Ditto on pure form!!
Molly Winton
>
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Ditto on pure form!!
Molly Winton
>
Took the words right out of my mouth...
dwr
>... Jim,
I liked the idea of a collaboration as well, even if it was just turning. Other emphasis is a good idea as well. Rules and themes are easily outlined. How would you see people paring up? We could encourage people connecting that don't necessarily know each other or do like the Exchange and draw names...
I vote collaboration, that way Platters, Miniatures, Candle Sticks... etc. can all be open for work, more people get to do their favorite and people get to know others they might not already know...
DW
A single arena will limit people...
dwr
>... since some do not do miniatures, others do not have a lathe with enough swing to do a real platter, etc. I see these contests as doing something you are adept at rather than a time to try something you have never done.
With Jim's idea of a collaboration, two or MORE people can combine their specialties from Platter work to Miniatures and everything in between. Pure form in each component can be a judging criterion. The field will be wide open for some very special creative minds to collectively stretch their imaginations while still doing the type of work they see best fits their skill and talents.
Along the way some new friendships can develop, expand the sense of community and I believe more people will participate because more options are available to them.
Just some thoughts...
DW
Theme with an 'Open' category
Barb Siddiqui
>so that anyone can enter, professionals or amateurs.
Me too... Pure form
Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!
>
rather than one type of vessel
Tom Sontag - St. Louis
>Would it make any sense to open it up a little? For example, instead of platters or bowls, how about "dinnerware" or "something functional for the table"?
Galleries organize exhibits all the time on themes allowing some interpretation (like the 2 bf idea); I think this encourages more creativity.
Re: Need suggestions
Jim Rutten
>Ellis,
If you had a contest for ugliest turnings I would be sure to win that so that wouldn't be fair. I vote for boxes, too.
Best Suggestion Contest......
Barry Irby
>This is the longest thread I've seen here in a while. Obviously lots of interest. I think you should give a prize for the Best Suggestion and skip the contest altogether. Think of it, no one knew they were bing judged, no one is limited by their equipment, no finanacial limits, no shipping costs, they put their best suggestion forward. You be the judge. Be sure to set up fair and even handed guide lines.
Re: Need suggestions
Lan Brady
>Ellis,
Being very much an amateur, I hve not entered any competions. All the suggestions so far, are good ones. As a follow up to Russ's comments. How about seprating the contest into 2 categories. Professsional and non- professional. I like to study the creativity of both groups. THe professions must think of making a profit while the amateur will work for 10 hours on a 50 dollar piece.
Just a thought, Lan
Ellis,
Being very much an amateur, I have not entered any completions. All the suggestions so far, are good ones. As a follow up to Russ's comments. How about separating the contest into 2 categories. Professional and non- professional. I like to study the creativity of both groups. The professions must think of making a profit while the amateur will work for 10 hours on a 50-dollar piece.
Ellis,
Being very much an amateur, I have not entered any competitions. All the suggestions,so far, are good ones. As a follow up to Russ's comments. How about separating the contest into 2 categories. Professional and non-professional. I like to study the creativity of both groups. The professions must think of making a profit while the amateur will work for 10 hours on a 25-dollar piece.
Just a thought, Lan
Re: Need suggestions
Lan Brady
>Wow,
I wish I knew how I did that!
Amateur all the way! lol, Lan
Re: Need suggestions
eliot d
>Instead of a category of turning, like Platters, Boxes, etc, why not something more general that probably would bring in more players: Something like , Turnings that Emphasize Color, or Pyrography, or Texturning.
I'll go for that one, Barb.
Don Henthorn
>I say have some of the contests open to the pros. They have the skills but that doesn't mean they always have the best ideas. Let everyone compete against each other at least part of the time. That is the spirit which made us great.
Re: Need suggestions
Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho
>Why not dispense with these lesser forms of turning, and move directly to something challenging - like pens?
;-)
Scott.
Re: Need suggestions
Russ Fairfield
>I am wondering why so many have so much to say about the theme of thwe contest, while so few will enter the contest
Your point is well made
dwr
>That is why I agree with the "open category" and a collaboration between two or more people. I don't burn, color or texture, so if that were the criteria I would not enter. HF turning is not on my radar yet, and my hands do not afford me the luxury of miniatures. My lathe will not do a platter justice, unless you call an 8-10" "Plate" a platter. However, I can contribute a lot in the spindle, bowl, 10" flat, box, finial, lidded, etc.
So, the more specific you make a contest, the fewer participants you will get by its very nature. If Ellis is wanting increased participation, then the contest needs to be more general/inclusive in scope, otherwise you get the same result; low participation.
A collaboration can include EVERY option that has been presented, including Pure Form, which would be a subjective judging criterion. Why can't several people collaborate and include everything from HF, Lidded, Textured, Stemmed, Colored, Burned, Segmented... and so on?
All you need is a list of participants that includes the area(s) of interest they would want to contribute to the collaboration. If pairing up is an issue, we could do a random selection like the Turning Exchange. Then each group can discuss what they think about the design, exchange ideas, etc. and assign tasks, forward pieces to other team members that need the piece(s) for their task and ultimately the final piece is completed. (Besides, if the truth were known, a lot of turners have thought or dreamed about teaming up with the "Pro's" on a piece but would never approach them...;).. so this could be an Ice Breaker of sorts!
In the end, WC can have an auction of the collaborations and use the funds for WC support or whatever.
DW
Re: Need suggestions
Winnemucca Lynn
>Something that would fit into a doll huse - size, form and use.
Re: I've worked 10 hours on a
Allen Neighbors
>two dollar piece. LOL.
I like all these suggestions.
Platters Do Not Have To Be Large.
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>A lathe with a 12" swing can make a platter. In fact you can turn a miniature platter and unless there is something by which to gage the size a picture would not reveal the size.
I Like All The Ideas But...
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>I agree about the spindle aspect. Our spindle turners are often overlooked.
Re: I Like All The Ideas But...
Russ Fairfield
>That's why I suggested goblets. And, I further suggest that they be grouped into two (2) skill categories.
My opinion is that, a nice looking well proportioned goblet with a thin wall is one of the most difficult, and the most impressive of woodturning forms. The goblet represents the best of both the spindle and the bowl, and maybe even something of a hollow form.
Time is not an excuse for not making a goblet because they are a relatively quick project. Neither is not having a large lathe an excuse for anything.
All of the same can be said for the platter. The only difference between the 6" saucer, the 12" plate, and the huge 20" platter is the diameter. It is difficult to tell one from the other when looking at a photo, unless someone has included a size reference. If they are well executed, they all require similar skills and techniques, and the smaller often requires the greater skill.
I like the lidded vessel idea...
Ellis Walentine
>... but it wouldn't be possible to judge the fit of the lid from photos and descriptions. I'd have to consult with the judges to see how they would propose handling that detail.
Thanks for the suggestion.
Ellis
Re: Me too... Pure form
Brad Vietje
>Me too, but we could even separate this into categories such as bowls, spindles, hollow forms (they could even be solids for the outer profile), plates &/or platters, boxes, natural-edge work, goblets, vases,...
BV in VT