Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Coring tools...a good investment?

Posts

Coring tools...a good investment?

#1

Coring tools...a good investment?

Joe Pack

>I watched Bill Grumbine's newest video a while back and was again impressed witb the coring set he used. It seems a shame to turn good wood into shavings when a second, or third, blank can be taken from the same chunk of wood, particularly when wood is sometimes hard to come by. I am considering a McNaughton coring system and wondered what folks here thought about them.

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#2

Steven Antonucci

Easy economics

Steve Antonucci

>If you look at the cost of wood (mine is free), the extra "blanks" a coring tool provides often pay for the tool in a very short time. In addition, once you know how to use a coring system, I believe that they are faster an produce far less waste (=less clean up).

If you make a lot of bowl, it's a good investment. I've cored without a system to preserve special pieces of wood, and it's no fun. I'm probably going to pick one up on my next trip to Woodcraft.

P.S. I'd bet that you could pay for it with one nested set of bowls.

Steve

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#3

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

Russ Fairfield

>Which coring system you buy depends on how long you want to spend learning to use it, and what you want to do with it.

It takes awhile to learn to use the McNaughton. Most folks can core a bowl straight out of the box with the Oneway, but pay a lot of money for being able top do that. The WoodCut is the easiest to set up and use, but is the most limited in what it can do.

And, it does make a difference in what you shapes and sizes you are going to core. If you are only coring bowls, there is little difference between the tools, and you could include the WoodCut in the comparison if you are only coring small bowls. If you are going to core tall vases and odd shapes, the McNaughton is more versatile because it doesn't pivot about a fixed center.

The McNaughton is the only one that can use a straight tool.

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#4

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

Cyril Griesbach

>Joe, I've got a Oneway system with the #1 and #2 knives and it works well. That said, I've also watched Bill Grumbine core with the McNaughton and he sure did make it look easy and a number of folks at his demo tried it as well and had no problems. I wish I'd taken the offer to give it a try at that time.

The Oneway has removable cutters that can be sharpened and replaced at about $30 so you may wish to examine the sharpeming process with other tools.

Still, Russ has given as good an answer to your question as there is.

Cyril

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#5

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

Ron in Drums PA

>I own a McNaughton and love it.

Some find it has a big learning curve. Others do not. I was one of the lucky ones.

IMO, well worth the bucks.

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#6

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

joaz

>If you core green wood either the McNaughton or the Oneway works great. I have had both. However, if you want to core dry wood you are in for a lot of work and a lot of wear on your lathe bearings and your body. I had to sharpen every 4 or 5 inches and even then it was hard going. Spraying water on the kerf helps some but you can imagine the mess!

Also, with dry wood a lot of heat in generated and can cause the wood to crack.

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#7

George Balock

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

George Balock

>Joe,

I've used my Oneway system to core smaller bowls from large blanks or to core out an especially nice piece of wood (burl or figured). I had a piece of bigleaf maple with a lot of figure. I sold the cored piece, which paid for the wood. Once the larger piece sells it will all be profit!

I like my coring system also because it cuts down on the amount of shavings I have to haul out of my shop. It�s quicker to core out a bowl than to turn out the interior.

George

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#8

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

Ed Moore

>I find that there is a demand for natural-edged red oak bowls with spalted sapwood. I also found that there was a 3 1/2 foot log at the end of my street which was mine for the taking. With my new Robust lathe I was set to use the McNaughton system to core some of the bowls.

I have learned two things:

1. There is a learning curve.

2. A slower speed just may be what it takes for a successful coring. DAMHIKT

Ed

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#9

Ask Why

Reality Check

>First you need to ask yourself WHY you want a coring system. If you are like most turners, the reasons are the same; � to save wood, shavings & money, which really adds up overall �to save time�, not just the time to core; which can also be faster than gouging out the interior of a bowl, but also think of the time of hauling and prepping logs to turn one bowl or the time at your job to buy your blanks, and all those shavings to discard. Yes, a coring tool is a GREAT investment! That being said, for the reason you are buying a coring set in the first place, the Oneway Easycore is truly the best system out there,. Why you ask? It is truly the easiest & fastest core system with virtually no learning curve. Although like any tool, the Mac can be mastered, but usually after many ruined blanks & usually and in many cases, at least one ruined bent blade in the learning process (out of eight turners I know that bought Macs, 4 have bent Mac blades, & three of those ended up unusable. I know one of those turners who sold their Mac, because they were afraid to use it after bending a knife in a big blank. Remember woodturning as a hobby is supposed to be fun!!

I take bit of exception of those that state the Mac is more �versatile�. Although on the surface that statement is true; but why would anyone think that the versatility to core out a vase is all that practical? Bowl blanks are where coring systems are practical and really shine. Some will argue that you can core smaller blanks with the Mac (mini), again true,

however I can core a blank as small as 5 inches with a Oneway, to me that�s a small blank as it is; however, if I do want to turn a cutesy small bowl, I don�t mind wasting a couple of inches of wood-really what�s the point, unless your turning Pink Ivory bowls!? Lastly I take exception to those who argue that because the Oneway pivots on a fixed point, you can only get the same core size & shape , I say hogwash; when you start using the tool, you will be surprised how much control you have over the types of blanks by adjusting the base unit and angle of approach of the knives. Not as versatile as the Mac but unless you�re trying to save every shaving of wood possible; what�s the difference??

