We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>After all the insanity of getting projects done for Christmas, I finally had something come out right. So here it is. A coffee mug turned from walnut glued up using staves.
I hope you all had a Merry Christmas and best wishes for a properous New Year!
That stuck spur drive was the bane of my existence last week. I couldn't get a nut for it, and it wouldn't come out with the knock out bar.
I finally got fed up. I turned the lathe on and hack sawed the thing off. I now have the only solid spindle Powermatic on the planet. When things slow down, I'll have to take the headstock in and have it removed or replace the spindle but in the mean time, I'm done with it.
Almost all of my turning is done using a faceplate or chuck so it isn't slowing me down, but I would like to turn some pens in the future.
>Last time I checked for someone, a new spindle for a 3520A was about $140.00. To have a machine shop remove that taper and repair any damage to the spindle is likely to be more.
Hope to have the article on making an extractor nut done before too long.
>Didn't mean to cause you so much grief posting the picture.
Great looking mug.
Wonder if you could chuck a 5/16" bit in your tailstock and drill the shaft of the drive spur and then tap it with a 3/8 tap and then figure out a sleeve or nut on the shaft? How about a short pipe nipple and a 3/8" bolt with a heavy washer? Tighten the bolt and extract the remainer of the spur. You have very little to lose if you are planing to replace the shaft. I would try "everything". Soak it with penetrating oil like PB Blast. Heat the shaft with a heat gun or torch while applying pressure with the homemade extractor and then put in the knockout bar and whack it.
>I won't be applying heat. I will be purchasing a thicker piece of rod for a knock out bar in the future. If that works, great. If not, I'd rather pay the money and have the spindle replaced. I don't think it can take much more pounding before its in some way out of round.
Now that I've got the picture posting method down here's another angle.
Where did you get the hardware? Is it available commercially or did you have to pilfer a plastic and foam demon? I can think of several people for whom this would be a great gift.
>I have dealt with much the same thing on my big lathe. I had the spindle bored to fit the drive and dead center that came with the lathe. Little did I know, it was a different taper than what is now predominant. It is deeper, so the newer design drive center wouldn't seat. I quickly found a much better method, and began holding almost all of my lathe fixings in a chuck. I am seldom without one the Vicmark chucks on the spindle.
I cut one of my drive centers down in length, then found a good, heavy machined washer that stopped on the taper at just the right point, made sure it was true, and tapped it pretty hard with a persuader to lock the washer guide onto the taper. It leaves a substantial amount of shaft which fits the chuck jaws nicely, near the closed end of travel. The washer registers, as far as I can determine, perfectly flush against the face of the chuck.
I turn big chunks of wood on them, and absolutely no down side, that I can find. With the Vicmark, unless I'm doing long spindles, I use the same system.
On the ultimate outcome, I think you may be able to drive the old one out without removing the shaft. I'd be tempted to give a strong rod a hefty thump or two with a 4 or 8 pound hammer just before I'd decide to tear the lathe apart. I'd also back the strike up with a similarly sized hammer and a socket or piece of heavy walled pipe between the bearing surface and the hammer, to deaden the blow outside the radius of the pipe or socket. (Email me if this isn't clear.)
This technique allows the bulk of the force to hit the desired object without hurting the bearings and races nearly as much. No problem just having them bore the old one out if that doesn't break the friction. Heck, if you're a good hand with tools, you may be able to mill it out and knock out the pieces yourself. I've done similar work on a lot of shafts. It is careful work, and not too hard to ding up the taper.