Re: Tacky Watco
GaryG in MD
>Eliot,
You said you wiped it on, but you didn't say if you wiped it off. That's the key. Watco, as you undoubtedly know, is a penetrating oil, not a surface finish. Any excess needs to be wiped off before it gets overly tacky, or you end up with a mess. Watco does not dry overnight -- it's an oil with a tad of varnish and very little drier, if any. The drying time depends on temperature, but I rarely sand before a week goes by (for a final coat), and in these cooler winter temperatures, I often wait two weeks.
First of all, sanding to 1000 before you put on your first coat limits penetration. You will find that many people will recommend sanding only to 320 before putting on the Watco. You get a lot better penetration this way (assuming you want it, but, to a certain extent, that's the point of using an oil finish). On the other hand, sometimes you may not want a lot of penetration (it depends strongly on the wood and application) -- in that case, on porous woods, you may actually want to use a sanding sealer first -- or, I guess, use your method of sealing the pores by sanding to 1000 first.
How the Watco acts depends strongly on the porosity of the wood. Porous woods may need up to 6 coats, so the surface may appear (key word) to dry quickly. (I've got a piece of sycamore that just won't stop drinking it up.) On the other hand, I have a piece of red oak burl for which any more than 2 coats is a waste of time because no more soaks in. In this case, the surface is clearly "soft" for a number of days.
Watco doesn't gel as quickly as Waterlox, but I store my Watco upside-down in 8-oz plastic containers. That way, I never have a problem with gelling until they get quite low, and then I just top them up with fresh oil. No waste at all.
I just put the first coat on a newly-turned red oak tool handle last night. Love that stuff.
...Gary