Yes the cost is a bit more for the Oneway system, but you get what you pay for, you don�t have to buy all the blades upfront, and the tool going to last you until the estate sale. Don�t forget the cutters are replaceable on the Oneway, you have to replace the whole blade on the Mac when it wears down. Remember, whatever the reason you may want a core system, the real reason boils down to time, and:

I bet I made a knee high pile of bowl blanks comfortably using the Oneway right out of the box, while most others were still trying to �master� their Mac. Watch me smile as I marvel coring out a 16 inch bowl blank with one hand (I�m still amazed of the ease of this system), then watch the uncertainty on the faces of even experienced users, coring out big blanks with a Mac.

Reality Check

PS, watch the free videos using the Easycore system on the Oneway site, If you do decide on the Mac, I suggest buying the Mahoney video, and add it to the cost of the system. Good Luck Joe

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#10

Re: Ask Why

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>I think it all boils down to personal preference. Each tool mentioned will core bowls, and it all depends on the skill of the user how well they work. People who denigrate the McNaughton don't know how to use it properly. I have gotten grandmothers coring bowls with this tool with no problems on the first try.

I core a lot of vases and I core a lot of burls. My wood is free most of the time too, but even so, waste not want not, especially burls. Examples below:


vase


vase core

I have done many of these over the years, and this one core above would pay for most of a McNaughton system. If I added them all up, I would have been able to buy lots of turning tools and other stuff (and I did!). But one core can be worth a lot when it is the right kind of wood.

Bill

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#11

Thank to all. I appreciate the advice.

Joe Pack

>

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#12

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

Allen Neighbors

>Russ, I have a Standard McNaughton system, and you're right about it. Without watching anyone else use it, and trying to just use their written directions, it has a certain learning curve.

But I'm curious about the straight tool. I haven't used it yet. And I don't have the slightest idea what it would be used for.

Help me out?

Thanks,

Allen

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#13

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

Russ Fairfield

>I use the straight tool a lot and for two specific things. It is good for making the outside of scaley pieces of wood into something that is round. Making a plunge cut into solid wood is faster and a lot more friendly to the body than trying to do this with a bowl gouge and making intermittent cuts.

Same thing for the inside. The straight tool is good for removing bad wood, large hardened resin pockets, limb inclusions, and wood with rocks and dirt from the inside of anything quickly. This is wood that I wouldn't save.

It is also a good way to remove a lot of wood from the inside of a tall vase form, and I make a lot of those. It is faster than drilling and using a boring bar setup with a scraping tool; and sometimes that heartwood core is worth keeping because it can be the most highly figured, and that makes nice pens.

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#14

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>The straight tool is my most used one. I make platters with it.

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#15

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

Greg Jensen

>Very easy to control parting tool.

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#16

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

Allen Neighbors

>Russ, thanks for the reply. But that brings to mind one more question. When you are coring out a vase... say one where you're going to save the core for making pens or a smaller vase, how do you part it from the outside piece? Am I missing something... or do you core it into a cone shape, to a small enough diameter that you can break it off the same as a bowl core?

I think I may have answered my own question. :o)

Thanks for posting.

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#17

Re: Okay, Gary... time to explain that to

Allen Neighbors

>a dense person. Do you mean that you use the straight tool to cut several platters off a single chunk of wood... as in parting tool?

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#18

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

Allen Neighbors

>Greg, do you use your normal toolrest when you use the straight tool for parting? Or do you use the McNaughton rest?

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#19

Re: Okay, Gary... time to explain that to

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>Allen,

Yes, I cut several platters from a single log. I put and a 75 to 100 pound hunk and round it. If I made a bowl from it, the bowl would be 12 or 14 inches deep. I just part off 2 to 4 platters at a slight angle then make a bowl with the remainder. It's just like a parting tool I've done it with the tool rest, but don't recomend it. If the turning is large the forces can be high.

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#20

Re: Okay, Gary... time to explain that to

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>Here a shot of the last 18 inch platter form this hunk of cherry. I had already taken of 1 or 2 before this one. The rest will make a bowl.


img

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#21

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

Greg Jensen

>I always use the McNaughton tool post. It keeps the blade from twisting. When using the strait blade for parting and cutting platter blanks you can control the tool with one hand then use the free hand to hit the stop switch. Try that with a standard parting tool. I quite often want to part off a section of a round blank that might be 8" or biger. The starit blade make short work of this. I use a motor shaft collar on the toolpost column to set the hieght. Then a just drop the toolpost in the banjo and I am at center hieght.

You can also use the stait blade to part off a picture frame from the bottom of a bowl blank.

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

#22

Re: Coring tools...a good investment?

Jorge Castaneda

>Allen,

You just answered yourself, it is the same with bowl blanks.