Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Soup bowl finish

Posts

Soup bowl finish

#1

Soup bowl finish

Sam Dean

>Hi Everyone!

I have a question about wood finish:

I've been asked to participate in a local charity event, called the "Soup Bowl". Traditionally, area restuarants donate soups and bread to eat, and ceramic artists make bowls to serve them in. Guests pay to eat, keep the bowls as a gift, and the money goes to a local food bank. They thought it would be a fun twist to throw a woodturner into the group, so finally for the question:

What finish would be best for a bowl used to eat (hot!) soup from?

I was thinking that (well cured) watco danish oil might be an option - or maybe shelac would be a better option. What do you think?

Thanks,

Sam

Re: Soup bowl finish

#2

Re: Soup bowl finish *LINK*

joaz

>Shellac is no good. Moisture and heat from soup would strip the finish from the wood. Athough you could use it as sanding sealer or undercoat.

I have used spar varnish on goblets successfully, only for beer and wine. No hot stuff.

I also use urethane oil for salad bowls. Again, no heat involved.

Perhaps other's will weigh in on other finish possiblities.

Good luck!


http://www.maine-web.com/woodturning

Re: Soup bowl finish

#3

Re: Soup bowl finish

georgetroy

>For a food safe finish I recommend Preserve for this type of finish. From Klingspor's Item #PF10000 $8.95 www.woodworkingshop.com

This information from the web site:

Blended from the meats of exotic nuts, this rare oil is the perfect match for woodenware such as bowls, knife handles, eating utensils and butcher blocks. PRESERVE is non-toxic and perfectly safe immediately upon application. The golden tone of PRESERVE brings out the wood grain and beauty of the wood while also protecting the surface. The deep penetrating qualities of this finish prevent food juices and odors from penetrating woodware. A great one-step finish for all kitchen items.

The directions on my container reads as follows:

Apply generously with hand or paper towel to clean dry surface. Allow Preserve to penetrate wood grain for 15 minutes. Reapply until wood is saturated and wipe off excess. Wooden ware may be use immediately upon application. This product is made by Masters Blend

PO Box 363 Manlius NY 13104-0363..I suppose you could do a search for a web site and/or a phone number to make sure about the heat. GT

Re: Soup bowl finish

#4

Re: Soup bowl finish-No Watco

georgetroy

>I forgot. Several years ago I was making Goblets for the Renaissance Restivals. I made some finishing with Watco. Talk about a bitter taste it was awful. I could only hope in due time that it passed. Never again will I use that finish to drink from. GT

Re: Soup bowl finish

#5

Nada!

Jorge Castaneda

>Sam

I've tried several oils and varnishes and in my humble opinion, no finish is your best bet for hot soup, my wife also likes no finish best for salad bowls.

$0.02

Jorge

Re: Soup bowl finish

#6

Re: Soup bowl finish- I wouldn't

Stuart Johnson

>I would try to find a very simple glass or clear plastic bowl that will fit inside the turned bowl to hold the soup. The buyer then gets a pretty bowl that isn't ruined with a thick epoxy or plastic like finish.

Re: Soup bowl finish

#7

Re: Soup bowl finish *LINK*

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hi Sam,

Your bowls are going to a great cause. It sounds just like a fundraiser that takes place all over the country that goes by the name "Empty Bowls". If so, what happens is that the bowls are not actually used to eat the soup out of. Each attendee donates a pre-determined amount of $$, usually around $15.00, and that entitles them to a handmade bowl and all the soup they can eat. The soup is served in disposable bowls. Find out if this is the case, as it will save a lot of headaches in trying to figure out a finish.

Hope this helps?

Jennifer


Click Here for EMPTY BOWLS Info!

Re: Soup bowl finish

#8

Re: Soup bowl finish

Sam Dean

>Thanks joaz; I've used shellac on other stuff, and I know they coat candy with it, but I didn't know about heat.

Sam

Re: Soup bowl finish

#9

Re: Soup bowl finish-No Watco

Sam Dean

>Thanks for the info GT - I'll order a can of preserve and give it a try. Definately good to know about watco - that's generally my favorite finish.

Thanks,

Sam

Re: Soup bowl finish

#10

Re: Nada!

Sam Dean

>I thought about the no finish option, but I would only use hard maple if I went this route. I'm worried that the bowl would stain excessively the first time in use, and wouldn't be as appealing as the ceramic bowls. If it was a bowl for my own use, I would go bare wood, but then again I know what to expect.

Thanks,

Sam

Re: Soup bowl finish

#11

Re: Soup bowl finish- I wouldn't

Sam Dean

>That's a good idea - I'll have to look into it. Maybe some colaboration with a ceramic artist may be in order to make the "inside"....

Thanks,

Sam

Re: Soup bowl finish

#12

Re: Soup bowl finish

Sam Dean

>Hi Jennifer,

It is just like the "Empty Bowls" fundraiser, except these bowls are actually used. A big part of the event is a "bowl washing" party the day before where all of the artists and other people involved get together. Maybe I should just saturate the bare bowls in pure bees wax and call it good. I think some experiments are in order this weekend.

Thanks,

Sam

Re: Soup bowl finish

#13

Re: Soup bowl finish

Barry Irby

>There is a turner in our club that makes treen and she buys CA by the gallon for the purpose of finishing it. Makes cupa and goblets and uses thee or coffee and wine and washes them in the dishwasher. We also have a pen turner in the club that finishes his pens with CA. Rubs it on while the pieces are turning on the lathe and sands with about 600 between coats. Polishes up nicely.

Re: Soup bowl finish

#14

Re: Soup bowl finish

Rick Allen

>Folks ate out of wooden bowls for many many hundreds of years with no finish at all. You should select a wood which won't taint the soup, such as maple.

If you want a protective inert finish the epoxy is the finish. The epoxy needs to soak in for the first coat. The second coat forms the barrier. Epoxy is used in many food process environments. Milking equipment is often lined with epoxy as are canned foods.

You also need to protect the epoxy. So a finish such as water based varnish should be used over the epoxy.

Please note that the same finishing procedure should be used both inside and out or the differential moisture absorption will likely damage the bowl over time.

Bare wood would be my choice for such an event. ANd the wood would be either maple or poplar.

Re: Soup bowl finish

#15

Go to Russ's corner here on WC.

Don Henthorn

>I'd prefer his reply to any.

Re: Soup bowl finish

#16

I Agree

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I would use a very hard wood such as hard maple from the Northern cold part of the US and no finish.