the outside. I loose about 2% of which I am sure a few are due to leaving undisclosed defects in the blank that later show themselves. I place them on the floor in a cool basement for initial slow drying stage. When the rate of weight loss slows the go into the attic of the pole building to further dry till they are needed. I have roughed bowls year around in all weather conditions, dry and wet (for my area). I roughed a lot of bowls in the beginning to practice tool use and form and save as much of the wood I had available as possible.
>1) 75-100 roughed bowls. I have a tree service buddy that calls me once in a while. Thus, my inventory goes up in 10-30 bowl waves. Took several months to establish a pipe line of bowl, but now that I have it, if I maintain it, I'll always have stock to play with.
2) 100% Anchorseal the bowls and loosely stack them on a shelf in the corner of my northern Michigan basement shop to dry. 6 months is a miniumum. 1 in 20 fail, but those all ready had tell-tale signs of a failure while roughing. A good grained rough out is pretty safe.
3) I cut roughly to the 10% thickness rule.
4) I'm at the edge of town, but still in a neighborhood. During the cold months when everybody's windows are closed, I'll dump a garbage can of noodles into my fire pit in the evening, along with a cup of used oil, light them off, and let them smolder thru the night. Gone by morning. During the warmer months, I don't do too much roughing, but when I do, I load up my flat bed trailer, then take the back roads at higher speeds to the next town (10 miles away) to get a soda with my wife. When I get back, they're all gone. The Solution to Pollution is Dilution. Not legal, but it works for me.
>John, I'm on lunch break from making tools. I'll answer the other posts sometime this evening, but I wanted to post this to you first.
I'm not sure where you live, but the High School FFA might be interested in taking your shavings... just keep the walnut out of it. They use it for bedding pigs, sheep, goats, calves, colts; I guess I should have just said animals, huh?
A local Aviary might want some... as might the "egg-woman"-it makes good nesting material. It's also good stall stuff if there's a riding club nearby.
Also, if you have a thing like "tradio" or some other free sales program/advertising on a local radio station, you might advertise free mulch. Some gardener may want it. I stack it pretty high around trees, shrubs, etc., but don't use it in flowerbeds next to the house.