Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Tacky Watco

Posts

Tacky Watco

#1

Tacky Watco

eliot d

>I often sand to about 1000 and then wipe on Watco oil. It appears to dry over night. Recently, I felt I wanted more finish on certain pieces , so I recoated several of them with the same can of Watco after they were dry -- weeks later. One is walnut, one cherry and one oak.Now, for some reason that I can't understand, after nearly a week, all three are still tacky. My shop is at quite normal room temperature. Any ideas?

Re: Tacky Watco

#2

Re: Tacky Watco

Nick Tuzzolino

>If you did't wipe off the successive coat(s) thoroughly, the oil won't penetrate as readily as the first coat and remain tacky. (I just happened to learn this the hard way).

Re: Tacky Watco

#3

Re: Tacky Watco

B. Leathers

>I had the same thing happen to me a while back and it was always towards the bottom of the can. Perhaps an oxidation occurred. Recently I've gone to Waterlox finishes topping off the can after use with bloxygen. Maybe others will offer assistance as I would like to go back at times to Watco too. B. Leathers

Re: Tacky Watco

#4

Re: Tacky Watco

Russ Fairfield

>I would look at the reasons for your problem in the following order - the finish in the can is too old, the finish on the wood is too thick, you applied the 2nd coat too soon, or the humidity in the atmosphere is too high.

Re: Tacky Watco

#5

Re: Tacky Watco

GaryG in MD

>Eliot,

You said you wiped it on, but you didn't say if you wiped it off. That's the key. Watco, as you undoubtedly know, is a penetrating oil, not a surface finish. Any excess needs to be wiped off before it gets overly tacky, or you end up with a mess. Watco does not dry overnight -- it's an oil with a tad of varnish and very little drier, if any. The drying time depends on temperature, but I rarely sand before a week goes by (for a final coat), and in these cooler winter temperatures, I often wait two weeks.

First of all, sanding to 1000 before you put on your first coat limits penetration. You will find that many people will recommend sanding only to 320 before putting on the Watco. You get a lot better penetration this way (assuming you want it, but, to a certain extent, that's the point of using an oil finish). On the other hand, sometimes you may not want a lot of penetration (it depends strongly on the wood and application) -- in that case, on porous woods, you may actually want to use a sanding sealer first -- or, I guess, use your method of sealing the pores by sanding to 1000 first.

How the Watco acts depends strongly on the porosity of the wood. Porous woods may need up to 6 coats, so the surface may appear (key word) to dry quickly. (I've got a piece of sycamore that just won't stop drinking it up.) On the other hand, I have a piece of red oak burl for which any more than 2 coats is a waste of time because no more soaks in. In this case, the surface is clearly "soft" for a number of days.

Watco doesn't gel as quickly as Waterlox, but I store my Watco upside-down in 8-oz plastic containers. That way, I never have a problem with gelling until they get quite low, and then I just top them up with fresh oil. No waste at all.

I just put the first coat on a newly-turned red oak tool handle last night. Love that stuff.

...Gary

Re: Tacky Watco

#6

Re: Tacky Watco

Cyril Griesbach

>Good information, Gary and it supports what I've been believing for quite a while. Thanks for the support.

Cyril

Re: Tacky Watco

#7

Re: Tacky Watco

bowlman

>OK everybody, listen up. Here's your Christmas present from the old fat guy himself. Been using WATCO and WATCO variants since before 1980. If it is tacky and you don't want it to be tacky, here's the secret (shhhhhhhhhhhh don't tell Jennifer or Molly or Carol) ......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................spray ..................................................................................................liberally ..............................................................................................................................................with ......................................................................................................WD 40 ................................................................................................................and wipe of firmly .............................................usually does the trick in just 1 application though I have been known to tack things up so much that 2 "de-tackings" were needed.

Ho HO HO

Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays, Happy Kwanza, Feliz Navidad, Joyeuz Noel, .... and to all a good night!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Dick "Santa Claus" Gerard

Re: Tacky Watco

#8

Re: Tacky Watco

eliot d

>Well, I see that I have some things to learn about Watco. I probably didn't wipe it off well enough. So I just went over them with mineral spirits, which seems to have gotten me back to where I was before I re-applied the finish. (Strange how beautiful the finish appears for a short time before the mineral spirits evaporates.Wish I could keep that look somehow!)

Re: Tacky Watco

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Tacky Watco

Keith Tompkins

>Eliot, you can usually wipe on a new coat of watco, which will begin to dissolve the old layer, then wipe it off thoroughly. I've never been too impressed with the watco oil, takes too long to build a decent finish. Mix it 50/50 with pure tung oil....much better.

Re: Tacky Watco

#10

Re: Tacky Watco

eliot d

>Keith, So why not pure tung oil?

Re: Tacky Watco

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: Tacky Watco

Keith Tompkins

>dHi Eliot, you can use pure tung oil, but it tends to dry more slowly. The watco has driers in it, the tung oil just adds more solids. Personally, I like pure tung oil as a finish.