Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

comments please: Sorby "slicer" blade

Posts

comments please: Sorby "slicer" blade

#1

comments please: Sorby "slicer" blade

GaryG in MD

>I don't have a "bowl saver" system yet, but, for starters, I like the idea of using a straight "slicer" tool (such as the Sorby) for saving some mirror frames off the backs of bowl blanks -- beats turning it into mulch.

I checked the Archives and couldn't find any info.

I'd like to hear from some of you who have actually used this tool.

How practical is it?

How catchy is it?

I have a Don Pencil Scorpion, so I would expect to use that handle/arm brace (assuming it fits). Is that a (good/bad) idea?

How hard to use is it?

Does it produce good results?

Is it useful or a waste of time?

TIA, Gary

Re: comments please: Sorby "slicer" blade

#2

Slicer" long"

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I've used one a few times.I bought a used Dennis Stewart set.Sorby bought thier design from him.Just think if it as a large parting tool. I've never used a bowl saver, but I think the bowl savers are better for coring. The slicer will grab if you don't widen its path with extra cuts. You also need to cut with the tip on ceter or it can grab. The blade only has a slight lateral bend, so the cut is mostly a cone. I did just use it recently though. I trued up the outside of a cherry burl with it. I removed a ring of wood from around the rough bowl blank instead of just shavings. I will have some pieces from that ring big enough to use for inserts in box lids or for bottle stoppers or Christmas ormanents. I found it easier to remove a ring from the outside of a blank than to core one out. It also functions as a large parting tool.It isn't a great value on a cost per cut basis, because I don't use it that often, and wouldn't really bother with it on wood that has plain grain.

Re: comments please: Sorby "slicer" blade

#3

Re: Slicer" long"

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>OOPs that should read "tip on center"

Re: comments please: Sorby "slicer" blade

#4

Re: comments please: Sorby "slicer" blade

George Van

>Gary, I have the McNaughton set which includes a straight tool. I use it when I want a fast core to speed up roughing and reduce shavings and I am not concerned about keeping the core or getting the �full sized� core out of the blank. It also works well when aligning the piths in a crotch and then dividing the crotch with the �parting� knife. I have always used it in the McNaughton gate on larger blanks where it is quite safe, I have not used it free hand in larger blanks where it could catch if it twisted. I almost always make more than one cut to work my way to the bottom to create some clearance. When I am coring something worth saving I used the curved blades.

Re: comments please: Sorby "slicer" blade

#5

ebd

Re: comments please: Sorby "slicer" blade

ebd

>I was going to buy the smallest straight McNaughton to use for exactly what you want to do. After some thought and emailing with some people here I decided to get the full set (smallest). I am very glad I did. The toolrest/gate makes getting the right angle extremely easy & reproducable as well as making the cut stable & clean. Having the full set allows so many more options that I think it is well worth it. One important thing that pointed me to McNaughton is the width of the kerf. All the other options indicate that you have to make 2 cuts to widen an already wide kerf. The McNaughton has the narrowest kerf and allows the cut to be made in a single pass.

Re: comments please: Sorby "slicer" blade

#6

thanks

GaryG in MD

>Thanks tek, George, and ebd; I appreciate the info. It gives me a lot of food for thought. ...Gary