Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Segmented Turning Question

Posts

Segmented Turning Question

#1

Segmented Turning Question

Steve in NC

>Happy New Year Everyone!

I have been off my feet for the past six weeks due to knee surgery. (Turned a few small items sitting at the mini but not much else.) To pass the time I have been reading up on segmeented turning which I hope to start on when I can once again stand in two weeks.

The books I have read so far show using a wide belt sander to flaten the rings after initial glue up. I do not have a wide belt sander nor do I plan on getting one (I am saving my $$ for a PM 3520).

Is it necessary to have a wide belt sander to flaten segmented rings or can it be accomplished with a belt sander. Or can one be very careful with the glue up and avoid sanding altogether.

Aslo, I plan to build the sled in Ron Hampton's book. Anyone have any experience with this setup?

Thanks in advance for your advice.

Steve

Re: Segmented Turning Question

#2

Re: Segmented Turning Question

Bill Stehman

>Steve,

Your rings will have to be flatten for good joints and construction although there are many ways to do this. Unless you are very good a narrow belt sander probably won't work. Jumbo jaws on your chuck works well if you have them or you could make a disc sander for your lathe. Either of these will for an occasional segmented bowl. There are plans on the net for home made drum sanders as well. I'm sure others will contribute in. Have fun and good luck on the recovery.

Bill

Re: Segmented Turning Question

#3

Re: Segmented Turning Question

eliot d

>I have done only about five or six segmented turnings, and they were all staved segmented turnings.There are times when sanding is very useful, but I just used coarse sandpaper contact-cemented to a heavy sheet of glass and did it by hand. It's used in staved work as one method to get the staves to close up to exactly a 360 degree circle. (What you do is plan for an even number of staves and glue the staves on half of them and then separately on the other half. Then sand each of the half glue-ups perfectly flat on the sandpaper before finally gluing the halves together.) For the kind of segmented work where there are numerous rings, I believe it's very advantageous to use a power disk sander before gluing nearly anything. You can make a perfectly useable one from a disk of MDF, properly trued up, with sandpaper attached, and use your lathe. In fact, if your lathe has variable speed, it's better than a fixed-speed disk sander.

Re: Segmented Turning Question

#4

Re: Segmented Turning Question

john lucas

>I've done at least 50 to 75 segmented pieces over the last 20 years and have never owned a belt sander. Would love to have one if I ever see one at a price I can afford.

I use 2 methods. One is to glue them up on a flat surface like a formica covered board. Hopefully this gets the rings pretty close to flat. Then I used a 2x4 that I jointed flat. I put 120 grit paper on this and flatten the ring. If I've wiped the excess glue off it doesn't take very long to do both sides. This is the only method I use for rings under 1/4" You need to check it frequenly with a straight edge to make sure you aren't taking too much off anywhere but it goes surprisingly fast.

For thicker rings I'll rig up a way to hold them on the lathe and true them up with a shear scraper. The Cole Jaws work great for many years I just had a flat piece of plywood with slots cut in it. I had small jaws made out of wood and cork that I adjusted to hold the rings while I flattened them.

for really accurate work I would flatten one side and then glue this ring to the existing rings already on the lathe. Then I would true this ring up while on the lathe.

Another method I used on occasion was to actually glue up the ring on top of the already partially assembled piece. I would put all the pieces on, put the hose clamp on to hold them together and then put the whole assembly on the lathe and clamp it with the tailstock and a scrap board. Then it was already there and ready to be trued up for the next ring. This is obviously much slower than stacking all the glued up and flattened rings but it's very accurate.

Last but not least is making a sanding drum to go on the lathe. You have to build a table to go under the drum that can be adjusted with a wedge or some other micro adjusting tool. I never tried that with the rings but did use this method to make thin veneers to go between the segments. It works but your fingers get tired of pushing all the pieces.

Re: Segmented Turning Question

#5

Re: Segmented Turning Question

bob davis

>i suggest you go to kevin neelley web site.he is amaster and shares his tools and techniques freely,,

Re: Segmented Turning Question

#6

Re: Segmented Turning Question

john lucas

>One more thing I've tried. It's a drill press cutter called the Safety Planer. It lookes like giant router bit with cutters that can be removed to sharpen them or replace them. It looks really dangerous but actually works pretty well and doesn't grab the work like you think it would. It flattens the rings well but leaves some fairly deep tool marks from the cutters. These have to be sanded out so it didn't save much time unless your rings are really untrue and need a lot of work.

