Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Need Critique For New Turner

Posts

Need Critique For New Turner

#1

Need Critique For New Turner

Allen Neighbors

>I have a friend named Harold, that has been coming over to my shop and is learning to turn, using Old Griz. I don't think I'm a very good teacher, since I still need to be taught too, but he will be purchasing his first lathe in another month or two. (He's hooked. :o) It makes two of us in about a 120 mile area.)

He's been reading this forum for about a month.

This bowl is the sixth piece that he has turned. He asked me to take a quick pic of it and put it on Wood Central for critiques.

It is from Spalted Magnolia. About 8" diameter X 6" tall.

Finish is Danish Oil. It's not cured yet, so it's not been buffed.

Please give him some constructive criticism, so he can continue to learn. Thanks. :o)


img

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

#2

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

Jim Swank

>Over all, it appears nicely done. It does seem to flare out a little to the rim. To me, that flare looks almost accidental. I'd like to see it either better defined and more definite, or gone entirely.

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

#3

Re:Looks very nicely done for ....

Jamie Donaldson

>...just a 6th bowl. With practice and experience the walls will be thinner and the shapes will have more flowing lines. Don't think every one needs to be a keeper- waste some firewood to practice, practice, practice!

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

#4

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>For the 6th bowl it is very good. I agree about the flair but the main reason I am posting is to mention that the shape it a difficult one (at least for me). If you could get a piece of wood that would allow a more gentle slope to the sides it would be much easier to turn.

I am presently teaching my first adult. She is a friend of the family so I couldn't say no or direct her to teachers much better than I. Fortunately she is a very quick intelligent student. Teaching is not easy is it?

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

#5

George Balock

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

George Balock

>Allen,

I agree, for just his sixth bowl, he�s doing well. Along with the other comments, I would add that one way to achieve a more flowing shape on a bowl is to start with a shallower bowl, especially for new turners. I know that we believe that wood is precious and that NONE should be wasted, some times it�s better to sacrifice some wood to get a better form.

George

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

#6

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

tm

>Al,

I know you and, having learned quite a lot from you myself I know you are excellent at sharing information.

I think Harold is very lucky to have you as a mentor.

Last week I taught my brother the basics by letting him turn a heavy goblet or chalice form out of an endgrain branch of sycamore. It came out okay, perhaps a bit chunky.

Chunky being thick bottomed and not elegant.

( just like my wife )

I learned that teaching is challenge and its the wise man that admits there is always more to learn.

Tool control and safety make up an important part of what the beginner

learns first.

I think mastering form is far more difficult. At 2 1/2 to 3 years of experience I still have to ask myself " Is this enough or does this shape need more refining?"

And of course there are those times when I refine a little too much

By submitting photos to peers and sharing with fellow turners here or elsewhere we gain insights as to what pleases the eye.

The Wood Turners Workbook written by Ray Keys has some good discussions of various forms and why some are more elegant than others.

Turning videos and books are expensive but they pay for themselves

eventually. Books on pottery and ceramics are another good source

for seekers of form.

I found some turning books and videos at my public library.

Welcome to one of the best turning websites on the planet Harold.

tm

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

#7

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks for the critique. Harold said he wanted just a subtle flair to the rim. That's the way he planned it. :o)

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

#8

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

Bill Crommett

>Don't spend too much time or effort on TM, because he won't be around much longer if he keeps talking about his wife that way.

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

#9

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

Allen Neighbors

>Barbara, thanks for posting. He did want just a subtle flair at the rim.

When he told me he'd like to turn something, I couldn't recommend anyone else from this area to teach him... there isn't any. I just told him I'd teach him all I knew about it... that took all of 10 minutes :o)... You're right... teaching a beginning woodturner is hard to do... especially when you're a beginner yourself, as I am. I'm constantly having to go back and explain something I'd said earlier, thinking that I didn't explain it well enough the first time.

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

#10

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

Allen Neighbors

>TM, you're a kind man. Thanks for the kind words.

I haven't talked too much about safety.. as a subject.. but I think when I explain something, I mention some hazard that is involved. Staying out of the line of fire is the first think I told him, though.

Trying to teach 'a fair curve', and the 'rule of thirds', is difficult to get across.

Thanks for the idea of the local library... I'll check it out.

Blessings to you, TM. Sure hope you can make the gathering in Pensacola in Feb.. :o)

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

#11

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks, George, I'll point that out about sacrificing wood to get better form.

Re: Need Critique For New Turner

#12

Re: ROFL... you're a nut, Bill.

Allen Neighbors

>