Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Advice needed...

Posts

Advice needed...

#1

Advice needed...

Neal_Addy

>I'm a total noob at air-powered tools and in need of advice on a decent compressor to drive a Powercrafter or similar carving tool. I'm looking for something quiet, small, and affordable (<$200?). I can't see ever needing to use it for other tools (nail guns, etc) so something adequate for this particular task is enough. Should I be looking at oil or oil-less, pancake or hot dog, dumb or dumber... my head is spinning!

What should I be looking for? Suggestions on specific units might help me get started comparing specs. Like anything new, it's just confusing at this point.

Re: Advice needed...

#2

Re: Advice needed...

Bill Howatt

>Some general comments:

Hot-dog, pancake, etc are just the tank layouts although they do tend to limit the tank size in a particular configuration.

Unless you are looking at real industrial quality compressors the HP ratings are very inflated! There is no way you can run a real, continuous, 5HP motor from a 120V, 15A circuit.

You want to check to air consumption of the biggest tool you wish to run. It will be listed like X Cubic Feet/Minute (CFM) at Y PSI. A compressor will be able to deliver a certain volume of air (CFM) at a low pressure say 40PSI but not at a high pressure like 90PSI so you have to have both numbers correct.

A big tank does not compensate for an inadequate compressor. It will keep the compressor from starting right away but if the tool uses more air than the compressor can produce it will never catch up. A big tank will reduce the number of start/stop cycles when using properly sized tools.

Generally an oiless compressor is noisier than a cast-iron oil compressor with the latter being generally considered the best by most people. The oiless has an advantage that it does not put oil into the outlet airstream. For oil compressors, oil separator/filters are used if the air is going to be used in critical applications like spraying.

Even though you think you only want to use it with this one tool, give some thought about things you might do with it so you don't go too small. You really don't want to go too big either since they are noisy beasts regardless of the type.

For a brad nailer only you can get away with a small unit. For portable use of my nailer I have a 10gal tank with regulator. I fill it to max pressure and can pretty well use it all day.

Re: Advice needed...

#3

Re: Advice needed...

John in Kerrville

>I can only 2nd what Bill has already said. I am not sure you can do this for under $200.00. My air tool repair guy generally has a shop full of air tanks being repaired. One day I asked why so many Huskys were sitting there. He laughed and showed me the size of the pistons. Then he showed me a piston from a "real" upright. The little one would probably need two more just to meet the size. He explained what Bill said and I had ran into this before. Look at the CFM instead of HP. CFM is doing the work.

john

Re: Advice needed...

#4

Re: Advice needed...

Neal_Addy

>Thanks, John and Bill, for taking the time to respond. You've answered a few of my questions and probably raised a few more. Some of this still goes over my head.

You say that some oil (or at least vapors) can be released through the outlet tube? That doesn't sound like a good thing for a carving tool (oil getting sprayed on the wood and all). Would oil-less would be better for this application or am I over-reacting?

BTW, the Powercrafter tool requires a 3/4 HP compressor or larger. 1.5-2.0 CFM at 45 PSI.

Re: Advice needed...

#5

Re: Advice needed...

Gordon Seto

>No expert here. The oil-less pancake compressors do run hot and noisy; and without oil lubrication, they do not hold up as well. A lot of air tools, PowerCrafter included, do need to add a drop or two of oil to the air line to lubricate the air turbine every few hours of operation. On some tools, you may even need to install an automatic air line lubricator to mix atomized oil in the compressed air to lubricate the tools.

You definitely don't want oil in the supply air for breathing. Other than that, oil from the compressor crank case won't be that critical to our use in workshop.

Gordon

Re: Advice needed...

#6

Re: Advice needed...

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>Do not read the listed HP rating, THEY LYE !

The companies will tell you a compressor is 5 HP, yet you plug it into a plug with an output of 20 amps @ 120 volt = 2400 watts / 750 = 3.2 HP max. and this does not cover motor start demand.

Roughly 750 watts is 1 HP. Amps times volts = watts

The only thing you care about is air output at a given pressure.

Look at output at 90 psi.

Put your vac system and air compressor in a kids playhouse outside your work area.

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Advice needed...

#7

Re: Advice needed...

Rick Allen

>Most all of the small compressors have a 50% duty cycle. If the tool you are interested in uses 2 CFM at 45 PSI. Then the compressor needs to be capable of at least 4 CFM at 45 PSI. The exhaust for the powercrafter is at the hose end of the tool. It is a good idea to get a exhaust sleeve for the tool so the exhaust exits well away from the business end.

BTW compressed air for cleaning sanding dust off of "stuff" is my primary use of my air compressor.

Good Luck with your quest.