It did save me a lot of time when I had my old bandsaw. You couldn't resaw thin pieces worth a darn on it. The thickness varied a lot from the blade wondering. I would use the safety planer to thickness them and then run them through my lathe mounted thickness sander.

Re: Segmented Turning Question

#7

Re: Segmented Turning Question *LINK*

Ron in Drums PA

>I've only done a few segmented pieces. All of the have been staves and are to thick for my proformex sander.

I work similar to the way John mentions, I rig a way to mount the turning on my lathe using cole jaws and longer screws. I flatten by shear scraping then take a long piece of 5/4 hardwood that is about 2" wide and longer then my turning. I wrap a sheet of sand paper around the stick and sand both side of the turning at the same time.

I think hardwood works better than plywood because plywood can bend slightly. Also, the hardwood has been planned flat and ture.


Wood Turning Exchange 2007

Re: Segmented Turning Question

#8

Re: Segmented Turning Question

Stuart Johnson

>I hold the ring with Cole jaws and flatten one side with a pass or two with a scraper and sand flush with a long board covered with a belt cut from what ever size belt I've purchased. I then glue that ring on and flatten the over side.

With that said I did get a Woodmaster 2675 drum sander for Christmas so I'm sure my process will change :)

Re: Segmented Turning Question

#9

Re: Segmented Turning Question

Malcolm Tibbetts

>Steve, there are almost as many ways to flatten a ring as there are segmenters.

The cheapest method (and it can be very accurate is to use your lathe. Mount a disc of MDF onto a faceplate, draw concentric circles as mounting guides, center your �to be flattened� ring, applying multiple dabs of hot melt glue around the circumference, turn with a bowl gouge followed by a little shear-scraping, check across the ring with a flashlight under a straight edge held across from side to side, and then use a sanding block with 80-grit to make the final perfect surface. Don�t over sand; the surface should be near perfect before sanding. You can remove the ring with a utility knife, glue it onto your turning, and then flatten the other side preparing it for the next layer. Another advantage of this method is you can also �round� your ring at the same time, and you can turn a rough profile on the outside of the ring, which will reduce the amount of surface area that requires flattening.

Any segmented turning can be constructed this way. Just don�t compromise; the surfaces have to be perfectly flat. Goof luck with your new interest.

Re: Segmented Turning Question

#10

Re: Segmented Turning Question

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL Back From Europe

>I have used just about every method imaginable.

When I first started, I used a method similar to what John Lucas described.

Then I made myself a set plywood Jumbo Jaws and flattened that way.

Then I used wooden disk on a faceplate with a sanding disk glued to it (10" first, and at one point 20").

At present, I have a 6"x48" belt sander with the belt portion set vertically, and I move the rings back and forth, rotating a 1/4 of a turn every few seconds. Right now I like that.

I recently bought a used 16-32 Performax, and I don't think I will used that for most flattening. First, you cannot flatten a ring smaller than about 4" in diameter. Second, it takes to long. On my 6x48, I can flatten a ring in 30-40 seconds. You have to take such shallow passes with the Performax, that it takes just too long.

You have lots of options. Find one that works for you.

Mark

Re: Segmented Turning Question

#11

Re: Thanks Everyone

Steve in NC

>Thanks everyone for the suggestions. There are lots of good ideas to try. Hopefully I will post a successful item in the near future.

Steve

Re: Segmented Turning Question

#12

Re: Segmented Turning Question

David Walser

>Mark,

Re: your 16-32 Performex, couldn't you attach your smaller rings to a flat board to run them through the sander? While you seem to be getting good results with your belt sander, wouldn't the drum sander be more accurate (at least less susceptible to human error)?

I'm asking because I was thinking of adding a drum sander to my list of gotta haves.

Re: Segmented Turning Question

#13

Re: Segmented Turning Question

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL Back From Europe

>There seem to be a couple of issues (for me) are 1) by being able to to move the rings back and forth quickly on the belt, I can cut way back on the heat build-up to the wood, and having wood resin build up on the belts, and 2) Time involved - to accomplish #1 with the 16-32, you have to run it at a rapid belt speed, and you cannot take off much wood at rapid speed.

True, you can eliminate the human error, but after doing it for years, I can do it pretty well, and I always check it with the ring I am gluing it to before make sure it is a good flat/tight fit. And, you are right about doing small rings by attaching them to a transport board. But in the time it would take to attach one ring to a board, I can be finished with several rings.

However, please do not let this eliminate the drum/belt sander from you list of wants (I didn't). If you ever want to do rings that are tapered the drum sander with a perfect way to do it. Also, if you want to do veneers from exotics, it is the way to go.

Mark